When giants enter a previously niche market, it is clearly a sharp doubled-edged sword for the specialists that previously ruled the roost – they can ride on the wave of an expanding sector and the marketing efforts of larger suppliers, but also face fearsome new competitors. A wave of shake-out becomes inevitable, with a single specialized vendor usually left standing independent at the end of it, and WiMAX will be no exception. Already we have seen the flag wavers for the non-WiMAX mobile broadband technologies – Flarion and IPWireless – snapped up, while would-be WiMAX majors like Motorola are engaging in acquisition sprees to flesh out their offerings (including Moto’s takeover of equipment vendor NextNet from Clearwire). As the 802.16 pioneers seek to differentiate their products from those of their larger rivals, they are at the same time positioning themselves as attractively as possible for when potential buyers come knocking.
This is a particularly difficult task for companies that are publicly listed but have been struggling financially, as the experience of WiLan showed in 2005-6, and now fellow Canadian vendor looks likely to be the next pawn in the WiMAX M&A game. The company has wrestled with a series of financial setbacks and restructurings, despite having a rich store of technology resources, and now admits that it is considering a sale of the organization. This could be a good result, given that SR will have serious problems gaining the financial stability that it needs to make the most of its technology assets, but with the turmoil of the past few years, and the wide variety of companies on offer to WiMAX-hungry acquirers, it may struggle to attract a high price.
Despite this, the company told Canadian reporters that sale was only one option – although it certainly needs a new financing partner to fund its continuing reorganization – and that “it’s certainly not a fire sale”. Other options, the board said, are to attract a strategic investor or a further restructuring of operations, and indicated that talks were ongoing with several potential investors. However, investors were less confident – and are unlikely to look kindly on the ‘further restructuring’ option unless accompanied by significant financial injections, after a series of attempts that have yielded only limited results. SR’s shares lost almost 10% after its statements, falling to 18.5 cents on the Toronto Stock Exchange. This is a sad contrast with the company’s high of $9.41 in February 2004, eight years after SR launched on the stock exchange. The all-time low was 13 cents in January 2006. If current efforts fail, the company could be forced to seek creditor protection, and is releasing only condensed full year results for 2006 until its future is more certain, admitting there were doubts about its ‘ongoing concern’ status until new financing is achieved.
This financial position clearly makes it tough for SR to play in the same league as the majors, or even the well funded start-ups, since it needs cash to develop and launch its products in an increasingly impatient broadband wireless market, and to continue to restructure. However, as of April 30 2007, the company held just $17.6m in cash, down from $27.1m four months earlier. The year end balance sheet showed total assets of $150.6m, including $27.8m in intangibles, against $139.6m in liabilities.
The company spokesperson admitted SR was caught in a “chain reaction”, and still seeking to put into place a new restructuring plan, instigated by a new CEO, Serge Fortin, and CFO back in July, which looked to reverse many of the previously announced corporate changes. Chairman Lionel Hurtubise said in a statement: “While SR Telecom has clearly made significant progress throughout 2006 by executing on its WiMAX strategy, the legacy of the organization’s past restructuring efforts continue to disrupt operations and weigh heavily on our financial performance.”
He stressed that he believed the product and operational decisions made in the past year had been correct and would eventually deliver fruit. These decisions have included a strategy to try to survive the inevitable hiatus before the 802.16e Wave 2 certification process (the critical one for more large scale deployers) is fully underway. This involved ploughing significant development resources into a 16d platform that is positioned as more than a stopgap on the way to 16e, but rather as a fully functioning system in its own right, which operators will be able to migrate to 16e because of Intel’s dual-mode Rosedale and other advances, but when their mobility plans require that, not because it has run out of basic capability. In the early years of WiMAX, SR was one of the companies that aimed to go directly to 16e rather than incur a dual R&D burden, but it changed its mind early in 2006 and received certification for its symmetry MX base stations and CPE last May (it also offers symmetry One, a pre-16e product). SR stakes its differentiation on implementing advanced techniques in both 16d and, in future, 16e, some of them – notably space time coding or STC, which improves indoor performance and plug and play capabilities – uniquely adopted by the company. It has also, like Aperto, put great efforts into QoS, supporting 1,000 classes of service including six channels for VoIP.
SR Telecom is highly aware that most large carriers – and its target base, including key customers Telefonica and Telstra, is more tier one than most specialists – require plug and play, self-installable CPE. It has taken the risk of ploughing big sums into developing this, even at a time of financial turbulence for the company, largely at the behest of key clients such as Telefonica for its wide scale Spanish roll-out. Now it hopes to carve out a leading position in indoor, plug and play CPE even before MIMO-enabled wave 2 16e makes this commonplace. STC is the main technique that SR claims puts it ahead of other indoor CPE makers – notably Airspan and Alvarion – and this is now supported by Intel in Rosedale 2.
All this fits with SR’s heritage as a developer of strong broadband wireless technology for carrier class roll-outs – built, in particular, on its acquisition in 2003 of Netro, a company that had previously bought AT&T’s Project Angel experimental BWA platform. But despite that, it has been plagued with setback after setback in its attempts at refinancing and reorganization, and these are far from behind it. Last fall, announcing its third quarter, SR claimed this was the time that the company finally shook off the financial impact of legacy restructuring efforts with a final Can$29m restructuring charge, and also announced $20m in new funding through a five-year convertible term loan with existing creditors. In the summer, it had gained $50m in emergency credit, converted $73m in debentures into equity and raised $54m in new equity though private placements.
But six months later, the impact of these various provisions seems not to be heavy enough. The company does not expect to issue first quarter results before the May 15 filing deadline, and it released unaudited, condensed results for 2006, with the proviso that there was “doubt about the appropriateness” of its going-concern assumption, “given the uncertainty regarding the outcome of the company’s discussions about its financing options.
There was some light in the abbreviated results. Revenue for 2006 was reported at $87.5m, up 15% from $76.4m in 2005, an increase attributed to a production ramp-up early in the year, but the effect of this on finances had been diluted considerably by problems with the company’s new outsourcing agreements. This had delayed wireless product shipments throughout the second half of the year and resulted in $5.4m in late delivery penalties. Meanwhile, the bottom line was hit by a $16.4m increase in SG&A expenses and a $14.3m rise in restructuring charges. Consolidated net loss was $115.6m, including special charges, deepening the 2005 loss of $91m.
The latest round of reorganization includes the loss of 75 jobs to save $5.5m in operating costs, plus the wind-up of the legacy SR500 and Airstar product lines within the next two months. SR has also confirmed its manufacturing agreement with Taiwan-based MTI to build WiMAX base stations and CPE, a move that the company hopes will address its recent supply problems.
Such changes look horribly like a company just chipping away at its problems, and SR’s best hope seems to lie in finding an acquirer that is attracted by its technological advances, buoyed by the company’s refusal to sacrifice R&D investment for short term gain in the difficult years, which could give a new WiMAX vendor some readymade product advantages. SR does have some major customers, notably Telef’nica in Spain, and has deployments in 130 countries, but it is relatively behind the curve in converting its business to WiMAX, and so the user base would present an acquirer with the challenges of supporting and converting (or dumping) legacy installations, which could outweigh the attractions of readymade revenue. The company will need a buyer in the short to medium term, to be able to exploit its technology base effectively, and at this point, a would-be investor would presumably want to be confident that there could be an M&A exit route, and one that would still exist once the large vendors are catching up with some of SR’s product advances. It would be easier and more advantageous to find a savior now, while the market is still immature and the majors scrabbling to launch real products, but whether SR can gain the valuation its products and skills should be worth remains doubtful.