Sony has significantly boosted the fortunes of its Sony Ericsson handset joint venture by donating its high profile Walkman and Cybershot brands to the cause, with the former the only logo with a hope of touching that of iPhone/iTunes in mobile music. But many believe the real killer move for the smartphone maker in its core multimedia heartland would be to import the PSP (PlayStation Portable) gaming brand to the phone market. The Japanese giant may have come a step closer to taking on the iPhone by the jugular, filing two patents that point to a touchscreen gaming/phone device with direct and gesture-based input.
The two newly filed US patent applications show a handheld touchscreen unit with both methods of input plus a system called ‘tactile pixels’ for feedback ‘ this is based on a grid of small ‘bumps’ that would lift to reach the screen and help simulate physical button presses. The patent suggests that individual tactile pixels could serve as an alternative control mechanism to the main touchscreen, and it says that it would be the first touchscreen to receive ‘visible and mechanical’ input at the same time.
Potential applications of the invention are listed in the filings as gaming devices, phones, portable media players, web browser devices, navigators and email gadgets. One of the patents is credited to Phil Harrison, until February the president of Sony Computer Entertainment and a key player in developing the PlayStation business.
Of course, these are just patent filings and there is a long way to go before they may turn into a PSP phone, but the documents indicate how the race to innovate in the area of touchscreens and other forms of input, and in high end mediaphones in general, is heating up. While some majors like Nokia are focusing more intently on attracting applications software and achieving mass presence in smartphones from high end to midrange, others are betting their futures on leading the market in hi-tech usability and multimedia features. Currently, Apple’s efforts are grabbing the headlines, and Sony Ericsson, with the help of its Japanese co-parent’s consumer electronics expertise, is fighting hard.
The real innovators are often the Koreans, however, especially LG, whose upgraded Chocolate phone is due shortly. LG has often accused Apple of copying its ideas and even filed patent suits against the US company shortly after the original iPhone launch. Now there are signs that the Korean government, always a key player in the fortunes of the country’s hi-tech companies, may be taking on the battle. ETRI, Korea’s state-funded technology research center, has filed a lawsuit for patent violation against Sony Ericsson, HTC and Kyocera for alleged infringement of three 3G patents, filing in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. ETRI is claiming ‘significant royalties’ and hints strongly that other suits may follow.
These specific patents cover digital modulation schemes – Orthogonal Complex Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (POCQPSK), acquisition indication sense MA (AiSMA), and Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (QPSK), which were patented in the US in 2002, 2003 and 1999 respectively. More important, though, is the indication that, in common with Japanese and Chinese companies and governments, Korea is seeking to swing the balance of the IPR burden in mobile communications away from the west and in its own favor, a battle that has already played a major role in WiMAX, where core technology comes from Samsung, and which is now spreading to mediaphones.
ETRI said in a statement: ‘We will be shifting our focus of claiming our intellectual property rights from protection of core technologies to profiteering from them. We will maximize royalty income from our proprietary technologies.’