Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 January 2006

Qualcomm could challenge WiMAX under banner of a revived 802.20

Since Qualcomm decided to acquire OFDM start-up Flarion last year, there has been intense speculation over what exactly the CDMA giant would do with its new unit’s Flash-OFDM technology. Now, with the finalization of the deal looming, we can expect the chip designer to be more forthcoming about its plans, and we expect these to include a direct alternative to mobile WiMAX, and one based on a resurrection of another IEEE standard, 802.20 or Mobile-Fi.

It was clear when Qualcomm bought Flarion that, with all the key wireless standards moving towards a next generation centered on the OFDM physical layer, the company would want to amass its own patents and technology base in this area, both to provide a richer platform for the CDMA operator base and to go after new markets. Those new markets would include the mobile and converged fixed/mobile service providers targeted by the vendors of the upcoming 802.16e or mobile WiMAX systems. The Flarion deal made it clear that Qualcomm would not bow to pressure to join the WiMAX camp, but would, more characteristically, attempt to establish a de facto standard of its own.

However, creating industry standards and winning sufficiently broad support to spawn a volume market is a far more difficult game than when Qualcomm’s CDMA burst on the GSM-dominated scene, particularly given the industry hostility to the company’s royalty policies for its mass of patents. Flarion itself had sought to create a de facto standard around Flash-OFDM prior to the takeover, but despite keen interest from some big name operators, never looked likely to win, on its own, the large vendor and chipmaker backing required for success in the mainstream.

Qualcomm has far more industry clout, despite suspicion of its methods, but it must be aware that it will need to adjust its patent licensing approaches to an OFDM, all-IP world that no one vendor can hope to control. If it does so, it has the option, which we believe it will take, of trying to make its platform the basis of an open IEEE standard ‘ rather than its more traditional route of creating a de facto system that is then ratified by the 3GPP2 body. While it would have less control in the former case, and probably lower royalty rates, it would retain significant influence on the direction of standard ‘ as Intel and Samsung are demonstrating over at 802.16 ‘ and would gain the credibility of an open process with which to reassure customers and antitrust authorities.

Qualcomm has become more friendly of late to the idea of influencing, rather than dismissing, IEEE standards, recognizing that these can be integrated with CDMA to enhance the appeal of its chipsets to a wider range of vendors and carriers, and to provide a more flexible platform for mobile broadband data. It submitted an (unsuccessful) proposal to the 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standards group and has developed advanced CDMA/Wi-Fi chipsets for dual-mode handsets.

But the company still relies on controlling its key technologies, rather than following the crowd, in order to maximize its royalty revenue, responsiveness to the market, differentiation and margins. This is why we believe it will seek to co-opt the almost dormant 802.20 initiative rather than supporting WiMAX in the early stages. 802.20 was conceived specifically for highly mobile broadband wireless, and therefore fits more naturally into Qualcomm’s stable than 802.16e, which was originally designed for portability and limited mobility and has only recently ‘ as the agenda has shifted to target major carriers ‘ taken on the full mantle of mobile services. Despite huge R&D efforts, WiMAX will not achieve the same level of high speed mobile hand-off as the 3G technologies ‘ or Flash-OFDM ‘ for at least another year.

Initially, WiMAX will flourish in the mobile world primarily as a nomadic technology ‘ an expansion of Wi-Fi’s capabilities, mainly laptop-based ‘ and critically, as a convergence platform, spanning fixed broadband as well as portability. It has a headstart in supporting the increasingly important converged operator models, but lags in fully mobile services. Thus, with the 3G-plus systems (HSDPA and CDMA EV-DO) also advancing in terms of fixed and indoor usage, Qualcomm may hope that an accelerated 802.20 roadmap, supporting true mobility at vehicle speeds, may be able to sideline WiMAX as a complementary technology for cellular operators. Depending on spectrum and regulatory decisions, it could also appeal to wireline carriers, as WiMAX does, as a means of adding wireless services without 3G licenses, although with no focus on fixed usage, 802.20 will not be adequate as a convergence platform in the foreseeable future.

Mobile-Fi might be a natural fit for Qualcomm ‘ although, in the past, it has often been hostile to the activity ‘ but it is even more obvious for Flarion, which was a key contributor to the would-be standard in its early days. Together with Navini, which jumped ship to base its roadmap on 802.16e once the 802.20 initiative seemed to be sidelined by WiMAX, Flarion was the biggest name in Mobile-Fi.

But who needs another broadband wireless standard? Mobile-Fi would be even further behind than WiMAX in gaining critical spectrum and usage decisions from the world’s regulators or attracting real vendor and operator interest. Indeed, two years ago 802.20 appeared to have been stifled not only by the increasingly mobile remit of WiMAX but also by hostility from the 3G community, whose platforms it challenged more directly, at that stage, than 802.16e. Although Motorola, Cisco and, in the early days, Qualcomm itself were contributors, there were many accusations from Navini and others in 2003 that meetings were being packed and the agenda hijacked by key 3G players such as NTT DoCoMo and later Qualcomm too.

However, the world has moved on now. The 3G vendors and operators know that the next generation network will not be a single technology but a combination, including OFDM systems in the mobile broadband roadmap, and are now seeking to influence rather than divert that agenda. Many are looking to 802.16e, but Qualcomm and its close allies would be more interested in 802.20. It would still need to attract major vendor support though, something Flarion failed to do (with the exception of a partnership, mainly geared to 450MHz spectrum, with Siemens). And vendors are suspicious of Qualcomm’s iron control of its chosen markets.

There are reasons, though, why some vendors and operators might look kindly on Mobile-Fi, provided Qualcomm took a conciliatory stance on licensing. One is that some parties are starting to feel that Intel and Samsung are gaining a Qualcomm-style dominance of the WiMAX agenda; another is, of course, the superior mobility of Moble-Fi, important for some applications such as in-car entertainment; a third, and perhaps most important, one is the approach to IP.

A smooth migration to all-IP networks is one of the most important challenges facing large wireless operators, and both the 802.20 supporters and Qualcomm itself claim the upper hand in implementation of mobile IP. The more integral the support for IP, the cheaper and lower risk will be the move to merge and later migrate legacy systems with all-IP and key technologies such as the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS). This is sure to be Qualcomm’s killer card.

The stated mission of IEEE 802.20 is to develop a packet-based air interface optimized for transport of IP services, that will enable ‘worldwide deployment of affordable, ubiquitous, always-on and interoperable mobile broadband wireless access networks that meet the needs of business and residential markets’. It was designed from the outset, uniquely, to use IP ‘ which has been cobbled in to 3G and WiMAX. As with Wi-Fi and WiMAX, Mobile-Fi follows the IEEE model of designing a new PHY (physical layer or layer 1 protocol) and MAC (media access control or layer 2 protocol) around the IP packet (layer 3). Cellular 3G technologies are also incorporating IP by retrofitting their technologies and looking to full IP integration with 4G, but they use a circuit- rather than packet-based approach. The circuit-based route involves high latency and poor reliability, which have forced 3G adaptations into cumbersome workarounds such as spoofing and translation, and a centralized network architecture that goes against the nature of distributed IP.

WiMAX standards do not define the Layer 3 standard, which is key to radio resource management, hand-off and power control and other features that make mobility seamless. As a recent research note from Deutsche Bank put it: ‘Qualcomm dominates this space with its IP position. Any attempts to define this layer will draw the scrutiny of Qualcomm and could cause further delays to an already lagging [WiMAX 802.16e] standard.’

The case is not as clear cut as this. There is significant work being done on Mobile IP and on legacy-WiMAX integration, with large sums being spent by such luminaries in the field as Motorola. And if Qualcomm, as seems likely, feels that it will do better to challenge WiMAX under the banner of an industry standard rather than with proprietary technology, it will suffer the same delayed timescales as its rival, with 802.20 not yet even ratified. But Flash-OFDM is a significant weapon for Qualcomm, bringing OFDM and all-IP into a portfolio that is already more advanced in mobile data and IP capabilities than most alternatives. WiMAX has the huge market advantage, but it will not have the race all to itself.

BOX: The FLO standard

The FLO Forum, the industry body that supports Qualcomm’s FLO mobile broadcasting technology, has officially submitting the its air interface specification to a Telecommunications Industry Association (TIA) subcommittee, as a step towards global harmonization.

The Rorum is preparing additional specifications, including minimum performance requirements for FLO devices and transmitters, which are expected to be ready for submission to standards organizations early this year.