Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 September 2007

Sony moves in on Apple as iPhone price cut betrays a whiff of panic

Apple surprised the markets with a deep price cut on the iPhone, slashing $200 off the 8Gb model, bringing the cost down to $399. This appears to spring from the desire to maximize sales before new competitors from Nokia and Sony Ericsson ship towards the end of the year ‘ indicating the extent to which Apple must now be worried by these challengers, not only to its handset business, where it might be expected to bow to the cellular giants, but to its iTunes/iPod mobile music platform, which remains dominant ‘ for now.

As we have seen, a string of challengers for iTunes’ crown have appeared recently, and significantly these are mainly coming from the mobile arena. Verizon, RealNetworks and MTV joined to announce their own music service, Rhapsody America; and Nokia followed with Music Store and a clutch of devices to accompany it (see Wireless Watch September 3 2007). Then, last week, it was Sony’s turn, as the Japanese giant chose to extend its Portable Media Player (PMP) lines with new Walkman devices – the NWZ-A810 and the NWZ-S610, both with that same magic amount of flash memory storage, 8Gb, as the iPhone and Nokia’s upgraded N95.

The threats to iTunes all come from companies that have access to huge amounts of flash memory, at globally significant, rock bottom prices ‘ Verizon through its handset makers, especially Samsung; Nokia through its vast supply lines; and Sony because it makes some flash memory and buddies up to Samsung and SanDisk for the rest. And at the prices that the Sony devices are being offered, there is only one thing stopping everyone going out and buying one, and that’s being sure that they can get any music they want. Addressing that issue, Sony has closed down its old Connect service, with a promise to customers that it will offer conversion tools to convert the Atrac 3 formatted audio to Windows Media Audio. It also hinted at plans for many new services, including one that is part of the PS3 games network, that will be able to deliver in this format, raising the possibility of a far more unified and open standards line from Sony that could also include the Sony Ericsson Walkman handsets.

With Connect gone, Sony may look for a third party music service to partner with, and the main candidate would be Napster, which so far has failed to win a deal with one of the major portable device makers. Sony already Sony bundles Windows Media Player 11, and a Napster trial, with the MP3 Conversion Tool it is promising in its new devices, although with the new focus on openness, it would be odd if the new Walkmans and Sony Ericsson handsets didn’t have access to Nokia Store and the MSN Music store as well, before long.

Like Apple with iTunes, Sony will also now transport its PSP platform to a cellphone format, and Sony Ericsson executives have said the PSP phone will be ready for Christmas. It will support all the existing games and will provide a choice of modes ‘ the familiar PSP UI for gaming, and a new-look phone interface for other functions including internet. This product will go head-to-head with Nokia’s revamping of its N-Gage platform, now a software and web services offering available on various handsets rather than a dedicated device – and may leave Apple wondering whether it should address the gaming space too.

With the majors stirring themselves into action, the iPhone price cut was perhaps a predictable first response from Apple, although the depth of the reduction was a surprise ‘ and not a welcome one to shareholders, or to customers who had paid the full price. Such was their annoyance that Apple CEO Steve Jobs issued a public apology and said Apple stores would offer a $100 credit to anybody who had purchased at the full cost.
‘Our early customers trusted us, and we must live up to that trust with our actions in moments like these,’ he wrote in a letter posted on Apple’s web site. Customers who bought an 8Gb iPhone within 14 days of the cut can claim a $200 cash rebate.

Apple is to discontinue the smaller 4Gb iPhone altogether, saying that the 8Gb version has proved more popular, and at its lower price point will have broader market reach. Customers who purchased a 4Gb model within 14 days of this announcement are entitled to a full refund.

The mishandling of the price cut, its early timing ‘ when compared to Apple’s normal product cycles ‘ and the size of the reduction all point to a certain panic at the usually cool company. In particular, a vendor that relies so heavily on early adopters and pre-launch enthusiasm should not have made the elementary error of alienating that base, rather than offering its ‘peace offering’ proactively rather than under pressure.

The other important move from Apple was to introduce a Wi-Fi iPod, which provides most of the features of the iPhone, apart from the cellular connection (and, of course, the compulsory two-year AT&T contract). This could, therefore, prove a very popular option and one that could spread awareness and uptake of key features such as the touchscreen interface widely, in advance of the Nokia and Sony/Sony Ericsson launches. The iPod Touch looks almost exactly like its cellular equivalent and comes with key software features of the AT&T model, including Cover Flow, Multitouch, Calendar, Contacts, Clock, Calculator and a similar user interface and touchscreen.

This has given rise to speculation that Apple’s next response to the new attacks on its music position will be an iTunes Wi-Fi Music Store for the iPod Touch and iPhone. This would have the same selection and pricing as the desktop version but would provide the over-the-air downloads that Nokia emphasizes so much, plus the opportunity to partner with major Wi-Fi providers like T-Mobile/Starbucks. Apple has already announced a deal with the coffee store chain, which has been trying to break into the music retailing game. When a user walks into a coffee shop, a Starbucks icon will pop up on the iPod or iPhone, enabling users to browse and purchase the last 10 songs played in the store.

Such moves show that Apple will certainly not let go of its music lead easily, and has many cards it can play more effectively than it has before, once it feels the pressure to do so.

Apple boosts Infineon:

Shares in Infineon leapt 3.6% to €11.96 on news of the iPhone price cut, since the reduction should boost volumes, and therefore the German chipmaker’s revenues from its deal to supply Apple with core components. ‘We believe that the significant price cut announced by Apple for the iPhone is a positive for Infineon, which supplies a complete Edge platform to Apple,’ said Didier Scemama, analyst with ABN Amro. He added that by the end of 2007 Infineon will have shipped 4m of these platforms, and reiterated a ‘buy’ valuation on the stock. Other analysts were positive too, pointing to Infineon’s return to profitability in its wireless division, thanks to its deal with Nokia, which is starting to compensate for the disaster of the insolvency of BenQ Europe (formerly Siemens Mobile), which had been Infineon’s largest wireless customer. iSuppli believes that Infineon’s contribution to the iPhone accounts for $15.25, or 6.1%, of the model’s base cost of $265.83.

iPhone sales update:

Apple’s iPhone outsold all other high end smartphones in the US during July, its first month on the market, and equaled the sales of the most popular ‘feature phone’, LG’s Chocolate, according to research from iSuppli.

We may argue about the category definitions, but the statistics are strong for the iPhone, which accounted for 1.8% of handset sales to US consumers during the month. iSuppli expects a total of 4.5m iPhones to ship in 2007, rising to more than 30m in 2011.

The 4Gb and 8Gb models beat the other devices placed in the smartphone category inthis report ‘ including the BlackBerry, Palm portfolio and high end Motorola, Samsung and Nokia models.

Among the iPhones sold, 57% went to consumers under 35 years old, 52% were bought by males, 62% by people with college degrees or further. More importantly for exclusive carrier AT&T, 25% of the purchases involved a customer switching from another network. Lower prices and a 3G option will be key to achieving the 30m prediction, said the analysts.

Zune Phone?

Microsoft could join the race to offer converged phone/digital media devices, alongside the iPhone, Sony Ericsson Walkman handsets and the new Nokia music-oriented platforms. The company said last week that it was ‘not unreasonable’ to speculate that the company could introduce a smartphone based on its Zune digital music player, even though CEO Steve Ballmer said earlier this year that such a device was not on the cards. Instead, Ballmer said then, Microsoft would add more music and gaming functions to Windows Mobile.

However, now there is some pressure on Microsoft to unify its device platforms, both for efficiency in hardware and software production and also to provide a commonly branded, multi-model range like Sony’s or Apple’s.

Speaking at the Citigroup technology conference in New York City last week, Microsoft’s corporate VP for the entertainment and device division, Mindy Mount, outlined the future of Windows Mobile and Zune, giving rise to the Zune handset talk.

Mount said of Zune: ‘We all feel that last year was a good, solid effort for first year. I’d give it a B minus. Some things were really great.’ The Zune positives included ‘some elements of hardware’ and the video screen, Mount said, while the negatives included its weight and the failings of the Zune video service.

Mount denied there was a Zune phone in the wings imminently, but said it would be a logical possibility in future, especially as its hardware, software and services are integrated ‘ the area where Microsoft, like Nokia, sees its strength – and its quest for scale and influence – lying. ‘Clearly we do identify mobile being more integrated with photos and music,’ Mount said. ‘It’s a natural thing to have in our product roadmap.’