Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 May 2015

Potential BT break-up highlights mobile infrastructure boom

The proposed acquisition of EE, the UK’s largest mobile operator, by incumbent telco BT has sparked more intense regulatory scrutiny than was first expected, and may force the wireline firm to separate its wholesale and retail activities and open up its dark fiber to rivals.

Regulator Ofcom already, back in March, initiated a review of BT’s wholesale business, OpenReach, in response to claims that there would be conflicts of interest between its leased line backhaul services and its ownership of an MNO. Now Ofcom is also proposing to force the telco to open up its unused dark fiber lines for competitors to attach their own equipment – a move separate from the EE deal review, but clearly triggered by it.

Such an outcome would highlight the changing way that telecoms networks are being built and run round the world, not just in the UK, with the power shifting to infrastructure (sites and fiber), while mobile players, once relishing their lack of fixed-line albatrosses, rush either to find a wireline partner, or to ditch their actual networks in favor of a virtual model.

The trends for MNOs to offload cell towers, share access networks and rely heavily on third party infrastructure (from fibre backhaul to WiFi hotstpots) is changing the shape of the wireless market, and where the key sources of revenue and power lie. By the next decade, we will see far larger infrastructure powerhouses, serving far larger numbers of virtual wireless and fixed/mobile service providers, with a few major installations of sites, access networks and backhaul. For those MNOs which do choose to stay with their own towers and RANs, even into the 5G era, the wholesale aspect of their business will be increasingly important, and much of the real revenue will emanate from having a strong cloud platform to manage all those MVNOs on an ‘as a service’, and even an on-demand, basis.

Crown Castle and Google Fiber in the US, Arqiva in the UK, Indus Tower in India and the new tower joint venture between the three Chinese operators – these are examples of the new power players, whose huge infrastructure investments will enable the new generation of networks. Those will require huge amounts of backhaul (and fronthaul, in the case of Cloud-RAN), putting pressure on fiber resources but creating windfalls for those with fiber assets; and huge numbers of cell sites, from towers to lamp-posts, as the RAN densifies. Not that it will all be boom-time for the owners of such assets – the pricing norms will have to change radically to make the ultra-dense, ultra-high speed, virtualized ‘5G’ network economically viable. So dark fiber and small cell-site operators will have the opportunity to shape the new landscape and support the new economics, but they will need considerable scale and efficiency to do that profitably.

Of course, telco incumbents are often in a strong position to create these as-a-service mobile infrastructure businesses themselves, given their large-scale ownership of fiber and copper networks, and often useful sites too. This is where the regulatory balance will have to be finely drawn, and why antitrust and telecoms agencies will be casting a closer eye on the activities of infrastructure controllers which also have retail mobile and broadband businesses. In the US, Sprint and others have fought for years to have more rigorous oversight of how Verizon and AT&T manage their considerable fiber resources, and whether those are open on a non-discriminatory basis to rivals which lack those assets. The FCC can hardly be said to have taken a strong line, but some European regulators are likely to be more stringent.
That means the conditions placed on the proposed BT/EE deal by the UK’s Ofcom and its competition authority will be an important test case for other markets – and explains why the takeover may be accompanied by more stringent conditions than expected.

When the deal was announced, it was expected to disturb antitrust sensitivities less than the other big UK M&A story, Hutchison’s offer to acquire Telefonica O2 UK. That merger, by combining O2 UK with Three UK, would reduce the number of MNOs in the country from four to three, traditionally a touchstone for regulatory scrutiny. However, several recent European deals have had the same effect and been waved through without significant conditions – most notably the merger of KPN’s E-Plus and Telefonica O2 in Germany.

This shows regulators beginning to accept that, in the ultra-competitive European markets, three strong player with the resource to invest in new networks and services may be better for consumers than a quartet in which at least two are struggling. It also highlights two other changes in the landscape which must affect M&A policies – that competition is increasingly based on a multiplay of different fixed and wireless services, so mobile and fixed-line operators cannot be assessed in isolation any more; and that control of the infrastructure enabling those converged networks is a powerful competitive weapon too. Fair access to broadband lines has been heavily regulated for years, and Europe has gone through the painful process of deregulation and unbundling of wholesale and retail activities. Now the same approach may be applied to the fiber and sites which enable mobile services.

This week, Ofcom announced proposals to open up BT’s fiber networks to rivals. This aims to address some companies’ claims that current regulations, which require BT to keep its wholesale business separate from retail services, will not prevent it having a major competitive advantage once it acquires EE. They fear that EE would gain preferential access to BT’s infrastructure resources.

Ofcom’s proposals go far further than just addressing those fears – they would greatly reduce BT’s dominance of the fixed-line market and could even pave the way for complete break-up of the telco. It would oblige BT to open up its significant stores of dark fiber for use by BT/EE rivals. Although BT already leases its active fiber lines to other companies via its wholesale division, OpenReach, Ofcom would now force it to offer all its fiber holdings, even those not in use, with rivals able to connect their own equipment (from base stations to fiber-to-the-home boxes) to the lines, and so control their own traffic.

This is not really much to do with the EE deal, but sees Ofcom taking that opportunity to boost fixed-line competition to BT, which it says is inadequate outside central London. The regulator would also introduce new minimum service level requirements for OpenReach, such as activating a new leased line within 40 days, amid complaints that the telco sometimes takes too long to open up vital resources to its customer/competitors.

“Today’s proposals should help businesses across the UK who rely on high speed data lines,” said Jonathan Oxley, Ofcom’s competition group director. “We want to see more innovation, faster installations and more competition, by providing operators with the opportunity to deploy the technologies of their choice.”

Naturally, BT differs from this view. It argues that OpenReach already supports “a level playing field and a vibrant, competitive market with hundreds of competing companies, large and small”. It also argues that mandating dark fiber would actually reduce the smaller firms’ ability to compete because they would lack the resource to harness it and install the necessary equipment. The proposal “risks favouring a few companies that have the greatest capability to deploy it, to the disadvantage of all other firms,” said the telco, in a statement to Ofcom. “It will undermine investment – as a number of service providers have warned – and it would also increase costs, divert resources and add more complexity just when we’re beginning to make progress on improving service.”

The pros and cons depend heavily on one’s view of how actively BT has supported third party business, even when it comes from rivals to its own broadband, enterprise, telephony and TV services (to which it will soon add mobile broadband, regulators willing). It has certainly been more flexible than some fellow European incumbents, and has had a longer period of privatization and deregulation to adapt to new norms. However, it is clear that the UK market has suffered from having just one firm leading investment in fiber. BT’s 21st Century Network upgrade project has been ambitious and, in many respects, well-executed, but service providers are still too reliant on one huge monolith to do the right thing.

A more competitive environment on the fiber side would almost certainly have driven more rapid deployment, as one of the would-be challengers, CityFibre, pointed out. Its CEO, Greg Mesch, said: “The task of redressing the legacy of decades of under-investment in the UK for fiber infrastructure is too large and important to be left to solely one monopoly provider, and the role of smaller, entrepreneurial players must not be underestimated or undervalued.”

Another provider of wholesale fiber and site services, pan-European player Colt Telecom, pointed out that some southern European countries have been more aggressive in opening up access to infrastructure in order to boost competition from smaller players. Barney Lane, director of regulation at Colt, said: “Ofcom’s ruling is an important step in the right direction.  It will help spur innovation and incentivise connectivity providers like Colt to roll out new services.”

Any moves to open up dark fiber will take a couple of years to come into effect, if they do at all, and will not necessarily be directly tied into approval for the EE takeover. But it is undoubtedly that deal – which so epitomises the shift to quad play power around Europe – which has triggered the decision to readdress the issue (Ofcom last looked at BT’s dark fibre three years ago, but backed away from taking action.) Other mobile operators, particularly Vodafone – currently left out of the UK’s M&A whirl and set to become the smallest mobile  player in its home country – have complained that there will be a significant conflict of interest in BT’s ownership both of backhaul lines and its own MNO.

BT’s CEO Gavin Patterson, filings its official submission of its EE proposal to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) this week, argued: “The acquisition will lead to greater competition, given our history as a natural and willing wholesaler, enabling other companies to use the networks we own. We provide wholesale access to companies in the broadband market and we are happy to support others who wish to compete in the mobile market as well. The UK is one of the most tightly regulated marketplaces in the world and that will continue to be the case ensuring all companies can compete on a fair basis.”

One route, of course, is that BT will break up altogether, putting its £2bn-a- year fiber leasing activities, and other wholesale services, into a separate company, not just a division behind a Chinese wall, as it now does. When asked by LightReading analysts whether it was ruling out “structural separation” of BT as part of its ongoing strategic review, an Ofcom spokesperson said: “That review will consider questions such as the one you described, and we aren’t ruling anything in or out at this stage.” Structural separation would effectively mean break-up – under the current rules, OpenReach is functionally separate and its profits can support other BT group activities.

Unlike in some other major mergers of recent times, fibre and infrastructure issues are far more thorny than spectrum. BT has some spectrum  holdings, but even combined with EE’s, its assets would still fall below the revised cap that Ofcom announced last year along with plans for its 2.3 GHz and 3.4 GHz spectrum auctions. It is possible that the regulator may look for some spectrum swapping between BT/EE , whose holdings are weighted towards higher bands like 1.8 GHz and 2.6 GHz, and O2/Three, which are stronger in the lower frequencies. A more complicated set of decisions may surround the mobile sites – EE has a RAN sharing venture with Three, MBNL, while O2 and Vodafone own CTIL, which manages their combined portfolio of sites.

BT may be under pressure in terms of its wholesale dominance, but it claims it lives in a highly competitive environment for retail broadband or multiplay services, and that consumer choice would only be improved by an EE merger. In its CMA filing, it said the deal would provide new quad play bundles and increase alternatives to the current leaders in those services, Liberty Global’s Virgin Media and TalkTalk.

“A larger BT will be able to invest and innovate even more than now, something that’s good for jobs and good for customers, said Patterson.

BT has asked the CMA to fast track the investigation of the deal and move direct to the second phase of the process, a decision the authority will make in about three weeks’ time. BT still expects to be able to complete the £12.5bn acquisition by the end of March 2016.

Despite concerns of BT’s dominance, the UK’s independent infrastructure market is a growing one. Independent fibre providers like Colt and CityFibre support MNOs, wireless ISPs and smaller broadband providers in urban areas, and Colt has been particularly active in taking steps towards a ‘small cell as a service’ offering in which it installs and manages WiFi and cellular base stations on sites near the ground, like lamp-posts. Major broadband provider Virgin Media has also toyed with that business model, and has proved a strong competitor to BT for conventional cell site backhaul deals in recent years.

The switch from leased copper lines to fiber has brought in new entrants, a fact BT may use to its advantages in negotiations with regulators. For instance, last November CityFibre sigend one of its largest contracts, with EE and Three, as well as their MBNL venture (of course, this is the sort of deal the independents will worry might end when EE can use BT’s lines). Under the agreement, CityFibre is to deploy dark fibre backhaul connections to the two operators’ masts, for the first time in the UK, to increase bandwidth and support new, LTE-driven customer experiences.

This is the kind of new, flexible and cost-effective approach to backhaul which Ofcom hopes to foster by opening up more dark fibre. So far, the project is just being tested in one city, Kingston-upon-Hull, but CityFibre says this approach will give the operators greater control over their own capacity than they get from traditional leasing deals. EE’s  CTO, Fotis Karonis, said at the time:“This is a completely new model for the industry, set to provide a much-needed change to the economics of capacity management.” And his counterpart at Three said: “The ability to add our own high capacity infrastructure will be hugely important for our network, particularly in busy metropolitan areas.”

CityFibre also has agreements to provide high speed fiber networks to broadband operators Sky and TalkTalk in certain metro areas. And Virgin Media, as well as BT, is upgrading its fiber networks and expanding its backhaul agreements with the UK cellcos.

In the sites themselves, the major third party cell tower operator, Arqiva, has been expanding its activities into small cell sites, including WiFi, and smart city networks. Last year it signed a site sharing deal with CTIL, and obtained a loan of €190m from the European Investment Bank to support new infrastructure projects, including roll-out of  smart metering systems in northern England and Scotland; extension of its activities in WiFi infrastructure; and expansion of its digital radio and TV portfolios. Arqiva is also working with French IoT connectivity provider Sigfox to build 10 IoT networks in the UK using ultra-narrowband technology.

This growing amount of non-aligned infrastructure sets the scene for a more flexible approach to mobile and converged service provision, in which there are far more retail providers, tapping into a large pool of infrastructure on an increasingly flexible basis. ‘As-a-service’ approaches can reduce barriers to entry, such as installation and maintenance costs, for smaller providers looking to build WiFi networks, or – in an emerging option – to invest in their own small cells while relying on an MVNO deal for the ‘host’ macro network.

The next logical step is for service providers to be able to use backhaul and the access network on an on-demand basis, moving away from rigid multiyear contracts with MNOs and fiber owners and getting closer to the situation Google envisions – of infrastructure, bandwidth and spectrum being available on-demand to thousands of service providers, with pricing charged on a marketplace basis. This, the search giant argues, would enable all kinds of new services with greater control of network quality than purely over-the-top offerings, but with the cost base to support niche applications.

The UK, like the rest of the world, is a long way away from that nirvana, despite Google’s best efforts to create the infrastructure to underpin it in the US (with Google Fiber). Across the Atlantic, though, Google is not the only one spotting the opportunities in a more flexible, multi-operator world based around massive wholesale infrastructure. Allied Fiber is setting up a dark fiber business which would primarily focus on virtual and over-the-top players, not conventional mobile operators. In that sense, it is actually implementing some of the ideas which Google talks about for the future, but which, so far, its own dark fibre acquisitions and fibre-to-the-home deployments do not actually support.

As in wireless networks, Google is building for a different future, not aiming to become a conventional service provider. But companies like Allied Fiber may be getting there first, even as more traditional infrastructure players like Crown Castle are, like Arqiva in the UK, expanding their activities into ‘as-a-service’  operations and new types of networks and sites.

Allied Fiber is building up a nationwide US dark fibre network (so far it has completed the area from Jacksonville, Florida to Atlanta, Georgia). In an interview at International Telecoms Week earlier this month, CEO Hunter Newby said over-the-top content providers or social networks are more eager than MNOs to access his firm’s assets. It is all part of the trend, also seen at Google and Facebook, for OTT players to want greater control of the actual network, and therefore the quality of service they can guarantee for certain customers or applications.

“Their goal is control,” Newby told LightReading. “They want to own the network end-to-end for a lot of the same reasons individuals want certain rights and proofs. The content providers don’t like the cost structure or the fact that they don’t know where their data is going. They want to control security, the ability to provision capacity or add terabytes.”

And of course, as Google well knows, such providers are looking for far more flexible relationships than a rigid and expensive deal with a traditional mobile or fibre network owner. Newby added: “It will be table stakes going forward for whoever the next Twitter and Netflix is. If you don’t own your fiber pairs or cable, you are not relevant. That is a pretty high bar to have to cross.”

This isn’t about real ownership though, but about being able to access fiber and sites on a flexible, financially attractive basis in order to support the economics of highly competitive content and social services. That is why the wholesale and virtualized platforms will flourish as the major OTT players look for differentiation from the crowd.

Tower providers are also interested in dark fibre services like this, as they expect networks to densify and so change the mixture of sites which they need to offer, often with backhaul included. Crown Castle CEO Ben Moreland spoke on the firm’s last earnings call of “the inevitability of the need for cell site density”, and the company has been diversifying its portfolio accordingly. It said recently that small cells now make up 7% of its total site rental revenue and are driving strong growth – the small cell business grew 35% year-on-year, the company said on its Q1 results call, while overall rental revenues were up just 3%.  Small cells accounted for $53.76m of the quarter’s total revenues of $768m and the company expects that, for full year 2015, it will enjoy $100m in additional revenue, at least half of that coming from this new area of business.

Crown Castle has made several acquisitions to broaden its offering. In late 2011 it bought DAS and small  cell provider NextG Networks, which helped bring its new parent’s total tally of small cell nodes to 14,000 live or under construction, with 7,000 miles of fiber. “Similar to towers built in the late 1990s and early 2000s, we are focused on building small cell networks in the most attractive locations in the US, in places like Manhattan, Washington DC, Southern California and Chicago,” said the firm.

Including fiber in the service is essential to the business case. “One of our key concerns with the small cell model is our belief the fiber companies would take a large part of the profitability and revenue opportunity. By owning more of this tangible asset, CCI should increase the overall margin profile of each small cell project,” wrote Wells Fargo analyst Jennifer Fritzsche in a research note.

This year, Crown Castle bought Quanta Fiber Networks, also known as Sunesys, for $1bn in cash from Quanta Services. Sunesys owns or has rights to almost 10,000 miles of fiber in major metro areas and the purchase is firmly geared to small cell services, “more than doubling Crown Castle’s fiber footprint available for small cell deployments”, as the firm said. The deal follows a similar acquisition, last year, of 24/7 Mid-Atlantic Network which brought about 800 route miles of fiber in the eastern coastal region.

“Based on current small cell activity, including awarded and proposed small cell deployments, we have visibility into more than 3,500 small cell opportunities on or near the Sunesys fiber,” said Moreland.

Rival tower firm SBA is newer to this space but said on its own results call that it has signed “a handful of small cell contracts on its towers and received some fair rents”, and sees a positive development in this market. CEO Jeffrey Stoops told the company’s earnings call: “It’s interesting they are generally being placed at the 30-foot mark and we’re getting what we think are some very fair and good rents for that. So we continue to watch the area, it looks to be developing positively. And we expect to continue to pay attention there.”

Nearly all his peers in the sites and fiber markets will be saying the same, as densification finally starts to gather pace, and operators start to look for new sources of infrastructure to deliver new economics to the HetNet.

Colt launches European Supercore:

Delivery of high definition content to mobile devices is one of the primary target applications for Colt’s new European Supercore, a long distance 100 Gigabit Ethernet (100GE) network which connects major cities to support clients, such as media companies, with heavy bandwidth requirements.

Once, mobile operators would not have fallen into this category, when they had 3G speeds and limited data loads. But the era of mobile TV – HD, Ultra-HD, 4K and beyond – has changed all that, and MNOs will join cloud operators, large enterprises and media giants in tapping into resources such as Colt’s.

The new network connects major cities across central and western Europe, namely Amsterdam, Berlin, Brussels, Dublin, Dusseldorf, Frankfurt, Hamburg, London, Munich, Paris, Stuttgart, Vienna and Zurich.

“The European Supercore network is the latest demonstration of Colt’s commitment to address our customers’ fast-growing data demands in the major hubs that matter to them,” said Zhongmin Guo, VP of strategy and business development at the provider’s network services division.

Tesco may sell its stake in UK MVNO:

One of the UK’s largest MVNOs, Tesco Mobile, may be the latest provider to change ownership in the tumultuous market.

Supermarket chain Tesco is reported to be looking to sell its 50% stake in the unit in a bid to reduce its debt, following a wave of recent poor results and financial shocks. Its co-owner, Telefonica O2 (itself the subject of a takeover bid by Hutchison Three) may choose to buy it out. Another possible buyers could be TalkTalk, the broadband provider which has, so far, failed to find a mobile partner to go up against its rivals’ burgeoning quad plays – but which has an MVNO deal in place with O2 itself, and has previously acquired another Tesco unit, Blinkbox.

The stake is estimated by City analysts to be worth several hundred million pounds, as it generates £100m ($154m) in annual profits for Tesco. It provides services on co-parent O2’s network and has about 4m subscribers, making it the largest MVNO in the UK. However, it is still subject to intense price wars in this competitive country where, in addition to the four MNOs themselves, there are many MVNOs and branded resellers.

And while Telefonica may be running for the hills amid all the price wars, more MVNOs keep entering, including the new iD offering from retailer Carphone Warehouse. This will run on the Three network and offer LTE data with free voice, text and data roaming plus flexible contracts.