Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2006

Price war breaks out as European cellcos pre-empt roaming cuts

A price war is breaking out, triggered by European mobile operators’ opposition to EU plans to force down charges for international roaming. The four major UK cellcos have all announced cuts in their fees, a move that is likely to be emulated elsewhere as the operators try to pre-empt EU action led by commissioner Viviane Reding.

The mobile giants’ arguments against compulsory caps on roaming charges have been tortuous all along. Most outrageous was Vodafone’s claim that, had such caps been in force all along, it would not have been able to launch its popular Passport roaming offering, since with all the cellcos offering low fees, this would not have been needed. Hardly comforting for the businesses that have tolerated high roaming fees all these years, and for whom Passport was the best option available, but hardly perfect.

Despite gestures such as Passport, the mobile operators signally failed voluntarily to reduce roaming tariffs, and their mutual decision destroyed the argument that commercial forces alone would reduce charges. Business travellers had to use their cellphones ‘ at least until hotspot-based VoIP becomes more practicable ‘ however much they chafed at the costs.

So Reding got tough in March (see Wireless Watch April 3 2006 edition), saying: ‘[The mobile operators] already seem to be on the verge of claiming bankruptcy. They are nothing of the sort. We are not against people making normal profits but we are against 95% margins achieved on the backs of travelers.’

Her stand has finally convinced the cellcos that they can stall no longer. Vodafone, T-Mobile UK, O2 and Orange UK have all announced reduction in roaming charges, with T-Mobile promising a flat rate of 55 pence a minute for both its prepaid and postpaid UK subscribers calling home from anywhere in Europe, Canada and the US. This equates to a price cut of 54%. This level of reduction across Europe could reduce revenues from roaming by $5bn overall.

Vodafone will cut charges by ‘at least 40% within a year’ and seek reciprocal wholesale deals with ‘any European operator’ to ensure that subscribers’ roaming charges will be reduced to 45 pence a minute in future. Orange has promised reductions averaging 25% and consistent charges across the whole EU, while O2 and 3 will announce their own plans soon.

Early in 2005, the European Regulators Group reported that mobile carriers were charging ‘very high’ roaming tariffs ‘without clear justification’. Following Reding’s aggressive statements in March, EC proposals are due in June, with action set for July, so now the operators are trying to pre-empt these likely harsh regulations, while generating positive public relations spin.

Price war now looms, as well as a last ditch hope that Reding will water down, or even abandon, her pending proposals (an unlikely outcome).