Motorola finally took the plunge and said it would spin off its handset business, something activist shareholders led by Carl Icahn have been demanding for months in order to increase the total value of the company and free its higher growth units to fulfil their potential. Although the fallen giant officially insists this is to be a spin-off not a sale, an interested suitor emerged this week in the surprising shape of Videocon, a consumer electronics and industrial group from India, which is looking for international expansion. Although there would be many challenges in such a marriage, the fact that Videocon says it is in the early stages of preparing a formal bid indicates how the balance of power in handsets is shifting.
The Taiwanese manufacturers, once confined to white label markets, are building their own brands (HTC most successfully) and looking for global presence, with several linked by the rumor mill to Motorola earlier this year; the Chinese, though floundering in their domestic market against Nokia, are also looking to expand internationally. The Indian handset sector has not developed as quickly, but in newer systems like WiMAX, Indian firms are looking to leverage their cost and technology advantages to become a ‘new Taiwan’, and will soon start to look beyond low cost devices for the home customer base and towards international position.
Mumbai-based Videocon, which is controlled by the Dhoot family ‘ which bought Thomson’s picture tube business in 2005 ‘ has been expanding its consumer electronics reach, though it failed in 2006 in a bid for Daewoo Electronics of Korea. However, it is now taking an interest in the mobile world, having gained spectrum licenses during last November’s auction. It plans to launch mobile services in 18 cities and towns this year, despite the heavy competition already in place in India, but while offering Motorola handsets on these networks might bring some cost and competitive advantage, the purchase would be more important to boost Videocon’s retail business at home, and give it a beach head into international markets. The company currently has 700 electronics retail outlets in its home country and aims to increase that to 4,000 by 2013. As such, it would be in a position to adopt a direct-to-consumer approach to selling handsets ‘ as well as using its own mobile networks ‘ and establish the current Motorola range as the leading brand in the subcontinent.
However, the problems inherent in the plan are huge. The Dhoots say they have sufficient cash to fund a bid for the US firm, but they have no expertise in telecoms or in managing a company like Motorola. They might streamline its non-Indian operations, but otherwise leave them virtually intact, but would still face a management challenge in India itself, where the complex web structure of the family-run business would conflict with Motorola’s organization. It also seems unclear how Videocon wishes to divide its focus between being an operator and an equipment maker, and the ownership of spectrum would almost certainly muddy the waters and cut off potential channels for the handsets.
Some analysts believe Videocon has indicated its interest mainly to boost the valuation of its own business, given likely plans to divest a share to foreign telecoms partners later this year. As it was, Videocon stock rose 5% in a flat Indian market on Tuesday as news of the bid plans emerged.
If the bid turns out to be serious, it could draw others into the field, although to date there has been little real interest in Motorola. Speculation that a Chinese or Taiwanese phonemaker, or even LG, might bid came to nothing, and the decision to spin off the devices division is seen in many quarters as a fallback option following the failure to find a buyer. While separating its businesses should bring benefits, at least in the short term, to its enterprise, infrastructure and home networks operations – which are in a healthier state, but being dragged down by the handsets ‘ the fact remains that devices are still Motorola’s biggest business, and separation will do nothing to address the problems in that side of the company.
The other businesses will be relieved to be able to be judged by the stock market on their own merits, given that Motorola has lost 45% of its value in the past 12 months, largely because of the failure to produce a hit handset, and the loss of market share. By contrast, revenue from enterprise mobility solutions leapt by 43% to $7.7bn in the last quarter, with operating profit of $1.2bn, similar to the loss suffered in the handets unit, and there has also been strong growth in home networking.
One person greeting Motorola CEO Greg Brown’s announcement of the spin-off plan was Icahn, who sent Motorola’s board a letter that called the decision ‘much delayed and long overdue’ but still a ‘step in the right direction’. However, he wants the company to move more quickly, as every week worsens its market share predicament. His letter posed three questions to the board, which he recently denounced as a ‘country club’:
‘ Why will it take you until sometime in 2009 to accomplish the separation?
‘ Why does it take the threat of a proxy fight for you to make promises we all want to hear?
‘ Do you intend to carry out your proposals or will it be a repeat of last year’s proxy fight strewn with a string of broken commitments?
The letter went on: ‘Obviously the tepid reaction of the market manifests shareholders’ views concerning the value of your commitment. The only statement made in your conference call we totally agree with is that…’there can be no assurances that any transaction will ultimately occur’.’
Brown himself was not being too aggressive about the plan, agreeing it was not a silver bullet. ‘Today’s announcement doesn’t change the fact that we need to improve the performance of mobile devices and extend and expand its portfolio of products,’ he told the Wall Street Journal. ‘The prospect of restoring this proud franchise that’s pioneered wireless and of creating a new independent entity could be attractive to a new CEO candidate.’ One benefit of a spin-off may be that it will attract a better calibre of person to head up a company with a CEOship, than a business unit reporting to Brown ‘ though the candidate will also clearly be taking a major risk in taking on such a damaged business. There have been four people in charge of handsets in the past four years ‘ including Brown before his elevation to the CEO post after the departure of Ed Zander last year, and the recently removed Stu Reed ‘ and this is sending out confused messages to the market, at a time when Nokia, in particular, is exploiting Motorola’s weaknesses ruthlessly to achieve its own market share gains. Finding a head for the soon-to-be independent unit will be a priority, as a spin-off will carry too much uncertainty for the markets without a credible leader in place. Wall Street analysts believe former Motorola COO Mike Zafirowski, now CEO of Nortel, has been approached but turned down the job. Other names in the frame are said to be James Mooney, chairman of Virgin Media and with long standing Motorola associations from his days in senior roles at Nextel; and Edward Breen, former Motorola president who now runs Tyco International, and is known as a turnaround expert.
Motorola said it expects to finalize the split in 2009 by giving shareholders stock in a new company that will include the handset business through a tax-free distribution. Other decisions, such as whether the division would keep the Moto brand, have not been made. Brown said the company is in the ‘early process’ of figuring out details about the cash, patents and use of Motorola’s brand, and is working to retain engineers and other staff.
He denied, somewhat disingenuously, that Motorola had tried and failed to sell the handset division. ‘We’ve never had a for sale sign on mobile devices,’ he claimed.
The other handset makers:
‘ Nokia said in a US filing that replacements would account for just over 70% of its volume this year, compared to just under 70% in 2007. The company expected color screens, cameras, email and music players to help drive the market. Nokia noted that growth in China and Asia-Pacific countries have boosted falling sales in EMEA, North America and Latin America.
‘ Samsung has cut its sales forecast for this year, citing global economic woes, but said its profit will beat last year’s, helped by earnings growth in key areas such as chips, flat panels and handsets.
‘ Sony Ericsson, for the past couple of years the darling of the handset business, last week issued a warning that its profits for the first quarter of 2008 could fall by as much as 50% year-on-year, amid slowing cellphone sales. Sony Ericsson’s new CEO, Dick Komiyama, described conditions as ‘challenging’, pointing to the global economic slowdown and its impact on consumer spending. The joint venture estimates that its income before tax will be between €150m and €200m, down from €362m in Q107, although its gross margin should remain the same at 30.3%. The company is seeing weakening of demand for high end phones, which are its strongest market, as it has only recently started to target low cost models through partnerships in India and with Sagem.
‘ Dominant handset chipmaker Texas Instruments had previously cut its first quarter forecasts, citing weaker demand for chips used in higher priced 3G phones.