Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 August 2003

Operators shift from data to voice in quest for ROI on 3G networks

T-Mobile denied reports that circulated this week that it would launch commercial 3G services in the UK before the end of the year. It said it still plans to roll out its 3G network in the UK and Germany this year but will give no dates for customer trials.

This leaves Hutchison 3G as the only 3G operator in the UK and one of a small handful in Europe as operators still grapple with handset and roaming problems with the W-CDMA standard mandated by the European Commission.

Not that getting to market early is necessarily an advantage. The delays in 3G have forced operators to meet the rising demand for multimedia services such as photomessaging using 2.5G networks such as GPRS. For most consumers, these are more than adequate so, as Hutchison has found, the willingness to pay more for a 3G service is low.

This has driven Hutchison to try to get some return on its 3G investment by attracting customers with cheaper voice calls. It has had some success ‘ this week it said it had reached 155,000 subscribers in the UK and about 500,000 worldwide, though it still seems touch and go to hit its target of 1m users by the end of the year.

Cheap voice plans may be the reverse of the data-driven 3G dream, but now Vodafone has said that it also plans to use its 3G services, when they go live, to steal share in the voice calls market from the fixed line carriers.

This is realistic because 3G networks are more efficient and cheaper to operate than GSM and there is plenty of spare capacity. A 3G network at full call volume can carry traffic for 25% of the cost on a GSM system. This was one factor behind the carriers’ willingness to pay inflated sums for their 3G licenses and to build the systems ‘ they believed they could not only launch highly priced, premium services on these networks, but also that the margin on these would be even better than on GSM.

Now they are faced with the specter of the mass market sticking to GSM and GPRS for its multimedia needs, and then moving directly to 4G or to faster WLan/WMan services as those needs start to exhaust current technology, in several years’ time. The fallback option, less profitable, but better than nothing, is to go after the fixed line voice market.

Mobile operators with 3G networks have, for the first time, the potential to price match their wired counterparts (or parents, in many cases) on voice and still make a reasonable margin. This may prove a powerful lure to otherwise disinterested customers to move to 3G, and it may then be possible to sell the high end multimedia offerings on the back of that. Before 3G operator shareholders get too excited however, there are new technologies with which the wired carriers can bite back, notably the advent of IP-based voice over WLan handsets, which BT will offer next year. And before 3G will be widely adopted for voice, especially by businesses, it will need to solve the problems with bulky handsets, poor battery life and ‘ particularly critical for voice ‘ patchy coverage and frequently dropped calls.