Sony Ericsson has been the star of the handset majors this year, but has reached a crossroads in its fortunes, which have been largely dependent on high margin devices and strong brands. Now the Sino-Swedish venture aims to increase its volumes too, and last week CEO Miles Flint stole a little limelight from his Nokia counterpart with a pledge to overtake Samsung and possibly even Motorola in the handset rankings. In a corporate statement, the six-year old venture set out its ambitions more clearly than ever before: ‘Our goal is to become a top three player. That goal now looks more attainable. It’s a credible aspiration.’
Probably wisely, neither Flint nor the company spokespeople gave no firm timescale for this achievement, which is fraught with risk. Motorola’s recent problems have been partly down to its over-enthusiastic chasing of volume at the expense of margin, especially in emerging markets, while Nokia’s strong year has been the result of drawing a more skilful balance ‘ but the Finnish giant’s shift to software and internet strategies shows that it is aware that this balance may not always be achievable, and that it needs to expand into businesses with higher margins. It will be difficult for Sony Ericsson to get this right, especially as its key strengths lie in design and brand ‘ notably its clever extension of the Sony Walkman and Cybershot names – while it has some glaring weaknesses for the volume sector, notably a very thin handset portfolio. A small number of premium devices may be a strong and cost efficient strategy for a company that knows exactly who to target with its brands, but it will not work in the broader market, and the expansion of the catalog will require difficult changes from the vendor in terms of partners, supply chain, cost structures and marketing.
Sony Ericsson started its bid for the number two spot in cellphones earlier this year, when it announced new activities in India (see Wireless Watch February 5 2007), following fairly vague statements the previous fall that it would start to target higher volumes. The company has been the fastest growing phonemaker this year, and has put a clear distance between itself and its formerly neck-and-neck competitor LG, and is now biting at the heels of Samsung.
To overtake the larger Korean, Sony Ericsson has formed alliances with Flextronics International and Taiwanese ODM Foxconn to make 10m handsets in India within two years, and a design partnership with France’s Sagem for low end phones. These indicate a policy of protecting the high margin smartphone business for 3G, while expanding rapidly in GSM, where ODM partners are vital, and which represents the main source of market share growth until growth economies start to adopt 3G broadly, in the next decade. The two-tier strategy will be copied with local manufacturing deals in other high growth regions such as Latin America or even China.
Though Sony Ericsson has turned in stellar performance in the past year ‘ in its latest quarter, net income grew 54% year-on-year to €220m ($300.8m) and revenues grew 37% to €3.2bn ‘ it will be a very tough job to stay on top of the game. This is not just because of the risk of moving down the food chain, but also because of rejuvenated threats to its most successful brands, which leverage the Sony associations with music and photography ‘ but which are under siege from the Apple iPhone and from Nokia’s latest music drive and N Series of highly specified multimedia handsets (see separate item). With market share of 9% – a percentage point below that generally considered safe for long term survival in the handset market ‘ Sony Ericsson will find the next point or two of share the most difficult to achieve, especially if Motorola, whose misfortunes are currently offering easy pickings to its rivals, ups its game again.
And results from the Indian activities will not make a significant difference for at least a year. Sony Ericsson currently has about 6% share in the country, while Nokia has 70%, and is piling increasing levels of investment into manufacturing and super-efficient logistics in the country (India has overtaken the US as the Finn’s second largest volume market after China).
Although the Flextronics and other partnerships look sound for spreading the risk of moving to high volume, and tapping into strong expertise in manufacturing and logistics processes, overall the Sony Ericsson strategy for emerging markets seems to have various holes. One is the sparseness of its distribution network in large nations like India, and the fledgling nature of its Indian development centers, compared to those of Nokia. Also, it does not play in the CDMA market, which means its position in North America is likely to remain weak.
New technologies will need to be supported to reduce costs without sacrificing too much margin. Although the venture’s parents contribute strongly in terms of consumer electronics design and brand (Sony) and advanced cellphone platforms (Ericsson Mobile Platforms), neither of these giants is highly experienced in low cost, low power systems, although EMP has been making strong moves recently in that direction. Above all, Sony Ericsson needs to introduce single-chip technology, plus software that leverages the best user experience from limited physical resources ‘ trends that are currently being driven by Nokia and its partners, and by Qualcomm.
Even more importantly, Sony Ericsson needs to expand its choice of handsets more rapidly. This was described by one analyst, Chris Ambrosio of Strategy Analytics, as ‘dangerously thin’. Flint is starting to address this, and last week promised to introduce a number of sub- €100 models, without making the Motorola mistake of racing headlong into sub-$50 ultra-low cost phones. Like Nokia, Sony Ericsson will largely rely on models that offer stripped-down versions of the features of its smartphones, such as fairly good cameras or color screens, and which are targeted at higher income population groups in emerging economies ‘ with the hope that these will upgrade to smartphones in future, and that the overall spending power of the country will increase.
Flint reiterated that there were no plans to compete in ultra-low cost sectors as yet, and held up the recently launched entry level Walkman phone, the W200i, as an example of the core strategy. This has an FM radio and digital music player, but a basic camera and less memory than a fully specified Walkman handset. In an interview, he repeated a message he communicated strongly at the CTIA conference earlier this year, when he said in a keynote address: ‘Without profit, you’re nothing. It’s baked into our DNA: profit before growth.’ It will prove far harder to stick to this goal to the satisfaction of both its parents’ shareholders as Sony Ericsson embarks on its new path.
LG Electronics:
LG is looking to a range of new multimedia models to restore its recent lacklustre fortunes, which see it firmly consigned to the fifth position in the handset rankings.
One area of hope is North America, where it ties with Samsung for number two spot after Motorola (both have around 17% share, while the native vendor has 33%). Its strength in CDMA, from which Nokia and Sony Ericsson are excluded, has given LG a pivotal and potentially lucrative role in Verizon Wireless’ biteback against AT&T’s iPhone launch. Verizon’s response – now it has got round the threat of a handset import ban related to the Qualcomm-Broadcom patents disput – will center strongly on its new music services and on the LG Prada phone, which has many similar features to the Apple device, including a touchscreen.
LG will also look to increase the premium end of its line, especially in the US and its native Korea, with follow-ups to the Chocolate phone, part of its high end Black Line. Pundits expect imminent launches from LG to include an advanced cameraphone focused on Google and YouTube applications, and dubbed Viewty, plus the US shipment of Prada. This month will also see an upgrade to Verizon’s LG-made VX8300, the second best selling handset in the US in the last quarter.