Despite the hype around 5G millimeter wave bands such as 26/28 GHz, much of the pioneering work of making high frequency spectrum economically viable for mainstream wireless devices was done in 60 GHz. In most regions, this is unlicensed spectrum in which the dominant technology has been the WiFi-like technology WiGig (IEEE 802.11ad standard, with a next generation planned, called 802.11ay).
However, even in a band with plentiful capacity and a relatively mature technology, there can still be disputes about who should be able to use it, and how to protect others from interference. A group of companies including Qualcomm, Facebook, Google, Intel and Samsung have formed a 60 GHz Coexistence Study Group because they are concerned about the use of this spectrum by drones and radar devices, and the potential impact on wireless broadband services.
This raises the wider issue of how ‘unlicensed’ spectrum can be in the future, when some mobile devices are emerging which have very demanding capacity and reliability requirements, and operate at higher power than most radio devices – and so could start to introduce some of the congestion and unreliability that is accepted as a fact of life in 2.4 GHz, to the mmWave region.
The companies have written a collective letter to Marlene Dortch, secretary of the FCC, calling on the US regulator to address a range of technical and policy issues, particularly related to potential interference from drones and other radar-based systems. They are specifically reacting to requests from two companies, seeking FCC waivers and permission to use 60 GHz. These are Leica Geosystems, which wants to operate drones in the 60-64 GHz section of the band; and Vayyar Imaging, which wants to use its interactive motion sensing technology in the 57-64 GHz range.
“These waiver requests, which both seek the FCC’s permission to operate unlicensed radar equipment at higher power levels than currently allowed for such equipment under FCC Rule Section 15.255, exemplify the growing interest across industry in new wireless technologies that seek to use the 60 GHz band,” reads the letter. “These recurring requests for special relief outside of the current FCC rules confirm the need for the FCC to improve its regulatory framework governing unlicensed use of the 60 GHz band.”
Vendors and service providers are interested in the potential to operate across a combination of licensed and unlicensed mmWave bands to improve the economics of supporting applications with very high capacity requirements, or with a combination of capabilities needed.
Dean Brenner, Qualcomm’s SVP for spectrum strategy and technology policy, pointed out that there has been “a lot of cross-pollination between our original work for 60 GHz, which predated 5G, then a lot of that work became highly relevant when the FCC started looking at mmWave for 5G”. There is clearly a fear that all that investment in advanced antennas that can use multiple mmWave bands efficiently will be compromised if the 60 GHz portion becomes less usable. That could even drive up prices for the licensed mmWave bands, which have been on the rise, on a per-MHz/POP basis, in the USA.
Another key interest for Qualcomm lies in its aggressive championing of cellular technologies in unlicensed spectrum. Although it is a major WiFi chipset maker, thanks to its Atheros acquisition, its biggest differentiation lies in cellular, or highly integrated WiFi/cellular, products. Just as Qualcomm spearheaded work on unlicensed spectrum support for LTE, including driving the MulteFire technology, so it is leading standardization of 5G in unlicensed and shared spectrum, which will first appear in upcoming Release 16 and Release 17 specifications. This is another reason why the firm will be hostile to anything that compromises the quality and usability of a generous slice of spectrum that could be used for 5G-Unlicensed.
John Kuzin, the chip provider’s regulatory counsel for government affairs, said in the filing: “Any unlicensed band can also be used for 5G, and our unlicensed technology for this band can support both WiFi and 5G on the communications element.” 3GPP’s Release 17, due late next year, will expand the 5G standards to the 60 GHz band (the first 5G-U specs will be for lower bands such as 5 GHz).
Facebook’s presence in the new group points to its interest in 60 GHz as a high capacity, low cost band that is well-suited to extending Internet access (and with it, Facebook services) to the underserved round the world. The company has developed a 60 GHz platform for fixed wireless and backhaul, called Terragraph, whose specs are open to vendors to implement in their own products via the Telecom Infra Project (TIP). Facebook says Terragraph delivers fiber-like speeds with a distributed mesh of 60 GHz radios, targeting city districts with poor coverage, especially indoors, as well as rural access.
All the participants have an interest in maintaining the quality of the 60 GHz band in order to maximize the opportunities for their chips, services and infrastructure products, and to prevent any backlash against using unlicensed mmWave spectrum as a complement to 5G.
Of course, there is always a difficult balance to strike between encouraging innovation in unlicensed spectrum, and ensuring fair usage for all, and it can present one of the thorniest problems, especially for telecoms regulators whose main focus is on the more defined area of licensed bands. In the past, valuable services have been thwarted because of interference claims from incumbents, some more justified than others. The USA has seen the failure of the plan for a wholesale cellular network to extend enterprise and IoT services, because of the GPS community’s fears of the impact from LightSquared (later reborn as Ligado) on their adjacent frequencies. But it can also be argued that unfettered usage in bands like 2.4 GHz, while driving a broad ecosystem and affordable services, have also led to chaos and poor quality of experience.
The 60 GHz group are not, for now at least, proposing any specific restrictions on usage in the mmWave band. They are just asking for clarity for all potential users as interest rises from increasingly diverse organizations, especially those with higher powered devices such as radar and field disturbance sensors. A comprehensive rule-making process by the FCC would encourage full discussion, and eventually some clear rules to support reasonable coexistence.