Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

Single European regulator could avoid current 4G auction ups and downs

The European Commission is getting closer to creating a single telecoms market across the EU, a move that supporters believe could increase investment in this sector and accelerate the availability of new services.

According to Reuters, European Union leaders have asked the Commission to develop a blueprint before October, which should present ‘concrete measures to establish the single market in information and communications technology as early as possible’. Neelie Kroes, Commissioner for the digital agenda, has shown favor for a single market, and indicated that the first step could be laws to encourage network sharing, harmonized spectrum policies, and cross-border roaming or
Consolidation.

Other important issues to consider include pricing regulation, rules for M&A, and future spectrum allocations. But more difficult than these complex market and technical issues will be the political ones ‘ some state governments will regard the plans as a surrender of national sovereignty to Brussels. An EC spokesperson was eager to stress that the aim was ‘convergence not central planning’.

The GSM Association was one group welcoming moves to harmonization. Director general Anne Bouverot urged the Commission to ‘seize the opportunity to drive regulatory reform and encourage the investments in telecoms infrastructure required to achieve Europe’s Digital Agenda targets’. She said a single European telecoms market would boost GDP, innovation and investment and ‘establish a convergent path between the performance of the EU broadband market and that of the United States, which has, over the past decade, delivered substantially higher levels of investment’.

France Telecom-Orange, one of the major operators in the region and headquartered in a pro-single market country, said the move would provide a more ‘clear and predictable’ regulatory environment. Meanwhile, Kroes has pointed to how the harmonized approach to GSM had enabled Europe to lead the mobile industry, a position it has since ceded to the US, China, Korea and Japan.

As Europe’s 4G spectrum auctions pile up, many carriers ‘ especially cross-border ones and smaller or new entrant cellcos ‘ would welcome a simpler and more predictable set of regulations. Recent sales have betrayed the inconsistencies and some of the weaknesses of the current fragmented approach. The Czech regulator halted and cancelled the procedure because the prices had risen too high and it feared these costs would be passed onto consumers, slowing broadband growth. UK regulator Ofcom and its Austrian equivalent TKK would argue that their chosen auction structure, CCA, would have avoid prices going out of control ‘ but the UK’s recent sale delivered disappointing revenues to the government and has still, according to some experts, left operators without the spectrum they need.

That has not stopped Austria adopting the CCA (combinatorial clock auction) system, which has also been used in The Netherlands (where prices were well above expectations), Switzerland, Denmark, Ireland, Canada and Australia, as well as Austria’s own 2.6GHz sale. It is holding its largest ever auction of frequencies, scheduled for September this year and offering a total of 28 blocks in the 800MHz, 900MHz and 1.8GHz bands. The first of these is the digital dividend band, while the others have traditionally been GSM frequencies but are increasingly being used for 3G and 4G. Two blocks in the 800MHz band will be reserved for a new entrant and the reserve price for this spectrum will be €45.6m. TKK has put together a ‘newcomer package’ allowing that 800MHz spectrum to be combined with 2.6GHz frequencies, with the ability to enable national roaming.

At the reserve prices, the sale would generate about €526m ($680m). The process was originally scheduled to take place last year, but was delayed until the conclusion of Hutchison 3’s takeover of Orange Austria, which finally ended in January 2013.

CCA includes supplementary rounds where bidders bid on indivisible packages of spectrum, while prices are determined by a ‘second price rule’ ‘ based on competitors’ bids rather than necessarily on a winner’s own bid. Similar procedures have been used in multiband auctions in other countries, but critics are complaining ‘ as they did in the UK ‘ that the mechanism is unnecessarily complicated and Reuters reports that T-Mobile Austria has hired a game theoretician to help it prepare its bidding strategy during the six months before the auction takes place.

TKK justified its choice, saying in a statement: ‘Since the multiband auction is the largest allocation of frequencies that has ever taken place in Austria, companies must develop a variety of scenarios, in order to calculate the economic value of the spectrum for their companies to provide their expert teams and their strategy for the auction.’

It did not seem to have delivered an ideal outcome in the UK’s long delayed auction of 2.6GHz and 800MHz licences. According to sources who spoke to the Financial Times at the weekend, the outcome of the auction is not as clear-cut as it might have been. There are fears over how the frequencies have been distributed, and whether operators will face capacity constraints which could pose risks to their business models.

One unnamed participant in the auction told the newspaper that there had been ‘some jaw dropping outcomes’. Vodafone, Telefonica O2 and EE won spectrum in the 800MHz and 2.6GHz bands, while 3UK bought 800MHz licences and a subsidiary of British Telecom acquired spectrum in 2.6GHz.

However, the FT says the precise allocations are not what was expected and one of its sources said: ‘Some [operators] may struggle with capacity and others have too much of the wrong spectrum. I don’t think that the distribution of spectrum is efficient and so I think that there will be trades.’ Although regulator Ofcom has brought in rules to allow some forms of spectrum trading in recent years, it denied that this would be necessary for the LTE bands. ‘The auction achieved our stated aim of delivering a highly efficient and competitive outcome in the allocation of LTE spectrum,’ it said. ‘This is clearly reflected in the bids that took place during the auction, which we will publish shortly.’

The report claims that EE, which is already operating LTE services in refarmed 1.8GHz GSM spectrum, worked to shift bids away from the 800MHz band ‘ considered most attractive because of its coverage capabilities ‘ at a critical juncture. This helped depress prices ‘ the UK auction fell well short of government revenue expectations at £2.4bn in total ‘ and also meant that 3UK acquired more 800MHz frequencies than expected, although it was always guaranteed to gain some of the spectrum on offer. As the smallest cellco, it was protected by the auction process set up by Ofcom.

The FT report says that EE’s bidding strategy helped ‘take some of the heat out’ of the overall auction, ‘but even Three executives were astonished that it resulted in their company acquiring the treasured low frequency spectrum at Ofcom’s reserve price, which is far less than the huge sums earlier forecasted.’ Meanwhile, EE acquired only as much 800MHz spectrum as 3UK, but more in the 2.6GHz band than it had expected (while 3UK got none).

This could lead to further deals between the largest and smallest UK cellcos. EE is selling about 25% of its 1.8GHz spectrum to the fourth cellco as a condition of its merger. The two firms already have a RAN sharing joint venture, MBNL, and could now cooperate on 800MHz build-out ‘ or even trade spectrum, the FT suggests. It believes 3UK now owns 800MHz spectrum for which it has no plan, while EE wants more of the low frequency band to complement its 1.8GHz network with broader coverage. Vodafone, however, is considered to have achieved the best position in 800MHz with aggressive bidding, while O2 has less overall spectrum that its two largest rivals.

Over in Norway, the Ministry of Transport and Communications (MoTC) has set out its objectives for its own upcoming 800MHz auction. It expects the build-out of the digital dividend band, which supports cost effective rural coverage with its long range, to ensure that 100% of the country’s households have access to broadband in the near future at ‘basic good quality’ To achieve this, winners of the 800MHz licences will be required to provide coverage to 98% of the population within five years at downlink of at least 2Mbps. The state will also spend at least NOK150m ($26.8m) on the development of broadband in areas which currently have no coverage.

A cap of 2’10MHz will be imposed in the 800MHz band for operators which already have significant mobile spectrum holdings. Frequencies in the 900MHz and 1.8GHz bands are also expected to be auctioned along with the 800MHz licences. A cap of 2’20MHz will apply to the 1.8GHz band, and of 2x15MHz in 900MHz. No date has yet been set for the sale.

Meanwhile, Slovenian regulator APEK has issued an open call for bidders for additional capacity in the 1.8GHz and 2.1GHz bands, and expects to hold the sale on June 1. On offer are eight 2’5MHz sub-bands in 1.8GHz with validity up to January 3 2016; plus two 2’5MHz sub-bands in 2.1GHz, valid until September 21 2021. Winners must offer services in the specific bands covering at least 30% of the population within one year of the award.