Sony Ericsson knows that 2008 will be a crossroads year. The joint venture emerged like a butterfly in 2006-7 after a turbulent early career to become undisputed number four in the handset market and with growth and margins to die for. Now it has its eyes set on the number three ‘ and even, if both Motorola and Samsung slip up ‘ number two spot in handsets, but this is forcing it to confront the dilemma of all the handset majors: volume versus margin.
This is a game of scale so the former is essential, and Sony Ericsson is chasing it with new business structures in India and a new attack on the recalcitrant US. Two years ago the company could have chosen to be like Apple, generating high margins in a stylish handset niche, but that would really only have worked when it was still highly possible that the venture would be entirely submerged into Sony, making it part of a larger consumer electronics portfolio as the iPhone is. Now that it seems clear that Ericsson will stay involved for the long haul, and so Sony Ericsson has to stand on its own feet as a large scale producer of cellphones, which means drawing even more effectively on the design, brand and CE supply chain skills of its Japanese parent, and on the wireless reference designs of its Swedish one, even while pushing its logistical standards closer to those of Nokia.
As for Nokia, one of the greatest challenges is cracking the US market, where Motorola still holds sway and the Koreans have made stronger inroads than the Europeans. Announcing fourth quarter results, his first time in the hot seat since taking over as CEO, Hideki ‘Dick’ Komiyama pledged moves to make more impact in the US. Like Nokia, Sony Ericsson cannot play with the CDMA operators ‘ and the smaller firm has not yet taken the WiMAX plunge, so cannot even work with Sprint Xohm ‘ though it has better global brands than its Finnish rival, notably Walkman and Cybershot, Sony marks that have increasingly been applied to the handsets, with stunning results.
Komiyama admitted that ‘in the largest market, the US, our position is weak’. Like Nokia, Sony Ericsson has weaker relationships with the operators than Motorola or Samsung, partly because of its lack of CDMA, which makes it over-dependent on wooing AT&T and T-Mobile USA. Also like Nokia, the venture has struggled to adapt to the north American model, where operators expect a high level of control over the relationship, and where design requirements are often different to those in Europe and Asia. Nokia famously ignored the clamshell trend, which has been strongest in the US, for far too long, and now its smaller rival is saying it will add more clamshell phones to appeal to US consumers. It also says it will work hard on improving alliances with cellcos, though it will also look at other options such as direct sales and alternative channels, all of which run the risk of alienating carriers like AT&T that do not have a huge investment in Sony Ericsson anyway.
In general, Sony Ericsson’s results were well received, despite a Q4 fall in average sales price (ASP) and profits, possibly pointing to the squeeze on margins that will accompany the drive for market share. In Q4, net profit fell 17% to €373m ($553m), which the company blamed on higher operating costs and a lower tax rate in the year ago quarter. Revenue remained almost flat from a year earlier at €3.77bn. The company said Asian sales slid 18% because of difficult markets in Japan and China and unrest in Pakistan.
The full year saw the venture shifting over 100m units for the first time, and a slight increase in net income from €997m to €1.1bn, on sales up from €11bn to €13bn. In the quarter, unit shipments rose 18% year-on-year to 30.8m, though ASP fell from €146 to €123.
‘Our target remains to become one of the top three players in the industry, and the momentum we established in 2006 and 2007 makes this a realistic and achievable ambition,’ said Komiyama.
While the results make Sony Ericsson’s market share ambitions look reasonable ‘ and it gained two percentage points on 2006 to claim 9% of the world total ‘ it is important to remember that it will not normally be in a situation where Motorola is haemorrhaging market share as much as it did in the past year (it lost 40% of its total share), and indeed, the Swedish-Japanese venture has not capitalized on that advantage as effectively as Nokia and the Koreans. For instance, Samsung enjoyed over 40% year-on-year increases in unit shipments in the fourth quarter and the full year, with a total of 161m for 2007. But its healthy volumes came at a cost to margin, with ASP falling from $151 to $148 between the third and fourth quarters, well below Sony Ericsson’s or Nokia’s. Samsung needs to strengthen it high end lines in the coming months, especially adding more touchscreens and top quality cameras to keep up with the Nokia N Series, while also expanding its low cost options for emerging markets.