Most of the campaigns for open access, rather than carrier lock-ins, have come from the internet community, looking to encourage disruptive operators that will accelerate the emergence of the open mobile web. But now the US’ rural carriers have joined the fight, demanding an end to operator exclusives which, they claim, deny smaller players the ability to offer the most attractive handsets.
The interests of the mobile internet and rural access factions often collide, despite their very different businesses, because both need to reduce the dominance of the leading cellcos in order to thrive. This was clear in the run-up to the 700MHz auction, when the spectrum was held up as the great white hope for cost-effective rural coverage and for supporting new mobile providers. In fact, of course, Verizon and AT&T got the lion’s share, and while they have been forced to make some concessions to openness, these will only make them stronger in keeping smaller challengers sidelined. And the rural players remain, in many areas, short of spectrum to launch advanced services, while facing a heightened move by the majors to address rural areas directly, rather than through partners or roaming deals.
Rural mobile operators have petitioned the FCC to investigate exclusive deals between major carriers and handset vendors, saying this is anti-competitive and denies rural residents in many states access to popular devices like the iPhone. It is asking for deals with the top five ‘ AT&T, Verizon Wireless, Sprint Nextel, T-Mobile USA and Alltel ‘ to be probed. For instance, the iPhone is not legally available to residents in Vermont, or in rural areas of Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Kansas, Maine, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota, Utah and Wyoming, states the complaint.
‘For many consumers, the end result of these exclusive arrangements is being channeled to purchase wireless service from a carrier that has monopolistic control over the desired handset and having to pay a premium price for the handset because the market is void of any competition for the particular handset,’ stated the Rural Cellular Association’s (RCA’s) petition. ‘For other consumers ‘ particularly rural ones ‘ these exclusivity arrangements prevent them from purchasing many of today’s most popular handsets because they reside in areas not served by the one carrier offering the desired handset.’
This creates yet another digital divide, argues the RCA, but the cellco association, the CTIA, retorted: ‘There are more than 620 unique wireless devices for sale to consumers in the US. These devices are designed and manufactured by no fewer than 35 companies. Furthermore, consumers can purchase handsets from a number of sources, including large nationwide electronics stores, independent retail stores, manufacturer stores and web sites, online auction sites, as well as carrier retail stores and web sites. This is a vibrantly competitive and healthy market which provides consumers with an abundance of handset choices.’
According to the RCA, most of the devices offered exclusively by one carrier are from LG and Samsung, as well as the famous iPhone of course. Verizon has 18 exclusives, AT&T has 14, T-Mobile 10, Sprint seven and Alltel six.