Samsung has escalated its patent fight with Apple still further, claiming the iPhone 5 violates its IPR, in the wake of a rare US victory against its rival. A court has lifted a ban on US sales of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet, imposed in June.
The Korean firm has added claims about Apple’s newest handset to its existing patent lawsuit in federal court in San Jose, the venue where it suffered the biggest defeat so far in the two firms’ multi-faceted global battle. Judge Lucy Koh presided over a jury trial which ended in a $1.05bn verdict against Samsung (damages which Apple is now seeking to treble, but a result which Samsung is appealing).
The world’s largest phonemaker has its own separate suit against Apple in San Jose and has now added allegations that the iPhone 5 infringes two standards-essential patents and six ‘features patents’. Samsung is far richer in the former type of IPR than its competitor, but such patents are more complicated to pursue in court because of Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) restrictions on how they are licensed and the level of royalties. Apple has mainly pursued feature and design patents, which are more easily worked around, but which it can license as it wishes (or refuse to license).
‘As soon as the iPhone 5 was available for purchase, Samsung began its investigation of the product,’ the Korean firm said in its court filing on Monday.
The company was riding on a rare high, having seen Judge Koh reverse a temporary ban on the Tab 10.1, which she imposed in June. Koh said there were no grounds for keeping the preliminary injunction in place ‘ one of the few bright points in the August verdict against Samsung was that the firm did not infringe the Apple design patent, which was the basis of the sales bar. Apple had argued that the injunction should stay in place because the jury had found that the Tab infringed other IPR.
The Tab 10.1 may hit the shelves again, but it is an ageing product and Apple’s lawyers are no doubt engaged in forensic examination of the vendor’s newer offerings. Meanwhile, the new iPhone 5 claims will not come to trial until 2014, by which time Apple will have launched one, if not two or more, new iPhones, and Samsung will have unleashed a host of devices. Samsung has been able to add the new handset to existing lawsuits because it is citing the same eight patents as in previous claims against older iPhones, as well as the iPad and iPod Touch.
Judge Koh has already awarded Apple a preliminary injunction against Samsung’s Galaxy Nexus smartphone, which brings the fight closer to direct confrontation with Android wizard Google, since the Nexus is a co-branded range. In August, Apple also added the new Galaxy S III handset to its own infringement lawsuits and said in a filing last month that it expects also to add claims about ‘recently released Samsung products, including the Android 4.1 Jelly Bean operating system and the Galaxy Note 10.1 device’. Again, the specific mention of the OS seems to indicate a move to get Google ‘ still hovering behind the scenes, except in regard to tussles with its new subsidiary Motorola Mobility ‘ in the ring in person.
Following the August verdict, which found Samsung guilty with regard to six out of seven patents cited, Koh has scheduled hearings in December, to consider Apple’s request for a permanent US sales ban on the Samsung models involved ‘ eight smarthphones and the Tab 10.1. She will also consider Samsung’s bid to get the verdict overturned based on claims of juror misconduct.
Along with Koh, the highest profile US judge in the Apple/Android patent wars has been Richard Posner, most famous for throwing out a major suit between Apple and Motorola. He has also placed many of the broader issues raised by the legal battles in the spotlight, and this week he lashed out against overuse of patent and copyright rights. In a blog post, he said companies were making “excessive” use of such protections, citing, in particular, the software and pharmaceutical industries. He pointed out that, because hi-tech devices are made up of thousands of elements, all potentially patentable, this creates “huge patent thickets”. This opens too many chances for opportunistic litigation, often too complex for judges and juries to assess accurately.
Appeals Court judge Posner has previously criticized individual players too. Before cancelling an Apple jury trial against Motorola in June, he accused the firm of filing ‘frivolous motions’ and also ridiculed Motorola’s case. In his latest pronouncements, he concluded: “My general sense, however, bolstered by an extensive academic literature, is that patent protection is on the whole excessive and that major reforms are necessary.”
At least the various judges will have one set of claims taken off their plates. In a surprise move, Google’s Motorola Mobility unit has withdrawn a complaint it lodged against Apple just two months ago at the US ITC (International Trade Commission). That takes allegations of infringing seven patents off the table, leaving just one claim at the ITC.
If this is a conciliatory gesture, it is an unexpected one, give that both Apple and Samsung, its chief Android rival ‘ inside and outside the law courts ‘ have been escalating their fights lately, extending attacks to one another’s newest models and dousing earlier hopes of a truce.
The chief reason for Google to acquire Motorola Mobility in the first place was to strengthen its own IPR defence against Apple, and therefore that of Android, but it has recently seemed keen to avoid pushing the firms’ rivalry towards a true showdown. That was also seen in the search giant’s insistence it would not launch a native Google Maps application for iOS against Apple’s will, despite the demotion of Maps as its default offering on the iPhone and iPad.
The ITC filings were made in August, and two weeks ago the agency said it would investigate them. No reasons are given for the U-turn, but it does not seem to signify an out of court settlement, since the document explicitly states that there are no agreements between the two firms.
Patents expert Florian Mueller of FOSS Patents wrote on his blog that the decision may relate to the appointment of Administrative Law Judge Theodore Essex, who is renowned for setting a high bar for complaints, to conduct the initial review (in ITC procedure, a single judge makes an initial decision which can then be reviewed and even reversed by the full panel). “Maybe it’s not just a coincidence that Motorola withdrew its complaint shortly after his appointment,” Mueller speculated.
Motorola Mobility reserved the right to refile claims against Apple. A notice of dismissal was also filed in a companion civil lawsuit filed in a federal court in Wilmington, Delaware. A non-jury trial on Apple’s claims that Motorola violated fair licensing terms on some of its patents is due to start on November 5 in Madison, Wisconsin. And another case remains on the ITC agenda. The Commission cleared Apple of infringing three Motorola patents on August 24 but told the judge to consider whether a fourth one was infringed. Judge Thomas Pender will make that ruling by December 21.