Access to cellular phone services is increasingly regarded as a right rather than a luxury, even in very remote communities, which are often economically non-viable for operators to cover, without government subsidies, using conventional base stations. This product becomes even worse with 3G, because of the density of base stations required, which is inappropriate for sparse populations, but there are many areas, even in developed economies, that still lack even GSM service. Various approaches are making it more practical to target such regions, including compact or portable GSM stations and CDMA450, and in future, in many terrains mobile WiMAX may prove a more cost effective option than 3G.
Very rural areas of Europe are increasingly interested in using 450MHz spectrum, which is being vacated by analog telephony, for rural areas because it supports long distances and high spectral efficiency. CDMA450 is the main solution, with Flash-OFDM and IPWireless also readying versions of their networks for this spectrum. In the US, there is high interest among rural carriers in being able to access the analog television bands around 700MHz, with technologies such as WiMAX or CDMA, again because of the support for large cells and so the ability to reach a respectable number of subscribers even in an underpopulated area..
One of the most interesting short term solutions is the compact GSM station. Most of the large vendors have such a product but smaller suppliers are seeing an opportunity to develop a new revenue stream and gain a strong position in a market that is still of marginal interest to the large operators, and so to the large equipment makers. Alvarion, for instance, acquired mini-base station specialist interWave last year, partly to import expertise for its WiMAX roadmap in mobility and compact base stations ‘ both areas where it was perceived to be somewhat weak ‘ but also to generate new revenue while it faced the transition period from proprietary to WiMAX broadband wireless.
Some of the deals it has won through its new unit show the typical scope of these specialist miniature base stations. Around the time of the acquisition, Alvarion/interWave received a contract to roll out a GSM network in Russia for Gorizont-RT, the telecom operator in the Republic of Sakha, in the Arctic Circle. Sakha is the largest and most remote of the autonomous republics in the Russian Federation and was previously called Yakutia. Spanning three time zones and with 40% of its territory above the Arctic Circle, Sakha’s population centers are dispersed across a wide geographic area.
And last week it announced that Cable and Wireless would use its compact GSM systems to provide cellular voice, for the first time, to the Falkland Islands in the South Atlantic, with a system that will cost just $1.5m.
‘We look forward to completing the island deployment as it is the perfect application for our GSM network that reaches the unreachable,’ said Zvi Slonimsky, CEO of Alvarion.
But Alvarion’s plans also illustrate why the compact base station makers may play a more important role than just addressing remote markets that are of little interest to the majors. Some of the technologies they increasingly rely on, such as software defined radios ‘ to support multiple links depending on what is available in a given spot ‘ or pico base stations, are very important to future generations of mainstream 3G and broadband wireless technologies for improving coverage, especially in buildings, plus supporting multiple networks flexibly in an ‘always best connected’ manner that should improve the user experience. So some vendors are seeing rural compact base stations as a way to infiltrate markets through the back door and gain a springboard for the next generation of their more mainstream networks. Samsung’s launch of mini CDMA base stations for rural and other under-covered parts of the US represent such a prelude to future introduction of Wi-Bro, WiMAX, CDMA and multi-network platforms, and ZTE’s intensive activity in the CDMA450 market carries similar longer term objectives.
In buying interWave, which makes compact GSM and CDMA base stations and softswitches for integrating those technologies with IP, Alvarion promised its operators the ability to extend the edges of their cellular networks, or to backhaul them, at low cost using an all-IP long distance link combined with local switching in the combined GSM/IP base station (that link can, of course, be provided by WiMAX). Such products, though confined to a niche in poor or rural communities, are nowadays pointing the way to a far larger trend towards integrated networks, and show why interWave could be far more strategic to Alvarion than the $56m price tag would suggest, as well as bringing some expertise in mobile networks.
Alvarion is also preparing a low cost CDMA compact base station, based on interWave technology, targeted at areas that are not cost effective to cover with WiMAX in its first generation form. Alvarion believes that about 25% of rural and developing economy markets have such sparse populations and/or low income levels that WiMAX will be non-viable until costs come down dramatically and micro base stations are commonplace. Until then, low end CDMA2000 equipment supporting fixed wireless can cover very large distances with high spectral efficiency and resulting low cost per subscriber, especially in the 450MHz band, where this is open. The Alvarion Breeze2000 will be IP-based with its own self-contained switch, will support data rates up to 153Kbps and will be available for 450MHz, 850MHz, 1.9GHz and 2.1GHz bands.
Sofware defined radios can also be a major boost to the viability of cellular networks in very rural areas and a pioneer of compact base stations using this technology has been Vanu. The company, which grew out of the MIT Spectrumware Project, and in 1996 produced the first working software radio outside the military, has an architecture with three hardware components, an operating system layer and two stacks of application level software layers. Each hardware component has a control interface that allows the application to control and monitor hardware components through device drivers in the operating system. The hardware components, operating system and device drivers comprise the software radio platform. Regardless of the implementation, the basic system architecture remains the same.
Vanu and Mid-Tex Cellular deployed the world’s first all-software GSM base station in a commercial network in 2003, using Vanu’s Software Radio in the operator’s 8,000 square mile network. The demonstration showed how SDRs may offer more cost efficient and flexible options to hard pressed rural cellcos and encourage roll-out of services to underserved areas round the world.
This month, Vanu has won a deal with Ice Wireless of Inuvik, Northwest Territories, Canada, which is using the Anywave GSM Base Station system to introduce cellular service to remote Canadian communities in the extreme northern region, an area two-thirds the size of the continental US. Ice will also offer roaming for more mainstream operators. Anywave takes the Vanu software radio and implements is as a software application on off-the-shelf servers, in this case from Dell and Hewlett Packard, which work as base stations and so are far cheaper to instal and run than specialized hardware, for operators finding it hard to make margins because of low population size. Anywave’s ability simultaneously to implement multiple wireless standards on a single network also provides a significant cost benefit and new revenue generating opportunities for rural operators, and will allow them to introduce new technologies in future without an expensive hardware upgrade. Critically for niche operators, this will enable them to support roaming services for larger carriers with different networks from GSM to CDMA to WiMAX.
Flexible configurations and low cost build-out will be key to getting wireless services to remote areas of the world and will support the spread of all three major network options. Innovators in this area, such as interWave, Vanu and the UK’s PicoChip, should all find that, as the larger companies take an interest in rural access and multi-network systems, their status is enhanced.