The European mobile operators are starting to consolidate as scale becomes vital to remain competitive in a saturating market. Now the trend is affecting even the rising breed of MVNOs (Mobile Virtual Network Operators) which lease capacity on the cellcos’ networks to launch own-branded services. A trade association called the MVNO Global initiative has announced a plan to consolidate some existing MVNOs to create a pan-European system.
This could launch under a common brand, or engage in collective leasing and handset purchase negotiations to provide a more cost effective platform for a variety of different localized access brands. It would also provide a common roaming mechanism to support a pan-European offering and a centralized service delivery and administration platform. It is not clear whether it would lease capacity from just one operator, rather like the combined MVNO deal formed by the US cablecos with Sprint Nextel.
The target market is medium and high-end business and residential users, other MVNOs and service and content providers aiming to start European operations on the company’s technical platform. As MVNOs move from being purely cost cutters to offering high value business and consumer applications, the ability to deliver these cost effectively will be vital to be able to compete with the established carriers.
The new body says: ‘the key principle behind the initiative to merge existing MVNOs is to create shareholder value over and above that of the sum of the companies. This rationale is particularly alluring to existing MVNOs operating in tough mobile markets like Denmark and Finland. The companies should come together to benefit from economies of scale, thus reducing duplicate departments or operations, lowering the costs of the company and increasing profit. The companies in addition benefit from synergy: better use of complementary resources, a centralized service platform and the value of a global brand name.’
As MVNOs become more common, consolidation will occur, often through the network owners buying up their virtual rivals. This can be a powerful tactic for a major cellco ‘ letting an MVNO use its brand strength to attract a customer base, perhaps in a market that the network owner had failed to penetrate; commanding leasing fees for the network in the meantime; and then acquiring it once the user base has been built. In Finland, Elisa has bought MVNO Saunalahti, while TeliaSonera of Sweden and Finland acquired two Norwegian virtual operators, Sense and Chess. Scandinavia, which was a pioneer of the MVNO model, is also a good indicator of trends that will start to affect other territories where the concept is less established.
For instance, the history of MVNO acquisitions in Scandinavia indicates the rising value of these companies. When TDC of Denmark bought Telmore in January 2004 it paid €88 per subscriber, while Elisa paid €680 per sub and TeliaSonera €563, in markets with similar mobile potential. There is no longer such a gulf in the purchase price for an MVNO compared with a network owner ‘ TeliaSonera paid €1,000 per user recently to buy Orange Denmark, not even twice what it will pay for Chess and Sense, even though with Orange it gains spectrum licenses and network.