Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 February 2013

Patent licensing firms rethink their revenue model and look beyond handsets

The wireless IPR landscape has changed dramatically since the advent of the smartphone. When the handset was a dumber creature, there were relatively few companies with significant patents in the device, most of them related to the mobile connection. This cosy group traded IPR within its ranks and some players ‘ like Qualcomm and InterDigital ‘ were able to make a standalone business out of their patents. Once the cellphone evolved into a fully fledged computer, there were far more IPR stakeholders fighting for competitive advantage and as well as sparking the lawsuits which have dogged the industry over the past couple of years, this is also prompting major patent holders to change their business models.

The Samsung-Apple dispute highlights the stand-off between owners of software patents and the old-fashioned kind related to wireless standards. With the entry of PC, software and open source technologies into the mobile mix, there are not only more IPR owners, but more licensing processes. The traditional bilateral agreement has been joined by the patent pool (as in MPEG technologies) and the open source initiatives. So not only do major firms fight over whether and how they should license one another’s IPR, but also over whether licensing should exist at all ‘ hence Google’s bid to promote open source platforms like Linux and VP9 (albeit in versions it controls, Android and WebM), over paid-for licences like MPEG LA’s H.264 and H.265.

All this has arguably made essential wireless IPR less of an asset than it was a decade ago. Owners have less freedom of action in setting fees and chasing infringers than companies with non-essential IPR, since the fundamental patents are increasingly subjected by regulatory bodies and law courts to the ‘Frand’ (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) test on licensing practices. And essential patents occupy a far smaller proportion of a device’s total IPR bill, even as average selling prices fall, so the pot has to be shared between a far larger number of inventors. Add to that the rising legal costs of fighting off actions from rivals, antitrust bodies and the growing band of wireless patent trolls, and the landscape looks rather bleak.

This is not to say that patents are not still hugely valuable, as sources of revenue, bargaining power and influence over industry developments. But those firms for which IPR has been a significant part of the business model need to think more flexibly and smartly these days. So we see most of the big names stepping up their activities both in developing new technologies and then licensing the resulting IPR, but in a more multifaceted way than in the 2G/3G era. The key tactics are:

Make more out of less:

Large wireless IPR holders, such as Ericsson, Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia, have pledged to chase revenues more aggressively and have hired executives dedicated to that task, rather than seeing patents mainly as a bargaining chip. And while there is intense pressure on the per-device price that can be charged for a patent, given falling ASPs and greater IPR content, that can be offset by the sheer rise in device numbers. This is seen at Qualcomm, which will not have the same IPR stranglehold in LTE that it had in CDMA, but is still enjoying steady growth in licensing revenues on the back of smartphone growth.

Balance IPR and open source:

With the growing importance of free and open source approaches in the mobile world, most companies want to influence the open platforms and work with them. However, even the champions of openness, like Google, keep a few juicy patents back to improve their balance of power with rivals and generate revenues and control. That balancing act was clearly seen last year at Qualcomm, which reorganized to separate its open source activities from its licensing model.

Generate multiple revenue streams from inventions:

Patent aggregators and trolls are on the rise, but for those firms whose IPR arises mainly from their own inventions, it is important to maximize the returns on the R&D effort. Qualcomm has always turned the bulk of its inventions into commercial products, but now even companies focused mainly on licensing, like InterDigital, are stepping up their efforts to turn innovations into products which they, or partners, can bring to market.

Move beyond the handset:

For IPR power and revenue, the handset used to be the goose that laid the golden egg. No longer ‘ modern patent giants need to ensure their innovations are applicable to all kinds of wireless technologies, including the internet of things.

All these tactics are seen, to a greater or lesser extent, at InterDigital. A major holder of essential IPR in the 3GPP standards, over the past year or so, has mainly been in the headlines for attempts to sell some or all of its huge portfolio (after the market had experienced something of a glut, with the sales of the IPR mountains of Nortel and Motorola, among others); and for various legal battles, notably its complaint at the US International Trade Commission (ITC) against Samsung, Nokia, ZTE, Huawei and other phonemakers. The ITC said this week that it would launch a formal investigation into the allegations, but in the meantime, the company is rebalancing its business significantly.

The heart of the business remains the R&D effort, which centers on a Labs unit with 200 engineers headed up by Jim Nolan. Traditionally, the inventions have mainly been harnessed for licensing revenues, which have historically accounted for around 90% of the total ‘ in contrast with Qualcomm, for instance, whose licensing revenues were 43% of the total in Q412, though far higher in profits terms. While licensing will remain significant, now the aim is also to generate business in consultancy-based R&D and in launching commercial products, directly or, more probably, via a partner.

The company creates 95% of its patents through inhouse developments so it has always had the potential to commercialize them ‘ it had a fabless modem business until a couple of years ago, for instance – but this business has been ‘bumpy’ and inconsistent, according to Nolan. ‘The goal now is to make consultancy and development revenues more consistent,’ he said. ‘Partners are essential. Other companies will be better at products because that needs scale, a certain mindset ….’.

This thinking was seen in an alliance announced at the turn of the year with Sony, a company which certainly has scale and the product mindset, but has clear gaps in its wireless knowhow. The two companies have formed a joint venture called Convida Wireless, to which both will contribute funding and resources for M2M R&D and platform development. This will then be carried out by the InterDigital Solutions unit. Stephens Capital Partners will be a minority investor in Convida Wireless. The pact also includes a patent licence from InterDigital for Sony’s 3G and 4G products.

That agreement highlights how InterDigital would like to boost its solutions division, creating deals with short to medium term commercial potential, centered on its R&D activities. The Sony work, for instance, will draw on InterDigital’s existing M2M research, which include projects for a services delivery platform and standards work with Europe’s ETSI body.

The Sony deal also indicates how the attempts to sell chunks of the IPR portfolio must have focused the mind at InterDigital, forcing it to think deeply about where its skills lay, and to which technologies those skills should be applied, to generate new revenue streams just over the horizon. The exercise of trimming the patents base seems to have been helpful in concentrating the corporate mind on the key areas. Some collections were sold, notably about 1,700 patents to Intel in June (for $375m, indicating that patents sales are, in the current environment of horse trading, a serious revenue stream in their own right, though of course a one-time one). The portfolio is now ‘rightsized’ and ‘refreshed’ according to Nolan, and aligned with the areas where the company believes growth will be both in technology development and licensing. ‘A couple of years back we wanted to know what the ‘next G’ would be, and that would drive the technologies we would develop,’ he commented.

That thought process means taking a technology emerging into the mainstream and looking at ways to commercialize it in future, far beyond one or two applications ‘ thus maximizing the reach of any inventions, both in patent licensing and partnership terms. So InterDigital is deeply interested in HetNet, but not in a limited sense of interconnecting a variety of mobile cells and devices, but applying it more broadly to integration of personal area networks, sensors and even body area networks, all on one device. In turn, that means expanding beyond plumbing and into the user experience, taking on the risk of getting too far from core expertise.

To mitigate that risk, the firm is taking a route which is increasingly common in the mobile space, setting up a division ‘ Innovation Partners – to identify and invest in start-ups whose innovations will complement the main platforms and may generate new business streams in future. While large vendors have carried out this process for years through their venture funds and incubators, such outfits are proliferating now, as seen at Telefonica Digital, which said last month it planned to invest in 1,000 start-ups, and the newly expanded Samsung innovation funds.

It has emerged from all this soul searching with four main areas of technology focus, for all three of its activities ‘ licensing; development/consulting; and innovation partners, all held together by the Labs. The selected areas all relate to the evolution of the ‘network of networks’ in which there is seamless connectivity between huge numbers of different protocols, device types and spectrum bands, right out to the internet of things. The chosen four are bandwidth management and smart access; dynamic spectrum management; M2M; and advanced video research. In all four, there should be near term opportunities to bring products to market, generally through alliances, but also a development path stretching well into the future. Many engineers are already working on technologies which will be relevant not to LTE-Advanced but to its successors, ‘LTE-B’ and ‘LTE-C’, says Nolan.

In all four areas it will work with standards bodies where it can, for the influence and licensing potential that can bring ‘ it has activities in ETSI and OneM2M on the internet of things side, and with HEVC for video research. And it will be looking for new partnerships to add to the existing ones with Sony and, in the white spaces segment, Spectrum Bridge and Ittiam.

Even companies for which licensing is not a major component of total revenues are looking to boost their patent portfolios, for offensive and defensive reasons, and to focus R&D resources on technologies where IPR will be a crucial asset in future. Samsung, battered by its legal battles with Apple, is revamping its activities in R&D, and in backing promising start-ups, and moving far more of those efforts out of its Korean homeland and to IP/computing centers of excellence like Silicon Valley.

Its latest move is to set up a new venture capital fund, which will provide $100m in seed funding for component start-ups, as the Korean giant looks for the next big thing in mobile, cloud and M2M sectors, in particular. The company also announced that it had increased its US-based corporate venture fund to $1bn and opened a new office in Silicon Valley to manage and coordinate its efforts to invest in and work with start-ups.

It believes funding is heavily focused on software and web services these days, and it is harder for semiconductor innovators, with their higher risk and longer periods of return, to get off the ground. However, it is increasingly important for Samsung to stay ahead of the latest advances in its various chip and memory businesses, both for internal use by its mobile division and for the merchant market.

“Silicon Valley is the epicenter of disruptive forces, and we want to make sure we are part of it,’ said Young Sohn, who will head up the new Strategy and Innovation Center. ‘A number of investors are running away from basic science, semiconductors, materials and display infrastructure, but we want to make sure those things are well supported. We are very proud of being very patient and oriented on physics and materials because if you solve those issues you can have tremendous leadership long term.’

As well as the US center, which is currently hiring to expand its 100-strong team, Sohn’s organization has an office in Israel and plans to open other R&D hubs around the world, with locations reported to include Cambridge, UK and other US cities such as Boston and Austin, Texas.

The group is specifically focused on companies with innovations that Samsung could leverage in the short to medium term, rather than on incubation or financial investment per se. It will also take a role in identifying acquisition targets and aims to provide a bridge between Samsung’s partners and activities round the world, with its massive R&D and acquisition resources in its native Korea.

The new $100m Samsung Catalyst Fund will focus on seed investments in component technologies targeted at high growth sectors such as cloud infrastructure, mobile security, e-health, next-generation user interfaces, and the internet of things. It will be headed by Shankar Chandran, previously general partner at Panoroma Ventures, who will report to Sohn. Sohn himself spent a decade at Intel and has also headed up Agilent and Quantum. Most recently he was CEO of communications chip start-up Inphi, which was funded by Samsung and went public in 2010.

The larger Samsung Ventures fund did 20 deals worth $160m in total last year, Sohn said. “Every year we add more money to the venture fund, and it is probably one of the top three corporate venture funds in America now,” he said. Samsung is also creating another Silicon Valley center, this one based in Palo Alto and focused on content and media developments.

Patent trolls:

Technology developers may want to generate product as well as licensing revenues from their inventions, but there is a counter-trend that sees patent trolls ‘ aggregators which do not commercialize their IPR and in most cases have not created it inhouse ‘ stepping up their often destructive efforts.

In 2012, for the first time ever, patent trolls were behind more than half of IPR lawsuits filed in the US. They initiated 62% of suits filed up to December 1 last year, according to a study by Colleen Chien, a law professor at University of California. Although this was conducted across various industries, the report highlights the rising concern in the wireless sector about the patent arms races, often led by trolls, which threatens to add to product costs and involve vendors in costly legal battles. In 2011, 45% of patent lawsuits were filed by aggregators, up from 29% in 2010. In 2012, 61% of defendants had been sued by a licensing firm which had previously filed suit eight or more times.

All this reflects the growing aggression of some IPR holders as the value of patents, especially in wireless, rises.

Meanwhile, last May Google filed a complaint at the European Commission and the US FTC, accusing Nokia and Microsoft of hiding behind patent trolls. This was brought into the spotlight by a case brought by MobileMedia against Google, HTC, RIM and Apple (which resulted in a victory against Apple last fall), using patents transferred by Nokia and Sony. Google’s complaint alleges that its two rivals were funding trolls in order to weaken Android’s position and deter vendors from using it, because of the fear of high licensing fees or litigation. “Nokia and Microsoft are colluding to raise the costs of mobile devices for consumers, creating patent trolls that sidestep promises both companies have made,” Google said in a statement at the time. “They should be held accountable, and we hope our complaint spurs others to look into these practices.”

One transaction which had caught Google’s attention was the acquisition of 2,000 wireless patents and applications from Nokia by Canadian licensing firm Mosaid, in September 2011. Mosaid is sharing the revenue from the IPR with Nokia and its key partner Microsoft. Nokia also sold 450 patents and patent applications to Sisvel in January.