Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 December 2005

Samsung’s headstart does not mean Wi-Bro will be a closed market

There has been much talk, and a degree of paranoia, about how far Samsung would seek to exploit the Wi-Bro technology it dominates in a way that could harm rather than hurt WiMAX in the mobile broadband world. Wi-Bro is the basis of the proposed mobile WiMAX standard, 802.16e, but will be deployed at least a year ahead of that platform, and as it gains momentum even outside its native Korea, some have feared that Samsung would try to establish a de facto standard and make it hard for other would-be 802.16e vendors to keep up with its roadmap. However, while Samsung and, to a lesser extent, its compatriot LG will certainly seek to make the most commercially of the headstart they have in pre-802.16e networks, there are no indications that they aim to ‘do a Qualcomm’ and keep Wi-Bro semi-closed or separate from the WiMAX agenda.

In the crucial area of smart antennas, for instance, far from selecting a new technology and potentially forcing the WiMAX community to shift its roadmap to match, Samsung has announced an alliance with Arraycomm, the antenna specialist heavily backed by Intel and in which the chip giant has an investment. This does not smack of Samsung trying to wrongfoot its US rival or sideline American intellectual property in the WiMAX evolution. Samsung has been aggressive recently in statements that it aimed to prevent Intel dominating the WiMAX end user device as it has the PC and Wi-Fi laptop, and it certainly aims to gain leadership in a global standard that will not be dependent on US innovation and intellectual property. But by securing the support of the WiMAX community for Wi-Bro, rather than the originally conceived 802.16e plan, the Korean giant has scored a major victory in its quest, and now it knows it will benefit more in the long run by taking a lead in a globally standardized and supported platform, rather than aiming for sole control.

So we see the web of alliances around Wi-Bro, as the first pre-802.16e platform with real scale potential, becoming more complex and international even before there are any commercial deployments. Samsung has won its first tier one supporter in Europe, Telecom Italia, to add to its trial in the US with Sprint Nextel and its contract with Brazil’s television broadcaster TVA. But in its own Korea, Alcatel has already gained a foothold, indicating that Korea will not be a closed market, but a valuable springboard to China and east Asia for other vendors too.

ArrayComm was the first antenna maker to announce that it would launch technology this year supporting both of the smart antenna modes as specified in the new 802.16e profiles ‘ MIMO (Multiple Input Multiple Output) and AAS (Adaptive Antenna Systems or beamforming). The recommended architecture incorporates both techniques as MIMO mainly works to boost subscriber data rates, and AAS improves cell edge link budgets, manages interference and maximizes overall network capacity.

It is a tremendous boost for the company, and a step forward for hopes of a relatively unified WiMAX platform, that its implementation is backed by both Intel and Samsung and should provide a blueprint for others. Samsung has gained rights to the technology, which was originally deployed in ArrayComm’s own broadband wireless system, iBurst, for all its wireless base stations, and so it could be used in non-Wi-Bro systems too.

On the user front, Telecom Italia will trial Wi-Bro from Samsung at the Turin Winter Olympics next February. The Italian incumbent said in a statement it would be the first in Europe to try the technology. It aims to offer mobile broadband services on a wider basis through 2006 to offset decline in wireline revenues and to support new applications such as mobile videoconferencing. CEO Riccardo Ruggiero said: ‘I expect that in 2007 we could start selling these services.’

However, Korea Telecom, which will be the first commercial deployer of Wi-Bro and whose main supplier is Samsung, is now also working with Alcatel of France. For all the Korean government’s attempts to persuade operators to use homegrown technologies and suppliers, to reduce dependence on, and payments to, the west, the carriers often see centralized policies as oppressive and seek to stimulate competition by looking abroad too. KT and Alcatel are to establish a joint research center focused on Wi-Bro, a common Alcatel tactic that is often the precursor to major commercial deals in a new market.

The partners will build a ‘Wi-Bro Reality Center’ to conduct compatibility tests between base stations and mobile devices and demonstrate equipment and services, Other Korean telecommunications device developers will also participate, aiming to spread Wi-Bro service worldwide.