Korea’s SK Telecom keeps tapping on the door of the US mobile market, convinced that, with its first hand knowledge of a far more advanced market in terms of mobile broadband and content services, it can steal a march despite the dominance of the incumbents. Having failed at Sprint, the latest report is that it will bid for Virgin Mobile USA, and combine the MVNO with its own virtual operator, Helio.
SKT undoubtedly has a huge amount of market and technical expertise to offer any partner, but so far its efforts have been met with lukewarm response ‘ its bid to invest in Sprint Nextel was rebuffed with indecent haste by the board; and its Helio joint venture with Earthlink has been struggling, with the beleaguered ISP reducing its commitment and the MVNO, Helio’s main activity, finding the market tough. SKT is on the look-out for acquisitions to bolster two other US initiatives ‘ its SKT Holdings investment arm, which is focused on mobile content and web services such as social networking; and Mobile Money, a joint venture with Citigroup to develop and promote mobile financial offerings.
In the mean time, combining Helio and Virgin Mobile could help both withstand the current fall-out in the US MVNO sector, and bring together Virgin’s brand strength with SKT’s mobile media expertise to create a strong youth oriented offering that could be clearly differentiated from the major cellcos’ services, and with sufficient scale to survive the onset of market trends like flat rate mobile broadband. Such a deal would, ironically enough, need the support of SKT’s unwilling prey, Sprint, which has a stake in Virgin Mobile – but would probably welcome the merger of the two MVNOs, both of which use its network, since their chances of survival and expansion would be much improved. Sprint recently lost MVNO customers Qwest and Embarq to Verizon. Together, Virgin Mobile USA and Helio have 5.4m customers and they account for about 10% of Sprint’s user base and half its wholesale revenue.
The original Helio vision pointed to something far more disruptive than just another MVNO (see Wireless Watch January 27 2005), and undoubtedly SKT wants a platform to become a mobile internet services provider, not just a virtual network, in the US. However, Earthlink proved the wrong partner for such an ambitious plan. Although it had its own far reaching vision of making up for the decimation of its dial-up ISP business, by creating a broadband business using various wireless methods of bypassing the telcos’ broadband lines ‘ from metrozones to Helio ‘ its legacy business was too heavy a burden, and its technology choices too limited.
Despite the subsequent failure, Helio’s original CEO, Boingo founder Sky Dayton, set out the SKT vision as effectively as anyone. Earthlink took the view that all of America was underserved in terms of twenty first century services, and that SKT was the carrier to remedy that. Dayton said: “The wireless and internet worlds are colliding, and neither will be the same again. In South Korea, kids on the street are using their mobile phones to listen to music, watch TV, videoconference, locate their friends and access the internet ‘ as well as make voice calls ‘ as opposed to the US where the mobile experience is primarily about talking on the phone. Americans are living in the past. Utilizing emerging 3G networks and harnessing the explosive growth of Wi-Fi, SK-EarthLink will take the wireless experience in the US to a new level.”
Those hopes were dashed, but the objective ‘ to make an inroad into the incipient mobile internet, 4G-style market ahead of the leading telcos ‘ remains the same for SKT. By contrast with the Earthlink tie-up, the plan to invest in Sprint Nextel, and primarily to get a stake in Xohm (now the new Clearwire), would have been perfect for SKT’s purposes (and good for Sprint too), giving the Korean access to the first true mobile broadband network in the US, with a real chance of leaping ahead of Verizon and AT&T in the 4G stakes. SKT would have gained real influence over a build-out in a technology with which it is familiar (and even with one of the Sprint suppliers being its long term partner Samsung).
However, that proposal, despite rumors of revival, seems to be off the table, but at least Virgin Mobile would give SKT some kind of springboard for its mobile internet ambitions ‘ a well established operator with a strong brand, despite recent financial disappointments, and with key systems such as customer management firmly in place. This could be the foundation for the initial launch of a range of content and transaction services to be developed under the auspices of SKT Holdings and Mobile Money. The involvement of Citigroup in SKT’s putative US ecosystem is not to be underestimated either. One of the reasons that mobile payments have taken off more quickly in Asia and Korea than most other places is that the relationships between carriers and banks are strong (NTT group even owns a bank) and so there is not the same conflict of interest, in terms of revenue share, brand and position in the value chain, that exists in most markets.
For its part, Virgin Mobile would almost certainly benefit from an SKT tie-up. It was the role model for the MVNOs in the US in the early days, when the key to success was to target a well defined user base by leveraging a brand already well recognized by that base. Often, this was appealing to the wholesaling cellcos because it could bring in users from bases in which the had little direct influence, without the cost of customer acquisition, and without diluting the main carrier brand, for instance by reaching out to lower income customers. However, the association of non-telecoms brand and MVNO success has weakened ‘ witness the failure of ESPN Mobile and Disney Mobile ‘ especially as the major carriers have started to promise open access, flat rate broadband and a host of 4G-style services that require investment beyond most MVNOs’ means ‘ but which may prove more enticing to users than just brand. This means Virgin needs to get more creative in its thinking, and SKT could help it create a raft of new and cutting edge services tailored to its particular subscriber profile.
Virgin Mobile IPOd last October but the stock has since fallen badly as subscriber growth has slowed and Virgin has labored under a heavy load of debt. The MVNO make a profit of $4.7m on sales of $304m in its most recent quarter, and knows it needs to appeal to higher value users in order to improve ARPU, margin and churn ‘ something innovative services from SKT could help achieve. Of course, Helio is in an even worse position, having lost about $90m a quarter, or twice its revenues, last year, and with virtually no increase in its 200,000-strong user base since the start of 2008. However, despite its limited market weight, Helio does have some interesting mobile internet ideas, offering advanced video and over-the-air music services, which would benefit Virgin, as well as mobile access to MySpace.