Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2006

Qualcomm-BSkyB trial could have far reaching implications for mobile media

Hard on the heels of its deal with Microsoft to cooperate on CDMA/Windows handsets, Qualcomm is dangling the prospect of another huge boost to its wireless multimedia strategy, with a trial with one of the biggest content businesses on the planet, News Corp.

The initial agreement is for a trial of Qualcomm’s MediaFLO mobile TV datacasting technology by News Corp’s UK satellite TV arm BSkyB. This trial will now join the existing UK mobile TV tests – DVB-H pilots by Arquiva and O2 and the British Telecom/Virgin Mobile service, Movio, which will use DAB Enhanced Packet Mode technology.

Suddenly the UK, once expected to be a laggard in clearing spectrum for mobile TV, has become a hotbed. Presumably the latest trial is targeted at clearing the way for a full service launch on the back of a BSkyB bid for UK spectrum.

UK regulator Ofcom has committed to auctioning spectrum early next year which is ideal for use in mobile TV networks. It will make space for a 40MHz slice of spectrum in the 1452 to 1492MHz range on a technology and application-neutral basis by March 2007. However Qualcomm would have to adjust the spectrum that MediaFLO works in, and potentially fit it to an 8MHz PAL TV channel.

It is likely that any partnership between News Corp and Qualcomm will not end there, and if the trial is successful we would expect News Corp to become a full member of the alliance building between the CDMA giant and Microsoft, adding a content giant that controls Fox TV, Twentieth Century Fox, DirecTV and satellite TV operations all over the world. Parent News Corp also owns the MySpace and IGN games web properties.

News Corp needs a return path desperately for its ‘single play’ satellite TV, in order to drive a triple play bundle including voice and data, alongside its TV services, which will drive down its runaway churn of 1.45% a month. It has talked about buying or building a broadband wireless network in the US, possibly in cooperation with satellite TV rival Echostar, but one route could be to tap the other technologies that Qualcomm offers, in particular its Flarion Flash OFDM technology, to build such a network.

Globally, trials for mobile TV services have been in a number of spectrum bands, around 220MHz, in 600-700MHz and L-Band in 1670MHz.

News Corp is relatively expert at bidding for spectrum assets and has the knowhow of extracting the maximum value from spectrum once it owns it, something that only mobile operators might claim they can also manage. News Corp can also acquire content at a huge discount compared to others, and can therefore afford to pay more for the spectrum and still support a profitable business model.

Of the 40MHz, Ofcom expects to put about 12.5MHz into satellite radio, leaving 27.5MHz up for grabs in either one or two chunks. If 27.5 MHz was all used for mobile TV as suggested, especially if it turns out that the MediaFLO technology is used, then as many as 80 TV channels could be created, offering QVGA pixel density, about a quarter of that on a PC VGA screen. This would tie up the leadership in the UK for mobile TV market at a stroke, and leave precious little room for DVB-H and DAB Enhanced Packet Mode driven services, crushing O2 and BT’s efforts. A better division of the spectrum would be into three slices of about 9MHz each, to create competition in the market.

While BT already has spectrum to launch its service, without opening the bidding for at least two licenses, the UK would risk having no DVB-H technology provider, which would be dangerous given the weight of effort behind DVB-H which may lead to greater global economies of scale and cheaper devices.

The UK is running a poor fourth in Europe in terms of rolling out mobile TV, behind Germany, Italy and Finland, which all have planned services, and until this announcement was substantially behind the US.

Microsoft ‘ and even BSkyB’s only mobile TV partner to date, Vodafone Italy ‘ could also become part of this structure in the medium term. Microsoft and Qualcomm could extend their initial handset deal (see Wireless Watch May 8 2006 edition) to other areas, such as allowing Microsoft to provide the ad serving technology, using its adCenter product, to drive the delivery of key demographics from multiple viewing platforms, such as IPTV, mobile TV and MSN and web search.

The idea behind adCenter is to provide advertisers with a one-stop-shop experience, whether buying search, contextual or display ads, or video ads across a number of Microsoft properties, which now also includes inside Xbox games with last week’s purchase of Massive, the in-game advertising network.

The MediaFLO trials with BSkyB will begin this summer, and the technical trial will feature 10 channels of BSkyB content on a small number of non-commercial devices provided by Qualcomm. MediaFLO phones have already been shown by Samsung and LG Electronics at this year’s CES show in January in the US.

While the BSkyB technical trial is expected to be the first trial of FLO technology in Europe, KDDI has also formed a joint venture with Qualcomm to explore the use of MediaFLO in Japan. Previously MediaFLO’s only other success has been in signing Verizon Wireless to sell the FLO services in the US, once they are up and running, which may not be until very late this year.

MediaFLO says that it supports over 30 streaming channels of QVGA-quality video (320×240 pixels) at up to 25 frames per second, plus 10 stereo audio channels and up to 800 minutes of distributed Clipcast content per day (short format video clips), all with an average channel switching time of less than two seconds. Qualcomm has committed to making FLO available on UMTS phones as well as the CDMA cellular format where Qualcomm is dominant.

News Corp already has the beginnings of its own MVNO in the US, delivered using its MySpace brand on top of an MVNO run by Earthlink and SK Telecom on the Sprint network.

SK Telecom already uses Verizon spectrum for enterprise mobility, and if MySpace decided to shift to Verizon, Qualcomm might be able to broker such a deal and bring EV-DO Rev B into play to complete a triple play for DirecTV entirely in cellular technologies. Sprint’s relationship with the DirecTV’s major cable operator enemies means that any major triple play deal couldn’t happen with Sprint and DirecTV, without ruining the sprint relationship with cable.

It is a small step indeed for Fox to offer MediaFLO some of its content, and ad sales clout and to remarket the MediaFLO service in the US, in competition or cooperation with Verizon, and at the same time take a stake in the entire MediaFLO business, and we would guess that this is already being discussed. In return Qualcomm might apply its huge engineering intelligence to solving that triple play problem for News Corp using purely modern cellular broadband wireless.

Rumors of CDMA’s death exaggerated?

All Qualcomm’s activities in multimedia, and in networks and software that are can work on non-CDMA networks, show it seeking to expand its revenue base, and also to prepare for the potential fall-off of investment in CDMA2000 by carriers. Applying its technologies to W-CDMA, not just in chips but also applications, will be important as 3G expands, but MediaFLO shows that Qualcomm is also aware of the possible challenge from non-traditional wireless systems, and the likely rise of dedicated single-service networks. Mobile television is the most high profile of these, but others include the separate m-commerce systems planned by the major Japanese carriers.

We believe the notion that the CDMA market is in its last generation to be exaggerated, but much will depend on decisions made by some key operators over the coming few years as to whether they base their next wireless evolution on new iterations of CDMA2000 or move to W-CDMA, mobile broadband technologies or a hybrid system. Commentators who are negative about the chances for Qualcomm’s homegrown network, such as CSFB’s Eiji Aono, argue that subscriber growth will continue for at least five years, and so will drive some network expansion, but that there will be no more major deployments.

And such predictions are turning high levels of attention on operators that are shifting away from CDMA, notably Telstra of Australia and the Koreans. The Korean government has backed efforts by its carriers to reduce dependence on Qualcomm technologies and so limit royalties payments, which the Korean Ministry of Information and Communication recently said had totalled $2.63bn in the past decade for domestic handset makers such as Samsung and LG. Among these efforts have been the creation of homegrown platforms such as WIPI for content download and Wi-Bro for mobile broadband.

Predictably, the GSM Association is adding fuel to the fire of rumors of CDMA’s decline, claiming carriers are recognizing that GSM/UMTS will bring them global harmonization and the attractive economics of a mass volume platform. There are ‘unprecedented economies of scale in the supply of equipment for carriers and handsets for consumers’, the GSMA said.

Telstra is to phase out CDMA and deploy W-CDMA in 850MHz across Australia, while South Korea’s KTF is to switch focus from its CDMA network to a new nationwide W-CDMA/HSDPA network covering 84 cities by the end of the year, citing economic efficiencies, global roaming, handset availability, economies of scale and potential revenue gains from high speed services. These moves will fuel a market in an 850MHz profile for UMTS, though how important this will be outside North America, where the band is used for 3G by Cingular and Rogers Wireless, is still in some doubt. Decisions in India, in particular, and by major CDMA backers like Sprint and Verizon, will be far more important in deciding the future of CDMA2000. And it is hard to ignore the fact that the death of the CDMA platforms has been predicted for at least five years, yet Qualcomm regularly comes back with better than expected growth figures, even in unexpected markets like sub-$50 handsets. We should not write off CDMA2000, as long as Qualcomm continues to drive an agenda where it can be combined with other technologies to improve functionality and reduce risk.

CDMA contentions:

The CDMA Development Group (CDG) has hit back against speculation that its technology was in decline, claiming that CDMA EV-DO subscriptions are growing at a rate of 230% a year and that the technology has a three-year lead in wireless broadband.

“CDMA2000 has had a three-year lead in wireless broadband and is now deployed in 55 countries, serving close to 30m users worldwide,” said Perry LaForge, executive director of the CDG. There are now 35 live networks and 37 more in deployment.

Among the highlights cited by the CDG are that 2% of CDMA2000 subscribers are already using broadband, and the number of users is growing at 4m per quarter. For SK Telecom in Korea, EV-DO already accounts for over 40% of the operator’s subscriber base, and Japan’s KDDI has found that more than half of new subscriptions to its WIN 1xEV-DO services are new customers.

According to the GSMA, more than 105 mobile networks have launched commercial W-CDMA networks across 50 countries so far. Following the world’s first large scale commercial launch of HSDPA – the next evolution of W-CDMA – by Cingular Wireless last year in the US, more than 95 operators from 48 countries are deploying, or have announced plans to deploy the technology. Already, 18 mobile networks are providing live commercial W-CDMA/ HSDPA services. A number of networks have already announced deployment of W-CDMA/HSDPA in the 850MHz frequency band, including Cingular Wireless, Telstra in Australia and Rogers Wireless.

Chinook Wireless

The US is covered with small regional cellcos, and some of these are starting to swap out CDMA, seeing the GSM family as lower risk. Nokia recently won a contract with Chinook Wireless to build a GSM/GPRS/EDGE network across Montana, to replace a CDMA system.

Chinook Wireless was formed in May 2005 to purchase the CDMA wireless operations of Montana-based Blackfoot Communications and 3 Rivers Telecommunications. At the time, the carrier said its wireless operations would include networks in Butte, Bozeman, Billings, Helena, Great Falls, Kalispell and Missoula, Mont.

TechFaith:

Another indicator of the convergence of the Qualcomm and Microsoft agendas ‘ less than two months after Qualcomm formed a joint venture with Chinese wireless software house TechFaith, focused on user interfaces and applications for CDMA, Microsoft has teamed up with the same company to advanced Windows Mobile and Windows media in China.

The companies agreed to establish a strategic alliance to promote the use of these two platforms and will collaborate to improve the user experience and market share of Windows Mobile devices. The companies also have pledged to work to reduce the time to market and lower development costs.

The partnership covers smartphone and entertainment handset product development, application development, collaborative sales and marketing and an exchange of talent and technology.

Part of this analysis was originally published by our sister analyst service, Faultline, which focuses on broadband digital media and triple play models.