Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

Patent wars shift to wider range of mobile IPR holders

The latest patents lawsuits involve some different players from last year’s Apple/Android showdowns, but many of the issues remain the same. These include the rising influence of trolls, and the willingness of some major vendors to behave as trolls, in the sense of asserting patents which are not relevant to their actual products; whether firms with standards-essential patents are misusing the power that IPR brings them, with unfair licensing terms or charges; and whether holders of those essential patents should be allowed to use injunctions as threats.

These were all raised when Samsung responded to a lawsuit filed by Ericsson in November, hurling its own complaint at the Swedish vendor in the Eastern District of Texas. Ericsson had accused the Korean firm of patent infringement in both the Texas court and the International Trade Commission after the two rivals failed to reach an agreement over renewing certain licensing deals. In December, Samsung retaliated by filing a complaint with the ITC, citing the licensing deals and seven patent claims, mainly related to LTE. Now it has added two Texas lawsuits to its attacks, one based on the same alleged IPR violations as in the ITC complaint and the other on eight other patents.

The new group of patents cited relates to a wide range of technologies including CMOS memory, semiconductors and various techniques for transmitting and receiving wireless communications. Samsung is also claiming breach of contract, accusing Ericsson of failing to respect FRAND (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) guidelines in their licensing deal. FRAND issues are increasingly commonly dragged into legal actions where the defendant has significant IPR that is essential to standards, as Ericsson does.

Some of the Ericsson patents involved relate to handset technologies ‘ the firm retained its intellectual property rights even after selling its stake in smartphone maker Sony Ericsson to its Japanese partner. In addition, Samsung is becoming a viable competitor in the infrastructure space with its rising success in LTE networks and some of the IPR it cites relate to base station platforms.

Samsung uses aggressive language in its filings, and basically accuses its Swedish rival of behaving like a patent troll because it no longer has handsets, but still asserts the IPR. ‘Ericsson has recently jettisoned its mobile phone business and it now feels unhinged as a non-practicing entity in the mobile phone market to extort vastly unreasonable and discriminatory licence fees from Samsung under threat of product exclusion … Ericsson’s misguided actions epitomize the patent ‘hold-up’ problem that has been the recent subject of wide discussion within standard setting organizations and other authorities around the globe.”

Huawei and ZTE are also at one another’s throats over patents, and have seen mixed results in a court in Mannheim, Germany, increasingly one of the key centers of the current IPR wars.

As the two Chinese firms build up their patents power bases, they are coming into conflict with various rivals, including each other. In Germany, Huawei has won a suit it filed against its compatriot, although it lost another, related dispute.

The Mannheim court dismissed Huawei’s accusation that ZTE infringed on its LTE terminal patents, but upheld another complaint concerning a ‘key derivation function’ patent. ZTE has confirmed that it will appeal against that ruling.

Huawei has won a provisional injunction against sales of LTE base stations by ZTE in Germany as a result of the latter ruling. The patent at issue describes a way to ensure smooth handover of a signal in an LTE system, reducing the call drop rate. However, the injunction is ‘not final and it is not self-executing’ If Huawei wants to enforce the ban immediately, it will have to pay a bond of $1.3m in case the decision is later reversed on appeal. But if Huawei does go ahead, ZTE will have to pay fines for every violation.

Huawei has also launched several other patent lawsuits against ZTE in Germany, France and Hungary, while ZTE has filed 18 complaints against Huawei in Europe and China, concerning a portfolio of IPR for LTE infrastructure, core networks and terminals.

Of the five lawsuits brought in Germany, the Europe Patent Bureau has already declared two of the patents invalid. ZTE will continue to follow the other cases and their invalidation claims. In addition, a rotator data card patent at the heart of the French lawsuit has been declared invalid in China and Germany.

Also in Mannheim, Nokia has won a patent lawsuit against HTC and secured a sales injunction, subject to posting a $6.5m bond with the court first. But the infringing devices, the Wildfire S, Desire S and Rhyme, are no longer sold in the country, making the ban academic. The dispute centered on a power saving feature found in Qualcomm supplied chips, which HTC argued was ‘trivial’ and could easily be disabled. Nokia is asserting the same patent (EP0673175) in separate lawsuits in the UK and USA.