Every so often a device appears on the market that, either in perception or reality, sets new benchmarks and sparks a flurry of innovation from the vendors it threatens. Motorola set everybody chasing the superslim handset with the initial impact of RAZR, and now of course the catalyst is the Apple iPhone, which is spurring a rush by nearly all the phonemakers to bring forward roll-out plans for touchscreen, internet-oriented devices ‘ or to promote more effectively those they already had in the market. LG has seized the opportunity most dynamically, not just with its series of innovative launches, but also the way it is working with operators and using their fear of the iPhone to achieve a stronger position for itself in its targeted western markets. Of course all eyes are on Nokia, which is not only promising a touchscreen handset with advanced haptics next month, but now appears to be borrowing ideas from a device that has cult status in the US, the Sidekick. All this is about far more than creating new types of phone. Amid the rising demand for cool devices and mobile internet services (not that these user demands necessarily go together, as the success of a 2.5G iPhone testifies) the handset makers and operators are going through their latest round of trying to work out their relationships with one another, and how that will shape mobile internet services.
Ironically, of course, the iPhone, hailed by the open internet community as a device that would drive mobile web, has actually been launched using an entirely retrograde business model, based around exclusive tie-in to a single operator and network, and around a closed development environment. The power of the mobile internet wave is testified by the partial failure of that attempt to preserve the walled gardens. This has happened in three ways, all of them fundamental to creating a real mobile web experience, and all of them being heavily exploited by Nokia, LG, Google, Sony Ericsson and the other movers and shakers in advanced IP device platforms. First, Apple was forced to open up its development platform, however reluctantly, acknowledging that open, and probably open source, applications and content will be key to making the mobile web happen. Second, large numbers of iPhones were unlocked by hackers ‘ and will be again ‘ showing that cellcos cannot hope to retain tight control of their users in a world where consumers are full participants, not passive buyers of any phone they are given. Third, the closed model has been broken outside the US, notably by legal challenges under French and German competition law. As well as indicating that, in the mobile market that Europe has often led, US companies need to understand that Europe does not work like the US, this also indicates the intense interest of governments and regulators in mobility and the internet, and their willingness to ensure that old structures can be challenged in the interest of universal, low cost, innovative services.
Handset makers, then, have to adapt to these three key elements of mobile internet ‘ open developer processes, open access, and a rising level of consumer expertise. They have the chance to reduce their dependence on the operator channel and boost their own brands and new routes to market, but coming out of the relative safety of the operator alliance also means a new pressure to deliver innovative and strongly marketed products on a very regular basis.
LG, which has scored many points with Chocolate and the iPhone-like Prada, has now come up with the Voyager and the Shine. Voyager indicates that LG, like Nokia, has understood that the challenge has changed in high end phones ‘ not just to deliver style, brand, performance and price, but also a differentiated experience and full internet interface. Voyager is Verizon Wireless’ first featurephone with either a touchscreen or full HTML browser and retails for $299. It contains a huge array of features for the price, with two large, very high resolution, one of them touch sensitive with haptics, plus there are a large Qwerty keyboard, web browser, GPS-based Navigator and VCast mobile television. Voyager also has a 2megapixel camera which, unlike iPhone, does video, and its main failing is limited storage.
Meanwhile, Shine is being launched in the US with AT&T. It has a silver, brushed metal exterior with an array of features that include a 2.2-inch exterior display, a 2-megapixel camera, Bluetooth connectivity and AT&T Mobility’s multimedia offerings. The handset sells for $150 with a two-year contract, although AT&T showed that, despite the impact of the iPhone, most competition is still price-oriented. The operator halved the price of every handset for a Thanksgiving promotion, with the exception of the iPhone and the Samsung BlackJack. Verizon Wireless cut prices on about 25% of its portfolio, and Sprint Nextel on three music phones, while T-Mobile USA made no similar moves.
Over at Nokia, which continues to struggle with the US cellcos but is gearing up for a major direct-to-consumer push, its latest patent filing indicates that it is set to create a device similar to the Sidekick, which has been a very popular device in the US via T-Mobile, and bridges the smartphone-PDA divide more effectively than most. Motorola has targeted it with Q, and HTC with Touch, and now Nokia is hinting at a touchscreen cameraphone with full swivel keyboard and tablet functions, that could sit alongside its E Series or Internet Tablet ranges, depending on operating system.
Sony Ericsson has also been filing patents that point to the latest features we could see from the king of multimedia-oriented handsets. An interesting one shows a drag and drop interface for transferring content files between mobile devices using the NFC short range standard as well as the more usual Bluetooth option.
Another company that is clearly preoccupied with the iPhone ‘ especially the prospect of a 3G version with Qwerty keyboard, which could appear next year ‘ is RIM, whose BlackBerry range continues to defy all the logic that says it should be in decline, and is now seeking to expand into more consumer markets. RIM is now rumored to be working on a touchscreen device for this sector, to build on the consumer success of Pearl and attack the iPhone’s territory. It will not have the half-keyboard design associated with BlackBerry and will contain more multimedia functionality than most RIM devices.