Japanese operators, in each mobile generation, have blazed the trail for new architectures and advanced services, and 5G is no different. New mobile entrant Rakuten has claimed many of the headlines for its ambitious plan to deploy a fully cloud-native end-to-end network with open interfaces, but incumbent MNOs NTT Docomo, KDDI and Softbank are also taking creative technical and service approaches, and generating welcome new revenues for vendors.
Assuming the global coronavirus panic doesn’t wreck the Tokyo Olympics this summer, the games are providing a deadline for the operators to be able to showcase their 5G services, at least in the big cities.
Despite delays and unexpectedly tough challenges, Rakuten has now set a revised but firm date to launch its commercial services – April 8 – though these will be 4G at first, with 5G due to follow in June. As yet, there are no indications of pricing, though this is expected to be disruptive. Rakuten has launched an own-branded phone and messaging/RCS service, called Rakuten Mini and Rakuten Link respectively – a tactic with strong echoes of Reliance Jio, where chief architecture officer Tareq Amin was previously CTO.
Amin and CEO Hiroshi Mikitani, gave an update on network progress at a virtual event hosted by Qualcomm, which should have taken place at Mobile World Congress. Amin was keen to debunk claims made by US Attorney General William Barr that Rakuten’s open RAN platform was “pie in the sky. This approach is completely untested, and would take many years to get off the ground, and would not be ready for prime time for a decade, if ever”.
It is unclear why Barr thought he had become an overnight expert on mobile architectures, or why he was so critical of a platform which is being supported by the non-Chinese vendors the USA aims to bolster – including US companies like Cisco and Altiostar. It appeared to be a bid to downplay any innovation that was being made outside the USA, not just in China.
Amin – a man with far more experience of mobile roll-outs than Barr, having previously been at Reliance Jio and T-Mobile (and Huawei) – insisted his network was “pie in the sky” but was “delivering cost savings that are unimaginable”. This would have raised the hopes of Dish Network (see separate item), which – despite Barr’s scepticism – has cited Rakuten as a template for how it can achieve its own US 5G roll-out at low cost. However, Rakuten’s Japanese rivals have expressed doubts that the company really can achieve its cost targets.
In April 2018, the ecommerce and content provider was allocated 2×20 MHz of 1.7 GHz spectrum plus unpaired airwaves in 3.4 GHz, with the Japanese Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications saying it wanted to stimulate more competition, and lower prices, in a market dominated by the three big players. Rakuten aims to reach 96% of the population within six years, and to sign up 10m subscribers by the end of fiscal year 2028. Its plan is to invest about ¥526bn ($4.7bn) in that roll-out, over five years, a figure it has already reduced from an initial estimate of ¥600bn ($5.4bn), but the number does not include an additional $1.8bn for upgrading to 5G.
By contrast, NTT Docomo has said that it will spend ¥200 ($1.8bn) a year between 2019 and 2024 on 5G alone. The telco’s total capex spend in the 2018 fiscal year (to March 31) was ¥576.4bn ($5.1bn). This shows how a new entrant can (and must) deploy with a far lower cost base, leveraging cloud architectures, but also a considerable degree of outsourcing and asset sharing – Rakuten has an infrastructure partnership with several Japanese utilities, for instance, as well as a roaming arrangement with KDDI.
At the event last week, Amin said there are now 3,200 cell sites in operation in the area encompassing the three major cities of Tokyo, Nagoya and Osaka. This should rise to 4,400 by April 8, which Amin said was one of the most dense networks every deployed. Rakuten achieves this because: “We control the software layer across macro, micro, small cell, WiFi, and they are unified. They’re working as one heterogenous unit, harmonious in terms of what it needs to do.” Distance between cell sites is less than 200 meters.
There is an inhouse team of 130 engineers, and Amin says these can install a new radio/antenna in about eight minutes, compared with three days for a traditional macrosite. The small cells and radio heads come from Airspan and Nokia, and the virtualized RAN baseband software from Altiostar, running on Intel/Cisco hardware and Red Hat cloud infrastructure. Nokia is also providing and managing the cloud-native core, and Rakuten is currently migrating functions that were initially deployed as virtual machines, to a containerized architecture.
The design, Amin claimed, reduces capex by about 40% compared to a conventional network of the same scale, and opex by about 30%.
“There’s no longer a debate, does this work or not, we’ve achieved a capacity level that is really unprecedented on what you could do in maximizing throughput per sector, capacity per sector,” he said.
He claimed this network is supporting 99.7% availability as it scales up from 5,000 users added on a commercial trial basis in October 2019 (the originally scheduled full launch date) to 20,000 added in January 2020.
Mikitani told the audience that the original plan had been to build a conventional wireless network, working with Huawei, but – in what should have been music to Barr’s ears – it had instead listened to newly appointed Amin, who said new operators’ networks would owe more to Netflix than Vodafone. That meant cloud-native technology, common cloud infrastructure and COTS servers, open interfaces such as the fronthaul link from ORAN Alliance (see separate item), and a multivendor supplier line-up. Vendors are mainly from the USA and Japan, but Nokia and Tech Mahindra also play significant roles (see separate Rakuten story for full line-up).
With most of the mobile world watching Rakuten closely to see whether its network really does fulfil its cost and performance promises, there is an opportunity for the Japanese firm to export its architecture and knowledge to other markets. It has hinted that – like a select few other advanced MNOs in the past, such as SK Telecom and NTT Docomo – it could either license some of its systems to other operators or contribute them to open industry platforms like ORAN Alliance. Or it could leverage the repeatability of a common cloud architecture to roll out relatively easily itself, in other markets.
“We intend to export what we have built outside of Japan as well,” said Mikitani.
“Rakuten Mobile is not just about Japanese mobile network operator service, but we want to become – together with Qualcomm and others – a global MNO platform service.”
This would be in line with the cloud economics of the parent company, which involve replicating services, including video content and financial services, and now mobile applications, in many countries, taking advantages of the economies of scale of a common cloud platform.
Rakuten’s web services, including online banking, mobile payments and messaging, now have 1.4bn users round the world.
The first indication of this international ambition is a partnership between Rakuten and Singapore’s newest mobile entrant, TPG, to test open RAN systems. This could see TPG taking advantage of the experience Rakuten has gained from its own challenging roll-out, and the work it has done to harden open interfaces into robust commercial units.
Rakuten said that other operators can benefit from flexibility and faster innovation if they use open, programmable RAN software running on disaggregated architectures and general purpose processors.
“The strategic partnership is a validation of Rakuten Mobile’s strategy and we are happy to share our innovative end-to-end virtualization solutions built on our vision of an open and multivendor mobile network ecosystem,” said Amin. “Singapore’s high fiber density makes it uniquely suited for rapid open RAN adoption and successful implementation.”
TPG, a subsidiary of Australia’s TPG Telecom Group, operates a 4G network in Singapore, and to date has signed up 300,000 customers. Its acting CEO, Richard Tan, said: “Such efforts can help to accelerate the adoption of next generation 5G mobile networks with software-defined technology based on open interfaces and community-developed standards running on open hardware.”