Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2008

Smartphone makers warn of mounting margin pressures

The past year has seen war break out in the highest ranks of the mobile phone market, where there were once just a few models for consumers to choose from. Now a wide array of choices in smartphones and mediaphones is driving down prices, with even the iPhone affected, and this is hitting the results of those manufacturers that focus most heavily on the high end market. So RIM, Palm and Sony Ericsson all expect disappointing quarters, and need to act on one or all of three game plans for smartphone makers ‘ cut production costs dramatically, as Apple seems to have done for its 3G iPhone; rely on a powerful brand, as Sony Ericsson would by bringing Playstation into bat alongside Walkman and Cybershot; and/or create a strong software platform that will enable the handset to be differentiated by its applications and user experience.

The challenges facing the smartphone makers highlight two trends ‘ increasing competition, which is hitting volumes and margins; and increasing buyer savviness, with consumers shopping around to get even luxury features, like advanced cameras or push email, without having to pay extra dollars. The operators are bearing some of this burden, especially when they think it is worthwhile to carry a flagship brand like the iPhone; and the manufacturers are striking hard bargains with suppliers to drive down costs. But they are also starting to feel the pinch, and this will only get harder, with Qualcomm’s CTO predicting this week that 3G phones will fall below $100 before the end of this year.

Dr Roberto Padovani said in an interview that 3G device shipments would overtake 2G within the next two years as the faster network becomes established in major population bases like south east Asia, driven by demand for data services and by lower cost roll-out options for operators, such as refarming GSM spectrum. The prices of low end 2G handsets have already fallen from $400 to $100 in just the past three years, driven by higher volumes and lower cost components and though sub-$100 3G will mainly be targeted at emerging economies, consumers in advanced mobile territories will start to demand the same cut price products.

Against this backdrop, it will get harder to justify charging a premium for smartphone hardware features such as cameras ‘ beyond 5megapixels, many analysts believe the demand for super-high performance cameras is low, and consumers certainly do not want to pay a high price tag for what is seen as a marginal benefit.

All this will cause difficulties for the smartphone specialists, and the pain is already starting to show amid fears about consumer spending cutbacks. BlackBerry maker RIM has missed its first quarter earnings target and cut its outlook (though it did still double its profit). The main problem was that gross margins for the quarter were down a huge 51.4% compared to the previous quarter, at 50.7%. Joint CEO James Balsillie said the upcoming BlackBerry Bold should boost the second half of the year but said smartphone makers are in a bit of ‘a land grab game right now’.

Palm, whose fortunes have revived somewhat on the popularity of Centro, also reported a quarterly loss, at $43.4m worse than analysts had feared, and reversing last year’s Q4 income of $15.7m. Although Centro has been a strong boost for Palm, it is a mid-priced phone, with a low margin at $99, but the high margin Treo is not selling in sufficient volume. The company sold 968,000 devices in the quarter, the most in its history, but CEO Ed Colligan would not reveal how much margin the firm makes on Centro, arousing analyst speculation that the device is unprofitable.
Meanwhile, Sony Ericsson warned of a tough second quarter on ‘moderating demand of mid-to-high end mobile phones, in combination with a delay of new products shipped during the quarter’. It will break even before tax, but will suffer falling margins compared to a year earlier and the previous quarter.

The company has an ambitious web services strategy and the power of its Walkman, Cybershot and Playstation brands, but all this needs to kick in more strongly against Nokia and Apple. The joint venture said the market is ‘challenging’ and that it plans to ship approximately 24m phones during the quarter at an average selling price of €115, well down on previous estimates for both volume and ASP. During the seasonally slower first quarter, Sony Ericsson shipped 22.3m phones at an average price of €121.

Aldo Liguori, vice president of communications, said a number of new products expected for release during the second quarter ‘started shipping later than we had originally planned’. He added that the company continues to invest in R&D in high end products and will ship the first device in its new sub-brand, the Experia X1 slider phone, in the fourth quarter. Sony Ericsson has the additional burden of heavy reliance on western Europe, a market where, according to Gartner Group, sales fell in the first quarter of 2008, the first year-on-year drop in the region since it started tracking cellphone shipments in 2001.

All this makes it increasingly vital that phonemakers develop full platforms, with software, services and appealing brands, as Nokia is trying to do with Ovi and its Symbian Foundation. Relying on a pretty, feature-packed phone will no longer be enough to deliver the profits that shareholders want, even if consumers are delighted with the range of cost-effective choices.

The other route will be branding, as seen in other parts of the consumer electronics industry. The primarily brand-driven mobile device market is already under way, as the success of the iPhone has demonstrated, and is spawning a new subsector of the cellphone sector ‘ mobile brand designers.

One is France’s ModeLabs, which designs handsets that it claims ‘encapsulate specific brand values’, often for non-phone companies. Its first major commission has been jeans oriented handset to be branded by Levis, taking the company out of its previous niche of super-exclusive designer phones, such as the crystal encrusted Lady Dior phone, which costs over £55,000. The challenge is not just to reflect the brand in the hardware, but in the user interface and applications, in order to create a customer experience that is unique and supports the brand’s features. This may be the way forward for struggling MVNOs (mobile virtual network operators) ‘ some have tried to rely on their own brands, like Disney or Virgin, but are now looking to carry a variety of third party branded handsets geared to their target market.

ModeLabs optimistically forecasts that phones whose primary brand belongs to a consumer retailer, not a handset maker or operator, will account for 20% of the market in developed economies by 2011.

There is one other rescue plan open to phonemakers ‘ to cut costs dramatically in order to preserve margins even while slashing prices. Although some of the burden of the low price tags on Apple’s 3G iPhone will be borne by the carriers’ subsidies, the device maker has also been successful in reducing its bill of materials, according to analysis by teardown specialist iSuppli. The group estimates that the bill of materials and assembly costs for the 8Gb 3G iPhone will be $173, which would make it one of Apple’s most profitable ever devices. ‘The original 8Gb iPhone carried a cost of $226 after component price reductions; giving the new product a 23% hardware cost reduction due to component price declines,’ said iSuppli, which will conduct a full teardown and BOM calculation when the new handset ships. Carriers are expected to pay a subsidy of about $300 for each iPhone, depending on the territory. In terms of margin, iSuppli suggests Apple’ s iPod and iPhone products are typically priced about 50% above that of their BOM and manufacturing costs.