The spat between Wi-Fi MIMO specialist Ruckus and Wi-Fi router maker Netgear seems to come down to simple economics. Ruckus is suing Netgear, along with its new MIMO antenna supplier Rayspan, for patent infringement, over the antenna designs and associated software that have replaced the Beamflex technology which Netgear used to buy from Ruckus. The suit was brought in the US Court for the Northern District of California last week.
The two patents specifically refer to antenna designs using multiple selectable horizontal and vertical elements, and the RF circuit board to which they are connected. Rayspan was founded in 2006, to build air interfaces using what it calls ‘metamaterials’, which enable ultra-compact MIMO antennas. It says that its antennas work with fixed and mobile wireless Wans, Lans and personal area networks including 3G, WiMAX, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and GPS.
For two generations, the Netgear 824 RangeMax wireless router used the more expensive Ruckus antenna, and Ruckus is implying it shared quite a few secrets with its customer. But Netgear is facing a period of slowdown. Its revenues did rise last quarter, to $198m from $173m, but its margins fell and its expenses were up 20%. Clearly Rayspan knocked on the door with a cheaper technology in a tightening climate and received a relieved welcome.
It’s going to be a tough old transition to MIMO architectures if every time a new MIMO approach is used, there is a patent suit, but Ruckus reckons its has 70 patents granted or pending in the area of intelligent antenna or wireless technology innovation. Its system has six directional antenna built-in and is constantly dynamically searching for the best route around a home. There are 63 different discrete patterns that its wireless gateway can select to avoid interference. Ruckus systems also have a feedback loop built into them and an ability to resend lost packets. Even with its beamforming approach, Ruckus Wi-Fi still loses the odd packet, so the packet retransmission is essential as video is highly susceptible to packet error.
All of this makes it possible for Ruckus to send uninterrupted video around a home, and that now includes HD video on its new product ranges. Netgear so far has not tried to compete here and really just uses the beamforming in previous generations of its Wi-Fi routers to offer a more reliable data path around the home which can be sensed further away. But that’s not to say that now it is working with Rayspan that it won’t go down the video delivery route and become a Ruckus rival, pitching its devices at IPTV operators. Perhaps that fear is driving this suit.
In order to step up to the TV Wi-Fi market, Netgear would also have to provide software that competes with the Ruckus SmartCast technology, the traffic inspection and classification engine which provides RF monitoring, quality of service and application aware content parsing.
In its complaint, Ruckus Wireless seeks a permanent injunction barring Netgear and Rayspan from making, using, importing, offering to sell or selling the allegedly infringing products and it is also seeking damages.