It’s easy to assume that Sierra Wireless’s sale of its AirCard unit marks the end of the dongle and personal hotspot as viable product categories in their own right. Their capabilities will be integrated into gateways ‘ hence NetGear’s’ purchase of the Sierra unit ‘ or into smartphones themselves. This is part of a wider trend, for wireless to stop being an equipment category in its own right, as reflected in Cisco’s latest moves (see separate item). Belkin, a NetGear rival, buys Linksys as home gateways increasingly span Wi-Fi, broadband and even cellular, while Cisco concentrates on platforms to manage the whole all-IP thing.
However, this is not the whole story for the dongle makers. The market may not be fruitful for Sierra because of the dominance of Huawei and ZTE ‘ and there will be inevitable question marks over Novatel too ‘ but these form factors remain important, at least for a few more years. Dongles remain a low cost way to launch new networks or encourage emerging market users onto new services. And MiFi-type personal routers are still being launched by the big carriers to boost uptake of 4G (because users can connect them to existing Wi-Fi devices) and even to extend fixed broadband coverage.
Most of the world’s LTE roll-outs so far have seeded the base with dongles and hotspots and these are still important on more mature networks. Verizon recently launched the new Novatel MiFi 5510 LTE mobile hotspot, while at the Consumer Electronics Show this month, AT&T showed off its Unite personal hotspot complete with LTE and a 2.4-inch touchscreen. And in Europe, 3 markets simple 3G dongles as a way to get broadband access for rural customers.
However, the economies of scale required to make a profit from these commoditized gadgets are significant, and one by one the specialist suppliers are sure to succumb to the two big Chinese firms. The speed of that shift is reflected in the fact that dongles are at the heart of the European Commission’s probe into claims of dumping by Huawei and ZTE. These humble devices have also been at the center of a string of patent lawsuits. Novatel is currently suing ZTE for alleged patent violation while Option took Huawei to the EC with complaints of anti-competitive practices, before agreeing, instead, to form a joint development venture and marketing alliance with the Chinese giant.
That is one way to stabilize revenues and generate fees from inventions, by making common ground with majors. The other is to sell out of this business and seek greener pastures, as Sierra has done. The firm was once best known for its dongles but has spent the past few years refocusing on embedded markets as its consumer devices came under pressure from Chinese rivals. The company will exit the dongle and hotspot segments, selling its AirCard cellular modem business to NetGear.
The company will now concentrate on the M2M and embedded device spaces, where there is significant growth in applications such as smart grid. It will base its strategy around its three remaining product lines ‘ the AirPrime embedded modules, AirLink intelligent gateways and routers, and AirVantage M2M cloud platform.
NetGear will pay $138m in cash and assume $6.5m in liabilities for the dongles, data cards and personal routers, which will help it add a 3G/4G element to its Wi-Fi and home broadband activities. NetGear recognized the integration of cellular into the residential access sector several years ago, notably in working on gateways that integrated femtocells as well as Wi-Fi and Ethernet.
Sierra will now look to embed its connectivity into internet of things products, a move for which it has laid the groundwork over several years, notably in 2009 when it acquired specialist Wavecom, from under the nose of counter-bidder Gemalto. By June 2010, Sierra said it led the global market for cellular M2M communications products, and revenue from these offerings had topped 50% of its total.
Patrick Lo, CEO of NetGear, said in a statement that his company believes the AirCard LTE technology represents a significant market opportunity, especially in emerging markets and rural areas as a broadband access mechanism. Personal routers, particularly the Novatel MiFi, have been adopted by some carriers to provide fixed access in underserved broadband regions.
NetGear said the AirCard business has a 12-month trailing revenue run rate of about $247m through December 2012 and has 160 employees, all of whom will transfer to the new owner once the acquisition is closed.
Sierra CEO Jason Cohenour said the sale of AirCard would provide “significant financial resources and capacity to accelerate our growth in M2M and connected device solutions’. The firm expects to realize net cash proceeds of $100m from the transaction which is expected to close in March.