Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2006

Samsung claims mobile TV coup but DVB-H taking the lead

Samsung was declaring a major victory at 3GSM as three French mobile operators lined up to launch a T-DMB mobile TV trial in France. Until now, with the exception of British Telecom’s DAB based trial, this technology has been the exclusive preserve of Korea.

T-DMB is an extension of DAB and is a form of datacasting where intense bursts of video signals are recompiled on a mobile handset to make it appear like a real time broadcast but without killing the battery in no time flat. It is expected to be neck and neck in Korea with S-TMB, a completely different satellite version of the technology, and Samsung and LG Electronics are both pushing it as a global standard. ETSI, the European standards group, has endorsed both DVB-H, a standard pushed hard by Nokia and T-DMB, which does the same job but in a different way in different spectrum chunks.

But both German and French regulators have been in favor of there being at least one T-DMB trial alongside the multiple DVB-H trials in Europe. Under the agreement Samsung will collaborate with Bouygues Telecom, commercial broadcaster TF1 and digital network provider VDL, to evaluate pilot T-DMB services at the end of February, Samsung said. Other French trials include one run by TDF, a French cable operator recently bought by private equity player Cinven and Benelux cable operator Altice, and another run by TPS, a satellite TV player, which has just been bought by the CanalPlus parent, Vivendi Universal. CanalPlus is also running its own trial.

Samsung shipped its first T-DMB handsets to Bouygues last month. VDL is a network provider for digital audio broadcasts in France, and T-DMB can use existing DAB transmitters and spectrum. Samsung also unveiled its first T-DMB phone, the SGH-Z560, supporting HSDPA and speeds up to 3.6Mbps.

Still on the subject of mobile TV, NTT DoCoMo, Japan’s largest mobile operator, says it plans to offer mobile TV in Japan with Nippon Television Network, the country’s second largest broadcaster. There is no decision yet on which technology they might use, although both S-DMB and ISDB-T are both available for it to choose in Japan, and ISDB-T is supposed to be the standard for both digital TV and mobile TV. The two companies will each invest $42m to set up a fund that will consider ways to offer digital television services for mobile phones.

Finally, the WorlDAB Forum did its best to convince visitors to 3GSM that DAB is winning the war for mobile TV technology. The truth is that is it merely surviving. It counts among its successes BT Movio, which has also launched this week via Virgin Mobile TV, a reseller of the service, and in partnership with Microsoft. WorlDAB says there are 18 T-DMB trials around the world, including new ones announced for Germany and China for this year. WorlDAB says it will have shipped 2m phones with T-DMB by the end of 2006, but we remain skeptical. It showed a pilot at 3GSM, but apart from Samsung’s French trial, there seemed to be only illusory progress for T-DMB. The statement claimed there are trials in Germany, France, Holland, Norway, Italy, Spain, and China and plans for one in Taiwan this year. But the German trial is not up and running yet and the Chinese one runs head-to-head with a Nokia driven DVB-H trial.

DVB-H has been taken up by much of Europe, with trials or services announced in Italy, including a new one this week involving Vodafone; and in Germany, the UK, Spain, France, Sweden, the Netherlands, Finland, Switzerland, Denmark, Portugal and the Czech Republic. There are also DVB-H trials in the US, China and even in the T-DMB heartland of Korea, and in Japan, Kenya, Singapore, Australia, South Africa, Canada and Taiwan, while Nokia has just brought on board Indonesia and says Thailand and Russia will soon follow.

The Indonesian trial is with Emtek (Elang Mahkota Teknologi) Group, an emerging player in the country, which will begin its roll-out in the second half of 2006. Emtek is the parent company of broadcaster Meca and TV channel owner SCTV.

In a separate announcement Sony Ericsson and Nokia said they they can set up multivendor handsets in mobile TV services. Sony Ericsson devices will be introduced into existing Nokia DVB-H pilots later this year. The joint venture will have to work toward meeting Nokia’s Open Air Interface implementation guidelines, which the Finnish company has already made public. ‘Availability of interoperable DVB-H enabled mobile devices is crucial in opening up the mass market for broadcast mobile TV,’ said Ilkka Raiskinen, senior VP of Multimedia Experiences at Nokia.

Meanwhile, the Italian TV service, RAI, and Vodafone Italia are partnering to begin trials of DVB-H. Some of the experiments are being carried out at the current Winter Olympic games in Turin, using the Nokia 7710 handset and Nokia broadcasting equipment. Telecom Italia Mobile (TIM) and Italian broadcaster Mediaset have already agreed on DVB-H trials in Italy, announced last year, using content from Mediaset and Sky Italia, and when 3 Italia SpA subsequently said it would invest €220m ($260m) in bringing its own DVB-H network to Italy, TIM convinced it to merge its efforts into one mobile TV network, with access to the much prized Serie A Italian soccer league.