Blockchain protocol developer Algorand has found its first major environmental use case in air pollution initiative PlanetWatch, a startup that bundles elements of blockchain currency trading, air pollution sensor deployment and a data marketplace in an altogether perplexing offering.
It’s still very early days for PlanetWatch, but – as is often the case – we find it hard to see this becoming a key new use for blockchain within the IoT. The ideas behind the project are certainly intriguing, but as Riot has observed numerous times, most blockchain business ideas never get to the required level of ubiquity in order to provide the service they intend to – failing to reach critical mass.
PlanetWatch is using Algorand’s platform to create a reliable market for air quality pollution data, while simultaneously incentivizing the deployment of sensors. Algorand will act as the ledger for the air pollution data and provide the financial infrastructure for the trading of PlanetWatch tokens.
PlanetWatch has the perplexing task of operating three different sectors, all of which are reliant on one another. These are a quasi–cryptocurrency exchange (for its Planet tokens), a data portal, and an online marketplace for air pollution sensors themselves. Granted, we have caught the company at a primitive stage, but the complexity here suggests it will be a bumpy start.
First, let’s examine what Algorand is bringing to the table. The company is based in Singapore and claims to have “built the world’s first open source, permissionless, pure proof-of-stake blockchain protocol.”
The protocol is ‘pure proof-of-stake’ as participants are selected based on their stake of ‘Algos’. Those who have more are more likely to be selected to verify transactions. Algorand say its consensus protocol guarantees that its blockchain will never fork in two – an issue that results in two separate transactions being validated simultaneously with the same block, causing two separate chains to grow.
Security against attackers in the Algorand network is improved by ‘user replaceability’ – essentially, the randomization of the users who verify each transaction. Only users selected to verify a transaction is made aware of their own involvement, with no details shared of who else is involved. An extensive explanation of blockchain technology can be found in our 2018 report, here, but for now, the technical details aren’t necessary.
So, what does PlanetWatch hope to achieve with this technology? Algorand will record a ledger of air pollution data, while also providing a financial system for a host of confusing operations. Data from the sensors can be sold to the marketplace for Planet tokens, which in turn can be used to buy more air pollution sensors from the online marketplace.
We spoke to PlanetWatch CEO, Claudio Parrinello, who envisaged a landscape where investors would hand ‘Planets’ to sensor managers who would aim to make returns from tactical deployment.
Is there a potential marketplace here? The company’s website argues it will be able to overcome many of issues that often plague government-led collection of air pollution the data. Such data generally operates on a delay of at least 24 hours, and the mesh of sensors from which it is collected is rarely dense enough.
Real-time data will be offered to those who either invest in sensor deployment, or pay for access to a premium app. As for customers such as city councils, Parrinello envisaged the most likely scenario would be a monthly subscription fee. This would certainly make more sense, as we can’t imagine many city authorities investing in cryptocurrencies. Parrinello was tight lipped on future collaborations but acknowledged that smart city authorities were a promising customer base.
Algorand is based in Singapore, where development is constantly pushed by the government’s Smart Nation program. This has made much data publicly available through a portal on its website – but even this doesn’t have air pollution data past 2017. Of course, if enough sensors were deployed, PlanetWatch would provide an attractive source of real-time data on air pollution. But that is a big if.
We’re hardly convinced that PlanetWatch is a sure success, but it certainly shares elements with other recent blockchain trends. Although it prefers the term ‘tangle’ rather than blockchain, IOTA launched its own data marketplace in 2017, but it has been painfully quiet to date. There is also Datapace, a data marketplace powered by blockchain technologies, but much the same can be said of its activity.
Blockchain technologies are also finding their way into other more established data marketplaces. In our CES coverage a few weeks ago, we noted how Here developed a mechanism based on blockchain technologies which generates a ‘consent request’ to access a car’s data, that can then be revoked by the owner.
On the energy front, the past year seems to have seen lots of hype surrounding ‘microgrids’, small localized grids in which electricity can be traded through blockchain-powered exchanges, potentially leaving electricity distributors somewhat redundant, and likely reducing costs.
For instance, in 2017, Estonia’s WePower used Ethereum to record energy consumption and production throughout the country. 26,000 hours and 24 TWh of energy production was converted into 39bn Smart Energy Tokens.
Then there is the technology behind the defunct, but repackaged, Faraday Grid, which is now operating as Third Edition Ltd. The underlying software was the Emergent Transactional Platform, a blockchain-based accounting and energy transaction database. This turned into something resembling a router in digital networking technology, allowing electrical energy to flow in either direction, across any route to any destination.