It took years to squeeze GPS function down onto a single chip and bring it to the attention of the global cellular community, but right now there is probably no better selling point for handsets than location aware services, enabled by the satellite positioning system. Originally, location awareness was supposed to come about using triangulation services in a 3G network, but too few customers shifted to 3G at an early stage to make that viable, and that opened the way for GPS chips. But given that GPS techniques are now such a key differentiator for the chip industry, and given that the market took off rather suddenly, legal actions over intellectual property are bound to emerge, because there’s a lot of money at stake.
US researcher In-Stat reckons that there will be as many as 720m GPS chip units shipped in 201, up from 180m now, and rival ABI Research says that the chips are falling in price to around $3.50 apiece in volume this year. That makes the market something like $550m in value already, and rising to something over $1bn, by 2011, so it must be frustrating for a company like SiRF which has spent the past seven years working on GPS chip technology, to see giants like Broadcom and NXP entering the race for leadership in this key technology.
But a legal action that SiRF Technology has brought against Broadcom, alleging patent infringemen,t has just been set aside by the US International Trade Commission (ITC), which rejected claims that two of its GPS patents were infringed by Global Locate, now part of the larger chipmaker. Broadcom bought Global Locate just a year ago for $146m and one of the motives was a strong patent portfolio, with over 175 patents issued and pending, and the start-up’s offering of both baseband and radio integrated on a single CMOS chip.
SiRF went the other route, and was little more than a start-up itself in 2001 when it bought the GPS assets of Conexant, at a time when the larger chipmaker was under pressure. It is not certain what SiRF paid, but up to that point it had only raised some $60m, and went on to raise a further $19.6m straight after the deal. Today SiRF is a $330m revenue, profitable company, but under increasing pressure from Broadcom and also NXP, which bought its way into this sector recently, paying some $85m for GloNav in December 2007.
The ITC case judged one of SiRF’s patents as not valid and Broadcom also has a reverse case against SiRF which will go to court in August. This reversal on SiRF’s patent claims seems to imply that the business will be rapidly overtaken by the two majors and that SiRF may well need to seek a larger home, as the margin falls out of the GPS chip business and economies of scale rule the day.