The Indian government will be disappointed that only five operators are participating in the 1.8GHz spectrum auction, which starts on Monday. A larger number of bidders could have pushed prices upwards, and in particular, some insiders had hoped Reliance Industries (RIL) would use the auction as a route back into the mainstream mobile market.
RIL, which already holds national BWA spectrum in 2.5GHz, is not expected to confine its ambitions to that TD-LTE band. Once more mainstream FD-LTE spectrum is awarded in 700MHz and other bands ‘ probably from 2014 ‘ its own TDD network may well be pushed into a niche, supporting fixed services and offload for partners. RIL could acquire its own 700MHz spectrum and create a converged FD/TD-LTE system, turning itself into a 4G-only carrier with none of the burden of legacy technologies and ultra-low 2G ARPUs. However, it does need a roaming partner or access to a network with full coverage, if it wants to be a top tier cellco.
It has often been reported to be in talks with its own former sister firm, Reliance Communications, about a roaming-for-offload agreement or even a full joint venture. The Reliance group split acrimoniously in 2004 and the telecoms businesses went to RCom but in recent years non-compete clauses have expired and relations between the firms, which are run by two brothers, have thawed.
However, another route is now open to RIL. Sources indicate it could repeat the trick it pulled in the BWA auction of 2.3/2.5GHz spectrum in 2010. Then, it did not participate directly but immediately after the sale, acquired Infotel, a smaller WISP which was the only bidder to obtain national spectrum holdings. Now, it is possible that RIL will stay out of the 1.8GHz sale, keeping prices depressed, but will then acquire or partner with Videocon to gain access to that firm’s spectrum. Videocon itself won licences in the previous auction and launched GSM services in Mumbai, but had all its holdings revoked. It has been looking towards a bundled hardware/mobile access model, based on its significant business in making handsets and other devices. It pioneered a model of offering free minutes and texts on its network when consumers purchased certain of its handsets. However, it has no 3G spectrum and will remain a niche player without a larger partner on the telecoms side.
Five operators are in the running for the re-auctioned 1.8GHz GSM spectrum in India. The candidates will be Bharti Airtel, Idea Cellular, Vodafone India, Videocon and Telenor’s new joint venture, Telewings. Of the applicants, Videocon, Idea and Telenor (through its previous JV Uninor), are returning to the fray after the licence cancellations. But other previous holders of these licences, such as S Tel and UAE’s Etisalat, have backed away, while Bharti and Vodafone are new bidders, looking to bolster their existing 2G holdings.
Also, the Department of Telecom is likely to have to cancel a concurrent auction of 800MHz CDMA spectrum because there are no bidders remaining after the last one, Tata Teleservices, withdrew its application. Videcon had also previously pulled out.
Meanwhile, Indian operators have been told they can retain about 2.5MHz of their 900MHz GSM spectrum, when the country switches to 1.8GHz airwaves, which have more limited coverage and in many parts of India, deliver lower quality of service. Keeping some of the original spectrum should mitigate the risk of losing connectivity following the switchover though the cellcos will have to pay auction prices to retain 900MHz capacity. The auction for the 900MHz spectrum that will be retained will be conducted by March.