Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 September 2007

Sony Ericsson may be Sagem’s last hope for profitability

Problems at phonemaker Sagem highlight the increasingly unforgiving nature of the handset market and raises the question of how many tier two and three vendors are likely to survive the next few years. The French company saw operating losses widen from €52m in the first half of 2006 to €94m in the same period this year, with handset sales falling by 49% year-on-year, dragging down the otherwise solid performance of its parent company Safran.

Such a drain has Sagem become that the group’s outgoing chairman, Jean-Paul B’chat, admitted that the merger of Sagem and jet engine maker Snecma in 2004, to form Safran, had been a mistake. ‘We wouldn’t have done it if we had known then what we know today,’ he told a news conference, though he claimed that the worst problems are now behind them and the phone unit will not be divested.

The problems at Sagem have come from many sources, although Safran tends to point to a ‘less rigorous’ management culture rather than to the key problem for all vendors in this category ‘ being squeezed between the massive market share gains of the top five, and the emergence of extremely low cost suppliers from India and elsewhere. Sagem could not be faulted for its supply chain and procurement expertise, but outside France it was unable to combine this with strong brand awareness. And Nokia’s increasing dominance shows that, in the mobile phone market, both brand and cost efficiency are now essential, not just one of these – arguably, Motorola is still lacking the latter, while most of the white label and ultra-low cost manufacturers have little of the former, as well as being outflanked by Nokia on the logistics and cost base fronts.

HTC of Taiwan is one former unbranded vendor that is looking to make the difficult transition to competing under its own logo against the giants. Sagem has been trying to do this for some years, and for a while, like many smaller phonemakers, saw close partnership with operators as being its best chance of success. With the cellcos wanting to increase their brand awareness and their influence over handset design and development, many turned to smaller suppliers – more malleable than Nokia and willing to make operator-branded devices. However, in the past year or more the handset brands have been seizing back their upper hand, with the iPhone just the most extreme example, forcing operators to work with them ‘ and lessening the appeal of the smaller manufacturers.

The other way to acquire brand status beyond one’s own reach, of course, is to enter an alliance with a larger phonemaker that needs to plug gaps in its own portfolio, and this is now the likely rescue route for Sagem. B’chat said the unit would go into profit early next year, largely because of its new partnership with Sony Ericsson, which recently signed the French company to make it low cost handsets for emerging markets, notably India, where Nokia has massive market share. If this tactic works for Sagem, it is more than likely that Safran will put it up for sale, possibly touting it to Sony Ericsson itself. The Japanese-Swedish vendor needs to broaden its distribution channels and range of models in order to fulfil its recently announced ambitions of expanding into low cost markets and entering the top three handset rankings. However, while Sagem might help it achieve such aims, Sony Ericsson would not consider acquiring a company that might dent its enviable profit record of late, especially since its influence over its new partner’s decisions is likely to be profound, given Sagem’s dependence on the deal.

Despite the Sony Ericsson deal, many analysts remain unconvinced that Sagem can turn a profit next year, given the increasingly cut-throat competition of the market ‘ according to its larger compatriot, Alcatel (as was), which exited the cellphone market in 2005, surviving in the sector with less than 8% market share is ‘almost impossible’. David Perry, an analyst at Citigroup, said in a research note that Sagem’s losses ‘remain substantial, with no guarantee of a resolution in 2008’. Safran also said it has received ‘expressions of interest’ in its broadband and set-top-box business. Acquisition may be its best option ‘ last fall Motorola was linked to the company, but a bid did not materialize.