Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 April 2006

Scale versus margins dilemma becomes critical in handset top six

As the wireless giants mull over how to increase value from the infrastructure market, those with handset operations are enjoying a boom quarter. Qualcomm’s CDMA market far outshone expectations (see inset), while Nokia delighted investors with strong cellphone performance. Dips at Motorola and Samsung were largely down to networks rather than devices, where the market is increasingly falling into the hands of the top five suppliers. As cellphones become a business of scale, the coming quarters will start to throw up indications of how the big two’s contrasting strategies will play out as they battle for the top spot ‘ Nokia focusing on keeping margins high, particularly in newer markets such as the enterprise and digital home; Motorola going for volume in emerging economies backed by by a few iconic products such as the RAZR.

Although Nokia has taken an opposite stance from Motorola on the emerging class of ultra-low cost handsets (ULCH), targeted at low income groups in developing economies, it is still seeing significant growth from its targeted new territories, notably China, where a growing middle class is snapping up western phones. China was the major factor in Nokia’s first quarter out-performance, with net profit up 21% year-on-year to $1.29bn on sales up 29% to $11.7bn, and a 30% rise in cellphone sales. This was significantly ahead of market forecasts of $1.1bn profit on $10.7bn sales.

Nokia said its share of the device market in the quarter was 35%, up from 32% a year earlier. The company sold 75.1m phones during the period with the increase in market share driven mainly by strong gains in China, North America, Latin America and the Asia-Pacific region, which offset market share declines in EMEA. Nokia reiterated its prediction that 2006 would be a strong growth year for handsets, with total market volume expected to increase by 15%, with 70% of that growth coming from emerging markets. Analysts at Strategy Analytics expect handset sales to break the 1bn barrier in 2006 and to be up about 22% on 2005, though with margins under pressure from low cost sectors.

Nokia may be steering clear of ULCH, but it is still seeing its famous margins under attack as it becomes more reliant on entry level models for emerging territories. Its average handset price in the first quarter was down year-on-year from €110 to €103, although these prices are holding up better than many had expected ‘ last month, Nokia raised its estimate for average selling price to $125. Investors have been concerned about the heavy focus on entry models, so Nokia’s new CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo was keen to stress that the N70 high end multimedia phone was the largest revenue generator of the quarter. While this performance made the Multimedia unit ‘ one of Nokia’s three handset businesses ‘ a strong performer, the Enterprise unit was less successful, with sales down 39% and operating losses up to a hefty €66m. Enterprise houses a more long term strategy than that of the mainstream Mobile Phones division, spearheading the challenge to Microsoft and RIM in the mobile corporation sector which could support Nokia’s future growth and margin retention. However, it will need to show some results to investors before the end of the year.

At the Nokia Networks division, revenue increased 19% and operating profit fell 33%. Revenue growth was largely driven by services, which could make up 40% of the total this year, compared to 30% in 2005.

Though Motorola’s overall results were less glossy than those of its Finnish rival, its devices unit performed well and the company achieved global market share of 20% for the first time since 1998. It shipped a record 46.1m handsets in its first quarter, with RAZR being the key driver, but net income fell to $686m from $692m a year earlier because of weaknesses in the Networks division. Sales rose 23% year-on-year to $10.01bn.

Motorola said this unit would perform far more strongly in the second half of the year, with strategies built around the Moto Wi4 portfolio for broadband wireless starting to bear fruit. In that timescale, analysts are starting to worry that Motorola is over-dependent on RAZR and its offshoots, though the company claims it has unannounced handsets scheduled for the second half, which will continue to build handset momentum. These will include a W-CDMA device for Cingular and a CDMA/iDEN phone for Sprint, which will be essential to maintain a presence in Nextel, which was Motorola’s largest customer before its merger with Sprint, and whose iDEN network the equipment vendor supplies.

The main problem for the Networks unit is that Motorola lacks scale. While the need for volume, to spread R&D, marketing and distribution costs, is affecting both the infrastructure and handset industries, the US giant is less able to benefit from the trend on the equipment side, which may drive it to seek a major acquisition (see separate item). In handsets, the trends that favor the highest volume suppliers are increasingly benefiting Nokia and Motorola at the expense of smaller suppliers. In 2005, for instance, according to Telecoms Trends International, the top three ‘ Nokia, Motorola and Samsung ‘ captured more than 60% of the $117bn total handset revenues, the largest percentage to date that was concentrated in the hands of the leaders.

Motorola has been the most aggressive phonemaker about ULCH and now offers the Indian-made C115, with a basic monochrome screen, for $40, about $15 less than Nokia’s cheapest phone. This brought Motorola higher sales in India than its rival, by a factor of almost 3m, but dented its margins.

Samsung said recently that it would not enter the sub-$100 market in the near future, instead announcing a range of devices around the $100 tag to broaden its reach in new markets, without crashing its average selling price. This is closer to Nokia’s approach, although the Finnish company, while eschewing the sub-$40 sector ‘ perhaps because Motorola has been selected as the key supplier in the GSM Assocation’s Emerging Markets Handset Program ‘ has recently launched a range of entry level models priced between $60 and $90.

Like Nokia, Samsung sees entry level phones mainly as a way to attract new users who may one day have more disposable income to upgrade to higher margin models. It expects its new $100 phones to ‘eventually help Samsung extend our mid- and high end phones to those customers by giving them a good first experience with Samsung phones,’ said Seung Ro Yoon, company vice president, in a conference call.

Samsung had a disappointing quarter on the cellphone front. For the past four years, the company has used the first quarter to roll out new models at a time when competitors were resting after the pre-Christmas launch season, but this year it announced fewer new models, saw slowing growth at the high end and so was forced to slash prices.

It shipped 29m phones, below its target of 29.5m, and the operating profit margin of its telecom unit was 10%, down from 17% a year earlier. Executives said they expect the profit margin of its cellphone business to rebound in the third quarter but not to reach the company’s historic levels, in the 20% range, for at least a year. The cellphone results and a rapid decline in memory chip prices were the main reasons for a 25% drop in operating profit at Samsung. Net income rose 26% from last year, however, when it recorded a charge related to its credit card business. Cellphones and memory account for almost two-thirds of Samsung’s revenue. The company needs to revive its reputation as a frontrunner in innovative, multimedia handsets in order to boost its margins and challenge the mighty RAZR and N70, while formulating a more coherent approach to emerging markets in order to retain the volume that is increasingly essential to competitiveness in the branded cellphone sector.

This factor will also raise some critical decisions for Sony Ericsson, whose number four place is regularly usurped by the rapidly expanding LG, while sixth placed BenQ is still struggling to turn its acquisition from Siemens into gold (see inset). Like the big two, Sony Ericsson has launched some popular icon devices, including its Walkman phone, and its enterprise oriented phones also help keep margins healthy, but it lacks the economies of scale to play well in emerging markets and risks becoming a niche vendor. At this point, Ericsson might well decide to exit handsets altogether, leaving Sony to integrate the phones more completely into its broader mobile consumer electronics business alongside MP3 players, PSP games consoles and so on.

Qualcomm

Despite legal and competitive pressure on all sides, Qualcomm continues to shine, with an 11% year-on-year rise in net income in its first quarter, ended March 26, and its third consecutive quarter of record chip shipments.

The company said higher than expected shipments of CDMA handsets in the quarter boosted its net income to $593m and revenues up 34% to $1.83bn. It shipped about 49m Mobile Station Modem (MSM) chips during the quarter, compared to 37m units in the same period last year, and beating targets by 2.5m. This upside should contribute about $50m more to the top line, based on an average selling price of $20 a chip.

Qualcomm estimates that around 67m CDMA2000 and W-CDMA 3G handsets were sold worldwide during the quarter ‘ 6m more than it had originally predicted – at an average selling price of $208. W-CDMA royalties contributed 46% of total royalties compared to 32% a year earlier.

During the period, Qualcomm sampled the MSM7200 chipset, the first to support High Speed Uplink Packet Access (HSUPA) as well as W-CDMA/HSDPA networks, and also entered into a royalty bearing license agreement with an unnamed licensee covering OFDM subscriber units and infrastructure, indicating the CDMA giant’s moves to bolster its intellectual property in other wireless technologies, notably OFDM, which underpins its own Flash and MediaFLO platforms as well as WiMAX and 5GHz Wi-Fi.

BENQ

BenQ, Taiwan’s biggest cellphone maker, may report a second consecutive quarter of losses associated with the cost of taking over Siemens’ unprofitable handset division last year.

The first quarter net loss will probably be NT$4.9bn (US$151m) compared with a profit of NT$300m a year earlier, according to the median forecast of five analysts surveyed by Bloomberg.

Since buying the Siemens unit in October, BenQ chairman KY Lee has scrapped its cheaper phones and paid for rights to put its new brand on the shirts of Spanish soccer club Real Madrid, the world’s richest team. Like its nearest challenger for market share, Sony Ericsson, Lee is focusing on handsets that can download music and games to generate higher margins, rather than low cost sectors.

In the fourth quarter, BenQ posted a net loss of US$6bn after writing off NT$1bn in handset inventories acquired from Siemens. First quarter sales, already reported, rose 79% to NT$57.9bn from a year earlier. Fourth quarter revenue was NT$66.3bn, of which handsets accounted for 42%.