Significance: Optimistic market watchers said Apple’s surprise settlement with HTC could be a ‘blueprint’ for ending its legal battles with other rivals like Samsung and Motorola Mobility. But Samsung said it had no plans to negotiate, and it’s unlikely Apple wants to come to the table any time soon either, for fear it would be forced into the kind of weak bargaining position which led to its licensing agreement with Nokia ‘ a rare occasion when the Finnish vendor scored significant points over its rival. Unusually enough, Apple is on the back foot in its fight with Samsung ‘ overtaken in smartphone rankings in China and worldwide in Q3, as its one-phone-per-year model comes under serious scrutiny; in a weaker position in fundamental wireless IPR, a situation the Korean is yet to exploit to the full; still unable to escape its rival as a supplier of key components and foundry services. Apple’s CEO Tim Cook may be more willing than his predecessor to negotiate an end to patent lawsuits, but he will only do this from a position of strength, and for now, that is something Apple no longer has against Samsung, as the smartphone sector increasingly consolidates around a destructive two-handed battle.
Hopes finally rose that an end to the destructive handset patents war might be near when Apple and HTC called a truce and announced a 10-year cross-licensing deal. Some commentators spoke gleefully of the HTC deal being a ‘blueprint’ for similar pacts with Apple’s other major Android targets Google/Motorola Mobility and Samsung. Google has certainly shown itself reluctant to engage in direct conflict with its biggest rival, working through proxies in the Android IPR cases and backing away from full showdown in issues such as an iOS version of Maps. But Samsung’s mobile chief quickly insisted his firm had no intention of negotiating with Apple.
Even if the statement was just a tactic, it still highlights just how far Samsung has come in swinging the mobile balance of power against Apple in the past year. In survey after survey, Apple is seen sliding further into second place behind Samsung in particular and Android in general, while the Korean firm also has an upper hand when it comes to some major sources of competitive edge in smartphones, such as new screen and memory technologies. Of course, some of the Android gains will be reversed by the new iPhone 5, but according to many analysts, the impact of a new Apple handset on rival device sales has been less marked this time around than in the past. Samsung claims to have seen little slowdown for the Galaxy S III during the iPhone 5’s first weeks, while the debut of the iPad mini actually stimulated interest in lower cost small tablets such as the Kindle Fire and Google Nexus 7.
All of which begs the question, why would Samsung enter into talks until it can be sure of having weakened Apple as much as possible? HTC, once Android’s cheerleader, is suffering a decline in sales and market share and will have been in a relatively poor bargaining position against Apple, but Samsung could expect a very different deal ‘ and Apple’s CEO Tim Cook, despite expressing willingness to settle lawsuits, has nonetheless made it clear he would only concede if the terms were highly favorable.
He has undoubtedly signalled a change of approach. Under his predecessor, Steve Jobs, the priority was to crush Android products with injunctions and prolonged lawsuits, rather than to seek royalties for its patents (by contrast with Microsoft’s parallel IPR assault on Android, whose main objective is to gain recognition and revenues for its patents, weakening the Google OS by adding to its costs). It is notable that, under his CEOship, the firm has not take on Amazon, despite its high sales of Android tablets, or the Chinese suppliers, perhaps a sign that Cook has reined in the litigious zeal of his forerunner. He even described the litigation as a ‘pain in the ass’ last year.
But Apple could be in a poor position in terms of cross-licensing deals with Samsung, which has a huge store of IPR, much of it essential to wireless standards and key smartphone elements like displays.
All that suggests the stalemate between the two companies will persist, unless Apple anticipates a further weakening of its position over the coming year.
Following the HTC deal, Samsung’s mobile chief, JK Shi, told the Korean Yonhap news agency that his firm wants a legal resolution rather than an out-of-court compromise. He told reporters that there were no plans to negotiate at all with Apple, suggesting that the rivals are poles apart in their legal positions.
Samsung was the loser in the highest profile judgement so far, when a federal court in San Jose awarded a $1.2bn verdict against the Korean giant, but it has been the winner in some other cases, notably in Europe, and recently saw some of the patents at issue in the Silicon Valley case provisionally overturned by the US Patents and Trademarks Office. Some key cases loom, notably at the US International Trade Commission, whose outcome could shift the position of the firm that loses.
HTC, the first company which Apple sued when it unleashed its ‘thermonuclear’ attack on Android, had similarly enjoyed mixed fortunes in various fights with Apple, though it suffered the biggest reversal of the saga late last year, when it faced a possible ban on US imports of its Android products and had to find a quick workaround for an Apple patent it was judged to have infringed.
Such woes are behind it now, having announced ‘a global settlement that includes the dismissal of all current lawsuits and a 10-year license agreement. The license extends to current and future patents held by both parties. The terms of the settlement are confidential.’
‘HTC is pleased to have resolved its dispute with Apple, so HTC can focus on innovation instead of litigation,’ said CEO Peter Chou, while Cook said: ‘We are glad to have reached a settlement with HTC. We will continue to stay laser focused on product innovation.’ The latter statement will please Apple investors, which have raised concerns that the company is losing its innovative ‘magic’ and diverting too much energy to negative and costly lawsuits. Apple first sued HTC in March 2010, kicking off a string of lawsuits against several vendors, with broader relevance for the whole Android platform.
The truce will come at a price of course. Although HTC president Jason MacKenzie told CNet that the settlement would not materially affect the company’s financial results, analysts believe Apple could receive up to $280m a year from its new deal. Shaw Wu of Sterne Agee said in a research note that industry sources tell him Apple will get a net fee of $6 to $8 per smartphone from HTC in 2013. Based on his estimate that the Taiwanese OEM will ship 30m to 35m units next year, that would add up to $180m to $280m in fees. The deal was presented as a cross-licensing arrangement, which would mean Apple would also be paying some fees to HTC for its own patents.
As well as finding it far tougher to extract similar fees from patent-rich Samsung, Apple could also find itself shelling out additional sums of money to its enemy, on which it remains dependent for key components. Samsung was reported by Korean media to be planning a 20% price increase for manufacturing Apple’s A6 family of app processors, though the firm itself has played this down. “Samsung Electronics recently asked Apple for a significant price rise in the application processor,” reported Korean reports, citing internal sources. “Apple first disapproved it, but finding no replacement supplier, it accepted.’
This is another aspect of the complex relationship between the two giants. Apple has been loosening its supply chain ties with Samsung, which will be a major blow to the group’s semiconductor and foundry businesses, which number the iPhone maker in their top three clients. But Samsung still has plenty of cards in its hand too, since Apple, with its massive memory requirements, cannot get round the world’s largest maker of DRAM ‘ especially when it is innovating strongly in the next generation of mobile memory technologies. The same goes for touchscreen displays and processors ‘ in both cases, Apple is adding new suppliers such has Sharp and LG for screens and TSMC for foundry, but these have been unable to reach its volume and quality targets yet, leaving it reliant on Samsung still.
For the processors, Apple is tied into a supply contract with Samsung until 2014. Sources speculate that the Korean firm is hiking its prices to maximize revenue during the coming year, in anticipation of losing the Apple contract to TSMC in 2014. According to the report, Apple bought 130m app processors from the Samsung foundry last year and the figure will be more than 200m this year.
Corporate resentment at generating such business for an increasingly strong competitor is understandable. Samsung has been making the most of the waiting period for the new iPhone and managed to beat Apple in two recent and symbolically important polls. In one, by Strategy Analytics, the iPhone has been toppled from its position as the world’s bestselling smartphone, for the first time in two years, by the Galaxy S III. And in another, by Canalys, Apple dropped out of the smartphone top five in China, the world’s largest smartphone market, while Samsung extended its lead despite local competition.
Apple’s one-a-year strategy for the iPhone is likely to come under review for next year as the firm faces such aggressive competition from Samsung and its many models. The more the iPhone becomes the bedrock of Apple’s revenues, the more the annual cycle turns its performance into a boom-and-bust affair, with which the markets are showing some impatience ‘ and leaves windows open for Samsung. While the fourth quarter is sure to deliver massive sales and market share leaps on the back of the new iPhone 5, as Q3 league tables are published, Samsung and others have been making hay while the sun shines.
According to Strategy Analytics, the S III gained 10.7% of the global smartphone market on its own, during Q3, while the iPhone 4S was in second place with 9.7% after two years with Apple on top. The iPhone 5 managed to get 3.6% share even with only a short selling time during the quarter, which bodes well for the device in Q4.
The analysts calculate that Samsung shipped 18m S III units in the period, up from 5.4m in the second quarter, an increase of 230%. Apple shipped 16.2m iPhone 4S handsets, down 16% from 19.4m in Q2 as users held out for the newer model. Apple also shipped 6m iPhone 5s during Q3, after shipping in the last month of the quarter. The analyst firm’s executive director Neil Mawston commented: “The Galaxy S III’s position as the world’s bestselling smartphone model is likely to be shortlived.’
In China, Canalys says that Apple has been pushed out of the top five by low cost local vendor Yulong. This company came in at third position in Q3, indicating the rising influence of homegrown brands. Apple has always had a difficult time in China relative to its experience in western markets. It still has no deal with the largest carrier China Mobile, despite repeated round of talks. Mobile has reportedly resisted Apple’s stringent terms and insistence on full branding rights on the iPhone and App Store. It is likely to fall for the charms of a TD-LTE iPhone, but that has not yet materialized.
According to Canalys, Apple was in sixth place in China’s smartphone list in Q3, from fifth in Q2. Its share by unit shipments was 8%, down from 9% in the previous period. Samsung remained the top smartphone vendor in the fragmented market with 14% of shipments, and the only non-Chinese supplier in the top five. It was closely followed by Lenovo with 13% and Yulong with 10%, and ZTE and Huawei made up the numbers with just under 10% apiece. The pattern, in a market once dominated by western brands like Nokia and Motorola, shows the rising importance of local content and applications as handsets become more than phones ‘ as well as the cost efficiencies of the local vendors. The success of Yulong’s Coolpad range is credited to its broad product profile and having entry level Android models below $100, which led to heavy promotion by China Mobile and China Telecom.
Another analyst firm, IHS iSuppli, had placed the iPhone in seventh position among Chinese smartphones for the first half of 2012, while IDC has said that Apple’s share in the world’s largest smartphone market almost halved during Q212 ‘ the iPhone 4S is too expensive for budget customers, while top end consumers will have been waiting for the iPhone 5, which is expected to launch in China in December. Smuggled iPhone 5s are already being sold, often for over $1,000.
Individual quarterly reports may have limited significance, and are easily reversed by a new launch, but cumulatively, the polls and the trading of insults and lawsuits indicate an increasingly equal balance of power ‘ edging in Samsung’s favor because of its sheer scale in terms of components control, distribution channels and patent mountains. While the emergence of Android was a welcome challenge to Apple, this head-to-head is mainly destructive to consumer choice and innovation, as just two vendors seize so much market share and focus on trying to destroy one another rather than staying a step ahead of a wide range of challengers. For now, Apple is in the rare position of being on the back foot, but like smartphone rankings that can be quickly reversed. Unless one player swings the pendulum significantly their way, don’t expect an end to the patent wars any time soon.
Microsoft accuses Motorola of ‘hold-up’:
In another high profile patents war, Microsoft alleges that Motorola Mobility is adopting a “hold-up strategy” when negotiating licensing deals for its patents. The accusation was made as a case in Seattle opened ‘ a hearing which will be influential across the handset IPR world because it revolves around the thorny issue of how standards-essential patents are licensed.
Such IPR is governed by ‘Frand’ (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) terms, but both Microsoft and Apple are accusing Google’s Motorola unit of violating those guidelines. The issue is also critical to an Apple case against Samsung in Europe. While Apple is weak in terms of patents which underpin wireless technologies, both its main Android rivals have powerful holdings in 3GPP standards.
Microsoft’s lawyers told US District Judge James Robart that Motorola has priced its patents ‘to hold up Microsoft and its customers’. The case is the biggest of seven that the companies have filed against one another, and refers to a 2010 negotiation in which Microsoft alleges the Google subsidiary tried to levy an unreasonable fee for patents which are included in video streaming and Wi-Fi standards.
Motorola insists it offered Microsoft the same terms as other players. The two firms disagree on how standards-essential patents should be licensed, with the Windows giant favouring the pool approach and Motorola clinging to the mobile industry’s traditional bilateral (and secret) deals. Both firms argued that some of their evidence documents, containing detailed descriptions of patent pricing and negotiating practices, should be sealed by the court, and the judge agreed in at least some cases. The trial is expected to last for a week with a ruling to come in late December.
Android tablets to overtake iPad in mid-2013 says analyst
Android vendors have been making hay during the waiting period for the iPhone 5, and the ground they gained in the middle portion of the year will even position them to challenge the mighty iPad in the tablet segment.
Android tablets will overtake the iPad for the first time in the second or third quarter of 2013, predicts analyst Sameer Singh of Finvista Advisors in a research note (though of course, this refers to scores of Android models taking on just two iPad families).
Singh says that shipments of tablets running the Google OS ‘ such as the Samsung Galaxy Tab, Amazon Kindle Fire and Google Nexus ranges ‘ have outpaced the iPad’s sequential growth in six of the past eight quarters, with the launch of the Fire a year ago being the key factor in narrowing the gap with the market leader. The Fire defined a new category which broadened the total tablet sector, introducing a low cost approach which generated revenue for its vendor mainly via content sales. Apple was manoeuvered into responding with the recent launch of the iPad mini, while Google’s Nexus 7 falls into the same category.
According to IDC analysts, shipments of Android tablets rose to 13.8m during the third quarter of 2012, reducing the iPad’s lead to 50.4%, from 66.5% in Q212.
In his note, Singh wrote: “OEMs have learned from Amazon’s model that diversified price points would help expand the market and take share from the iPad. This has resulted in far more broad-based growth, which is not only sustainable, but should result in an accelerated ramp-up of sales over the next three to four quarters. Q1 2013 is likely to see a cyclical dip in shipments, but we are unlikely to see a crash. The growth pattern across OEMs is very similar to the dynamics in the early stages of the smartphone market, which suggests that tablets are finally being adopted by mainstream users.”
In a bright note for Apple, he expects the firm to increase its share to 55%, at least temporarily, during this quarter, because of the impact of the smaller iPad, but unlike some analysts, he does not think the new model will steal too many sales from Android rivals. He points out that sales of Kindle Fire HDs leapt on the launch of the iPad mini, presumably because Apple has endorsed the smaller form factor it once scorned, lending cachet ‘ but the Amazon and Google products remain significantly cheaper than their new competitor.
Singh adds: “The iPad would have to consistently outpace the growth of Android tablets over the next year to hold on to its market leadership position, which is quite unlikely. Therefore, current tablet market share trends are consistent with my prediction of Android tablets overtaking the iPad by mid-2013. However, both platforms should see rapidly rising volumes, as market share gains will be growth driven.” He did not factor the impact of Microsoft’s Windows RT tablets into his forecasts at this stage.