Mobile operators are gradually waking up to the need to innovate, not just in their networks, tariffs and devices, but in services that could keep users loyal and help them survive in an over-the-top world. The problem is, even when a carrier comes up with a strong service or content offering, it is tied to their own network ‘ limited in geographic coverage, and in the types of devices that go with the rest of the business model. This is leading some cellcos to take the next step and separate their newly minted digital innovations from their networks, seeking consumer awareness throughout the population and, most importantly, abroad.
Some of these initiatives have been modest in scope, though important because they show the carriers trying to meet OTT players somewhere in the middle. T-Mobile USA and Telefonica Spain, among others, have introduced VoIP and messaging offerings which are network independent and could take the brand overseas.
Now operators are looking at more heavyweight ways to create a digital brand and use it to penetrate new territories without the cost and risk of building a network. Telefonica and SK Telecom are the most active, with their Telefonica Digital and SK Planet subsidiaries, which increasingly operate without reference to the actual networks. And this week alone has seen Orange launching a major initiative to accelerate its strategic expansion in Africa on the back of digital services, while Korea Telecom is to launch its music offering in 45 countries as the basis for a more fully fledged platform in future.
France Telecom has launched a new subsidiary called Orange Horizons, specifically to develop opportunities in countries where the group is not present as a major telco. There will be a heavy focus on Africa, already the primary target area for Orange’s mobile network expansions. The first project under the Horizon initiative is in South Africa and comprises an ecommerce service to sell communications devices, and an online content portal tailored for the country’s local audiences.
The aim of such launches, Orange says, is to leverage its brand and expand awareness and customer loyalty, as well as generating new revenue streams ‘ all without the need for significant investment and risk. As well as ecommerce services, other ideas include flexible solutions for travel or payments, or even full MVNOs.
The South African projects will go live in time for the Orange-sponsored Africa Cup of Nations soccer tournament. The orange.com.za brand will support online sales of devices and accessories, as well as providing content tailored for South African users, including news feeds, sports and audiovisual content. There will also be competitions and a destination for Orange subscribers, visiting from other countries, to top up their phones or purchase other services.
Orange has piloted some of these online activities in Italy, where it already has a mobile network, but is broadening its appeal to customers by building a web store and portal. Further ventures in Africa and Europe will follow during 2013, either to strengthen an existing operation or to establish the brand for the first time.
The carrier said the opportunity is huge if a firm does not have to invest in a full network operation in each country. Its footprint covers 10% of the world’s population, ‘leaving 6.2bn people who could potentially become customers through Orange Horizons activities’, as the official line went. As well as the online stores (and Orange would even consider bricks-and-mortar shops for devices too), likely projects include over-the-top country websites that harness existing assets. These include the group’s two pan-continental portals StarAfrica and, in Latin America, StarMedia, as well as content provider partners such as Deezer (the French music streaming service in which FT holds an 11% stake).
Such strategies will become increasingly common among large operators, aiming to generate more revenue and reach from existing assets as well as make sense of a stream of purchases of digital assets over recent years. Orange said in its statement: ‘In addition to the brand, the group enjoys considerable assets that will enable it to launch specific business projects outside its footprint without any need for significant investments. These assets include the group’s global buying power for telecoms devices and accessories; its expertise in setting up shops or online stores; as well as its R&D and marketing knowhow.’
Meanwhile, South Korean operators are famous for their advanced services, as they rise to the demands of one of the most sophisticated mobile user bases on earth. However, they have a population of only 50m to address and are increasingly looking to expand their reach abroad. In the latest such move, Korea Telecom (KT) is to launch its Genie K-pop music platform in 45 countries.
In general, the two leading Korean cellcos, KT and SK Telecom, have backed away from major M&A activity to expand their international reach, following some high profile failures such as SKT’s Helio venture with Earthlink in the US in 2006. Working with established carriers to launch their content and web services is seen as a safer route which taps into their specific expertise ‘ often in short supply at network partners.
SK Telecom has been the most advanced in this respect with its SK Planet, an autonomous division to develop and market a fully fledged, network independent mobile and web platform. Now KT is making similar moves. Genie K-pop as launched nine months ago in Korea only, and has had strong uptake, according to the carrier. Its hallmark feature is full track preview, which allows users to listen to tracks in full, up to three times each, for free.
KT also aims to broaden its exclusive content offerings, which cover tracks and associated multimedia items, to target non-Korean markets. The app will be made available from this week on six continents, initially for Android devices only. The 45 countries include the US, India, Singapore, France, Germany, Russia, Spain, Brazil and Australia. A second wave of launches will include Canada, the UK, South Africa, Italy, Japan and others.
Of course, music services will always exist in the shadow of iTunes, and rely heavily on deals with major labels. KT’s partner is KMP Holdings, a distributor which has deals with Korea’s seven biggest music publishers, though despite the success of PSY’s ‘Gangnam Style’ worldwide ‘ sparking new interest in Korean culture – Genie is likely to need broader alliances to build into a truly international offering. More realistically, KT is taking advantage of the PSY phenomenon to achieve some opportunistic uptake but will focus its more serious software strategy on more generic tools.
However, the carrier is always willing to be disruptive in its bid for market share. It has raised royalty fees for artists to 70% in Korea, where the usual rates are said to be ‘miserly’ (as little as three US cents per track). Genie offers labels the ability to set their own prices and to run discounts and promotions.
It will certainly have been learning lessons from its arch-rival’s SK Planet venture, which aims to turn the cellco into a mobile software platform business independent of its own network, creating Google-style businesses in various countries, often in alliance with mobile operators, though the structure could also be entirely over-the-top.
In June 2011, SKT spun off its existing platforms business to give its content activities greater focus and autonomy, and dubbed the unit, later called SK Planet, its ‘next generation growth driver’. It is building one of the most advanced operator controlled applications and cloud platforms in the world, and has started to work with carriers outside Korea to get its services into their systems. The eventual aim is to reduce its reliance on conventional mobile services in its advanced but saturated homeland, and create an international content brand divorced from network ownership.
The new division offers services such as video calling, advertising platforms, mobile TV, and multiscreen content spanning phones, tablets and set-top boxes. It will remain wholly owned by SKT. In 2010, SKT said it would invest almost $1bn over three years in these efforts and even before unveiling Planet, it had been putting out international feelers for its ‘T’ content brand, with joint development initiatives with regional majors such as NTT Docomo in Japan and China Mobile. The latter will even run a ‘T’-branded store within its Android apps store, indicating the perceived value of SKT’s content to a cellco which usually guards its own branding fiercely.
SK Planet’s advantage ‘ like similar units from peer group operators like Telefonica ‘ is that it can make decisions more quickly and respond to mobile and multiscreen market trends, unhampered by the agenda of the ‘legacy’ network business. However, pitching new brands, however powerful in their home market, on a global basis is tough, especially in the mobile world where the platforms of Apple, Google, Amazon and even Microsoft have sway. And SKT’s track record is not strong ‘ when it partnered with Earthlink to create the US MVNO Helio, it came with an ambitious, and then revolutionary, strategy ‘ to build its brand and revenues around content rather than service pricing or devices. However, while this approach has gathered far more respect since Helio faltered and was acquired by Virgin Mobile (now Sprint), it has still had very little commercial impact on operators’ fortunes outside the major east Asian economies.
SK Planet’s revenues were KRW261bn ($237m) in 2011 and are estimated to be KRW330bn ($300m) in 2012. Elements include the T Store apps store, T Map, the Viki service to add multilingual captions to videos, and the HopPin mobile social media offering. The unit’s CEO Seo Jin-woo said at launch: ‘This sector is very young. Google, Microsoft, Apple and Yahoo, none of them have continued to be the absolute power for longer than 10 years ‘ Only those continually seeking change and innovation can survive in this industry.’ He aims to make SK Planet the top platform provider in Asia by 2016 ‘ T Store is already the biggest local app store, with 9.6m users nationwide, creating KRW8.6bn ($7.8m) in monthly transactions. ‘We succeeded in the Korean market, but it was in a walled garden. SK Planet is the new challenge toward the global market, Son added. T Store already has partnerships with China Mobile, Lenovo and Gree of Japan.