One of the most important issues in the evolution of the mobile internet is how the balance of power will pan out between operators, device makers, and internet companies like Google. All are trying to make their brands, user interfaces and revenue models the dominant ones in mobile web services, but so far many of the big headlines have come from outside the traditional cellcos. Apple iPhone/iTunes, Nokia Ovi and open Symbian, Google Android ‘ all these are high profile early names in the mobile web, and threaten to reduce the carrier’s role to that of a bitpipe. But now the operators are biting back. While some, like 3, are choosing to work with the internet brands, many are determined to grab the spotlight, and the control of the revenue split, for themselves, with the European majors leading the way. T-Mobile is said to be developing a software store similar to Apple’s AppStore or the retail channels planned for Ovi; and Vodafone and O2 are stepping up the challenge to iTunes in the mobile music and video sectors.
In Europe, T-Mobile has gained a significant profile for its Web ‘n’ Walk internet offerings but its bid to open its platform to developers will start with its US operation, according to sources. The operator is looking to steal some momentum from Apple, Nokia and the internet retailers by launching its own store, encouraging developers to create applications for its web-enabled handsets, and sharing the revenue Apple-style. To support this, it would open up a unified platform for all its handsets. This would be a big departure for T-Mobile, which has always made mobile applications available through its deck, which varies depending on the device and the operating system.
The success of Apple’s AppStore (see separate item) is clearly attracting the operators to grab a share of the spoils while they still have the chance of a major position in the mobile internet value chain. T-Mobile’s reported move could well spark similar ventures by other operators, in the biggest carrier bid to control mobile web applications since NTT DoCoMo unleashed its iMode service on Japan. One reason for iMode’s success in its native country was the generous share of revenues it granted to developers (though by the time it was launched in other territories, this differentiation had been lost). T-Mobile should bear the iMode experience in mind, and appreciate that generosity to developers will be the main way to populate its store quickly and take on the mighty brand of Apple ‘ whose store, despite popularity with consumers, is still criticized by some programmers for being over-controlled and mean with the revenue split.
The advantage T-Mobile, and other large operators, will also have over Apple is their market reach. T-Mobile has 30m subscribers in the US alone, three times the number of iPhones that are expected to be in use by the end of this year.
As yet, there are no hints of the revenue model that T-Mobile might adopt ‘ except that it will share proceeds with developers – but it seems that the projected service would cover all the web handsets and other devices that the cellco offers, or will introduce in future. It would therefore welcome apps for all the supported operating systems and software frameworks ‘ Windows Mobile, Java, Linux, Symbian (especially in Europe), the Sidekick, and future Android devices (T-Mobile hopes to launch one early in 2009).
On its devPartner site, T-Mobile is advertising for software partners. ‘T-Mobile is seeking innovative mobile web content to provide our customers with a richer, fuller mobile internet experience,’ it says. ‘If you are a skilled and creative mobile web content developer, we would like to evaluate having you help deliver a more compelling mobile web experience to our customers.’
In its home country of Germany, the issue will be more complicated for T-Mobile, since it is the carrier partner for the iPhone there and will gain its own share of revenues from the uptake of iPhone-based services like AppStore and iTunes. This is the dilemma that most major carriers will face, and most are, at least until the picture becomes clearer, taking a dual-pronged approach, promoting their own-branded services but also offering easy access to any third party application or store that attracts sufficient user demand. Some operators are trying to keep the two markets separate ‘ Orange and T-Mobile have been trying to support strong Nokia services like mobile search and maps while steering clear of its Ovi portal, which can provide content and apps direct to the consumer as easily as via the cellco front door. Others, like Vodafone, have embraced Ovi on certain handsets or user bases, but are promoting their own alternatives to different groups.
Nowhere is this complex situation clearer than in the rapidly growing market for mobile music and video. This sector is becoming hyper-competitive and the UK is one of the biggest battlegrounds for the fight against iTunes. As Microsoft apparently considers teaming up with Nokia to boost Zune (see inset), the operators are trying to grab a bigger piece of the action. This week, Vodafone and O2 will both announce new offerings, and both now provide multiple mobile music services, giving consumers wide choices but probably confusing them too.
Vodafone already offers MusicStation, mainly on midrange handsets, and Nokia MusicStore on high end Nokia phones, providing one-click access and the distinctive user interface. On Thursday it will add Vodafone Music, which was co-developed with streaming supremo RealNetworks and is already used by Verizon Wireless, Vodafone’s US joint venture. MusicStation, by contrast, is a managed service provided by Omnifone, and was launched late last year, in the same week as Nokia unveiled MusicStore. How can all these options appeal to customers and make money? And these three are all coming from one carrier ‘ it is likely that all the main UK cellcos will also launch multiple music brands, not to mention those available directly from the internet or marketed directly by device makers like Sony Ericsson.
So, O2 ‘ which, of course, headlines its media marketing with the iPhone and iTunes – now has a new offering for non-iPhone customers, developed with Sony BMG Music Entertainment. The partners claim their new music store is the first direct collaboration between a major record label and major operator, with no handset maker or white label service provider in between. The mobile internet site, MyPlay, will be available exclusively through the O2 Active portal, and is powered by multimedia publishing platform GoMedia from Momac.
MyPlay provides music videos, full track audio and realtones via artist microsites. Videos are priced at £1.50, realtones at £3.50 and music tracks at 99p. The service will be available on 350 handsets to both prepaid and contract customers, but has a reduced catalog with only a handful of artists involved in the scheme at launch. ‘The aim of MyPlay is not to provide a large library of tracks but to provide in-depth artist content which their fans can access directly,’ an O2 spokesman told The Times.
By contrast, Vodafone Music is on fewer phones (11 models within the Vodafone Live! portal) but has a wider track listing, and is more directly competitive with iTunes (and other Vodafone offerings ‘ O2 is doing a better job of segmentation to appeal to different types of music lovers and push different handsets, though of course it does also boast its Napster platform, with 5m tracks).
Vodafone claims, however, that Musicstation and its new offering will be complementary rather than eating each other’s lunch (and Nokia MusicStore is specific to certain high end phones like the N95). The main difference in Vodafone Music is a fluid user interface, which has definite echoes of iTunes and allows users to browse and buy music, as well as listen to a 30-second clip beforehand. Singles cost 99p and albums £7.99 with no hidden data charges. A more important difference is that users get to keep the tracks, whereas MusicStation is a subscription service rather than a store, and tracks are lost once consumers cease subscribing.
Finally, Vodafone has announced Soundbites, developed with music TV station MTV (also a participant in the RealNetworks platform). Soundbites features interviews with stars, behind the scenes clips at concerts, fantasy band games and other video content.
Vodafone Soundbites will be available in seven languages on MTV in Germany, Hungary, the Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Spain, Turkey, the UK and Ireland, Australia, New Zealand and on the MTV European feed, covering 16 countries.
Nokia may support Zune:
We all know that mobile music is THE smartphone application of 2008, and most of the handset makers and operators are chasing music lovers, and the appeal of iPhone/iTunes is prompting some unlikely partnerships from those looking to dethrone it. None more improbable than Nokia with Microsoft Zune, but that is the anti-Apple alliance most widely rumored last week ‘ just as Apple is said to be developing a ‘nano’ iPhone to spread its net to more budget conscious and pay-as-you-go consumers.
Microsoft has always been cagey about a possible phone version of its Zune media player, though this would be a logical move as other device makers start to put a cellular link into their star products ‘ notably Sony with the PSP. One problem for Microsoft would be that the non-Windows Zune might muddy its strategy in the handset market where it wants to push Windows Mobile ‘ though Zune might also be better at Windows at taking MS out of its mobile enterprise sector. In the short term at least, it seems more likely that Zune content and services will be more tightly integrated with Windows Mobile phones and also, possibly, Nokia devices. This could pave the way for Microsoft dumping Zune devices altogether and focusing on multiplatform music services instead.
Reportedly, Microsoft is looking to expand Zune content to include more video, and to extend it to new hardware platforms, Windows and even non-MS. Nokia would clearly be the biggest catch because of its huge mobile market share and its success in the musicphone sector, but how would Zune sit with Nokia’s own aggressive efforts around its MusicStore brand and its Comes With Music offering? If the two merged, one or other giant would lose an important brand. This is inconceivable for Nokia, given the strategic importance it has attached to its music services, and while Microsoft would gain market share and revenue if available on the world’s most used mobile platform, this would be a limited victory without the Zune brand.
Perhaps the most likely scenario is an uneasy alliance against Apple, with Nokia loading Zune Marketplace access on certain handsets that are not sufficiently premium to be optimized for MusicStore. It has similar two-tiered agreements with some operators ‘ Vodafone, for instance, offers MusicStore as its high end music offering but its own music shop on midrange handsets, even Nokia models. Or Zune Marketplace could just be one among many planned third party options within Nokia’s Ovi portal.
Microsoft, once Nokia’s sworn enemy, has already collaborated with the handset giant on mobile services. Two years ago it brought Windows Live, Live Search and Live Messenger, plus Hotmail, to Nokia platforms, though this partnership has had limited impact, but did show Microsoft’s new willingness to put its applications on non-Windows operating systems in the quest for market share.
Initially released in November 2006, Zune is a brand of digital media players and services that includes players, client software, and the Zune Marketplace online music and video store. It will come under new pressure if Apple does launch a nano iPhone in time for Christmas. Although some have dismissed the reports as a PR stunt by UK iPhone carrier O2, there would be logic in extending the iPhone’s reach to customers with lower spending power, or operators with less willingness to support heavy subsidies. Apple has already sacrificed exclusivity and high prices for market share by slashing prices and expanding distribution for the 3G iPhone. A nano model would enable it to preserve the core product’s remaining margins and desirability while offering a cheaper, simpler option that would drive increased uptake of iTunes and Apple applications.