Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 February 2013

Refarming and aggregation ‘ key ways to match LTE capacity to video demand

One of the key themes of Mobile World Congress this year was how carriers could obtain more spectrum capacity. Auctions of LTE spectrum are still in the future in the majority of countries, but most operators already know that perfect virgin frequencies will not be enough to meet their needs, even if they can buy them. So the debate this year centered on unlicensed, refarmed and cobbled-together spectrum ‘ all the ways in which operators can add to their armories at relatively low cost.

Bringing Wi-Fi into the heart of the network ‘ in its traditional bands or emerging ones like TV white spaces and 60GHz ‘ was important, but so was the better use of spectrum cellcos already own. Refarming 2G bands is a gathering trend, with a global ecosystem forming around LTE in the 1.8GHz GSM frequencies. Some carriers are considering using the lower capacity 900MHz GSM band for LTE also, though the more common approach will be to use this for extra 3G capacity ‘ in those markets, still the majority, where operators expect to hold onto and enhance 3G for many years to come.

The decision about whether to rely on 2G or 3G for broad coverage while building out LTE ‘ or, in rare cases like Verizon and Docomo, to rush headlong towards a 4G-only network ‘ is a critical one, as it will shape carriers’ spectrum and flexible RAN requirements. There is a growing band of cellcos which believes it will hang onto GSM long after it switches off 3G. Telefonica O2 is just one firm which believes that, although it will continue to upgrade HSPA+, by the end of the decade it will be converting its 3G spectrum to LTE, while keeping GSM for universal coverage.

The converse strategy, to turn off 2G quickly and use even the 900MHz band for LTE, has mainly been seen in the Middle East so far, but is garnering some interest elsewhere. The UK cellcos have a project to accelerate refarming in 900MHz, which could include LTE, while there have been tests in Sweden, France and elsewhere. But many will be prevented from running LTE in 900MHz because of its low bandwidth. Huawei says more than half of operators looking to refarm this band have less than 5MHz of contiguous capacity.

That will increase the logic behind either hanging onto GSM, or refarming for UMTS, in this low frequency band. Huawei and Qualcomm were showing off a technology designed to make the band more usable for 3G. At MWC, they demonstrated Scalable UMTS, which supports 3G within a half bandwidth channel. Huawei says it is the first vendor to show off this capability, and the partners hope to make it part of 3GPP standards. If that happens, it is likely to be featured more heavily by vendors as cellcos in major emerging markets look to migrate to 3G.

Scalable UMTS is currently a 3GPP Release 12 study item and will be commercially available from Huawei. With Qualcomm, it completed end-to-end testing of a prototype in November 2012 at Huawei’s Shanghai laboratory and claims that the test showed that the technology, in a half-bandwidth channel, provides the same spectral efficiency as normal UMTS. The technology can be jointly deployed with Huawei’s UMTS Flexible Carrier Bandwidth solution to save spectrum in deploying small cells and improve network capacity.

Samir Soliman, VP of technology at Qualcomm Research, added: ‘Scalable UMTS was designed to help operators maximize the data capacity and value of their existing spectrum. With varied use cases of Scalable UMTS, this band-agnostic technology is beneficial to both emerging and developed regions. In emerging regions of the world, Scalable UMTS can accelerate GSM refarming, whereas in developed regions, the technology enables efficient utilization of spectrum resources.’

As well as refarming, the other big spectrum discussion centers on carrier aggregation, which allows several bands to be tied together and treated as a single resource. There are many ways to do CA in 3G and 4G, and some will be standardized in LTE Releases 10 and 11 ‘ this is the most common feature on the LTE-Advanced menu to be commercialized this year by chipmakers and vendors, though many barriers to mass adoption remain, notably device availability in the various combinations of frequencies.

One approach to carrier aggregation, which is gaining significant interest, is SDL (Supplemental Downlink), one of the techniques with which operators aim to make the most of fragmented spectrum holdings and formerly useless frequencies. It allows TDD spectrum in bands like 700MHz (as tested by AT&T) and L-band to provide additional downlink capacity for an FDD LTE or 3G network in a different frequency.

AT&T and Qualcomm have been working on this technology to make use of the 700MHz unpaired frequencies the carrier bought from the chipmaker (which previously used the spectrum for its MediaFLO mobile TV service). Now Qualcomm is talking about trials with another early moving carrier, Orange, which have been conducted in the L-band (1452-1492MHz) with Ericsson.

The European Union’s standards body, CEPT, green-lighted the use of this mobile satellite band for two-way mobile last year when it decided to harmonize the L-band and reserve it specifically for SDL. Orange was the first to act, obtaining trial licences in the French city of Toulouse from regulator Arcep in June 2012. The trial system combines this spectrum with Orange’s 2.1GHz 3G frequencies, and uses base stations from Ericsson and Qualcomm device prototypes. The first public demonstration was shown off last week.

Orange says SDL represents a significant step forward from traditional spectrum aggregation systems already in use for HSPA+ and LTE. ‘After two years of extensive studies, CEPT ECC decided to harmonise the L-band for supplemental downlink. I am happy to see the industry materializing rapidly this decision which will generate substantial benefits to European users,” said Eric Fournier, chairman of the Electronic Communications Committee.

While Qualcomm sold its TDD 700MHz spectrum in the US to AT&T ‘ earning itself a strategic place in that operator’s LTE plan via the SDL trials ‘ it still owns similar frequencies in the UK, where it bought all 40MHz of the 1452-1492MHz spectrum when it came up for auction in 2007. At the time, UK regulator Ofcom said the band was ideal for use in mobile TV networks and auctioned it on a technology and application-neutral basis. But Qualcomm’s experiments with mobile TV failed and it is now focused on SDL, which allows the L-band to become part of existing cellular networks, using the same power sources and towers.

However, one of the primary reasons for using any SDL is still to support TV ‘ now likely to run on the evolved MBMS standard, which uses existing LTE networks, rather than requiring a dedicated infrastructure like Qualcomm’s defunct MediaFLO. Talking to Qualcomm executives at MWC, it seems that Snapdragon processors going forward all include hardware assists built in for HEVC, the emerging standard for encoding and decoding video. That means, according to Qualcomm, that a Snapdragon chip is now well equipped to drive an Ultra High Definition 4K screen and in future the potential is there to add 7.1 surround sound. The chips can also empower tablets to have real video editing functions.

The UK L-band spectrum alone might provide 100 Mbps of data delivery, which, if most of it were dedicated to broadcast video using eMBMS, might deliver anything up to 100 TV channels, perhaps more using HEVC. So it is clear where thoughts at Qualcomm, and many operator partners, are going with regards to this particular form of carrier aggregation ‘ and these TDD bands will end up supporting mobile TV after all, just in a more integrated way than originally envisaged.