Qualcomm last week launched its latest attack on WiMAX, with the publication of a white paper by executive head of marketing, Jeff Belk, simply entitled ‘Why MAX?’. But as the chipmaker ‘ despite its own OFDM roadmaps ‘ sought to crush the claims of 802.16e to provide non-3G license holders with an alternative mobile platform, one of the largest CDMA customers, KDDI of Japan, was talking up a strategy that relies on incorporating WiMAX with its cellular networks. Presenting at the same conference as KDDI, WiMAX GlobalComForum in Madrid, BT probably put its corporate finger on the real issue ‘ ‘4G’ has to be a set of services, not a technology, to avoid the early mistakes of 3G and countless other platforms before it. Unless the services are attractive and unique, it does not much matter what the underlying radio architecture is.
Belk argues that WiMAX comes with similar costs and spectral/performance constraints as the 3G technologies, W-CDMA and CDMA2000 EV-DO, and the same issues surrounding device cost and availability, but for many years will lack the advantages of harmonized spectrum, vast installed user bases and legacy voice revenues.
He wrote: ‘There is a basic problem in that there has not been any example of data-only systems being economically viable, and no discussion, if the WiMAX guys are going to do voice services, how they are going to penetrate a value chain and wireless ecosystem that will be rapidly approaching a billion units a year by the time the WiMAX guys get their act together. Let alone what frequency these alleged systems will operate at. Or how the standardization issues get solved”.
Over at KDDI, however, Dr Fumio Watanabe, general manager of wireless broadband, was outlining the company’s ‘Ultra3G’ vision, which would be music to the ears of the major vendors seeking to position WiMAX as pivotal to a fixed-mobile convergence strategy. KDDI, which has invested heavily in CDMA2000 EV-DO and, on the wireline side, in fiber to the home, now sees the next step as being its Ultra3G fixed-mobile convergence architecture, based on a mixture of access networks and devices, all held together by IP. Within this plan, he sees broadband wireless as having a critical role, with his main reason being superior price/performance – directly contradicting Qualcomm’s analysis (and a recent one by Vodafone that concluded WiMAX would be no cheaper to build out than HSDPA).
The aim would be to have a broadband wireless overlay on top of EV-DO, which would deliver high bandwidth applications and reduce the cost per bit for such services providing seamless access for the end user. He expects the cost per bit, once mobile WiMAX is fully developed, to be onlyone-tenth of that of EV-DO. Other key advantages, Watanabe said, were the ability to span fixed and mobile usage, and the fact that there is no WiMAX dependency in the upper layers of the network, since it is a standard only for the physical and MAC layers. This makes it easier to integrate it with other access technologies and deploy new services while minimizing the number of interfaces to be supported.
KDDI is currently field testing the first phase of its Ultra3G project, combining EV-DO, pre-standard 802.16e, an IPv6 core and an MMD (MultiMedia Domain ‘ the CDMA equivalent of the IMS). Much will depend on spectrum decision, with Japan, like other countries, weighing the possibility of making future allocations around 2.5GHz technology neutral rather than 3G-specific, something KDDI would favour as benefiting multi-network and converged roadmaps.
Although Watanabe mentioned WiMAX on various occasions, the Ultra3G project has not finally committed to a specific broadband wireless technology, and so the Japanese carrier might be seen as a natural fit for Qualcomm’s own OFDM/CDMA convergence roadmap. For all its bitterness against WiMAX, the chip company sees a role for OFDM-based technologies in high bandwidth applications (such as its FLO broadcasting technology). It also needs such a technology to give it a potential route into converged operators that require systems to span fixed and mobile services, not an issue that needed to trouble Qualcomm in the days when mobile-only companies were the most highly valued.
Therefore it has created FLO and other platforms, accumulated a large store of OFDM patents and acquired Flarion with its Flash-OFDM mobile broadband technology. Qualcomm accepts that the CDMA-based networks cannot have the mobile market to themselves forever and is supportive of OFDM, though only if it can control the platform. We can expect the company to produce a mixed-network architecture that will be highly attractive to existing CDMA operators, perhaps including KDDI itself.
Politics aside, Watanabe was keen to stress what most operators believe, that they will be using multiple access technologies in future, especially as all-IP systems, flexible spectrum usage policies, and software defined radios and base stations make this more practical and cost effective. ‘There are various standards for wireless access,’ he pointed out. ‘It is important, however, to standardize the wireless system as a whole based on the connection to IP core networks.’
Even more important is then to have some compelling services to deliver on top of the converged architecture, something some early 3G operators managed to forget. Brian Levy, BT’s group technology officer for innovation and service strategy, also speaking in Madrid, preferred to see WiMAX as one technology among many components of 4G, including fiber and other wireline options, and to define the fourth generation as a distinct set of services. ‘If we just leverage 3G services over 4G transmission networks then we will only be competing on price between one technology and another. This in my view will be a failed strategy,’ he said.
The key question is what will differentiate a 4G from a 3G service? Levy believes the distinction is usually allowed to rest solely on video and television, but that the operators that successfully leverage their broadband networks will be those with a more holistic view of the service set. Key elements in the consumer market could include personalization, online payment, integrated messaging, entertainment and video, and real time sharing of documents, all of which contribute to a subscriber’s particular lifestyle and way of living.
Whether we agree or not with the precise services being created by BT, the point is well made. Without enabling new ways of working and living, or enhancing existing ones, carriers will invest in high performance networks only to find themselves in a price war ‘ a fate that threatens some of the 3G operators as all-IP networks accelerate their pace into the market.