Moves by the European Union’s telecoms chief, Viviane Reding, to create a ‘super-regulator’ for the region, are arousing fears among some national incumbent telcos that they will be broken up.
Reding plans to publish proposals for a new pan-European regulatory structure in October and already various bodies are jostling for position to take control of the huge task. She has already stated that, as well as reducing the autonomy of national regulators, she would like to see some national operators broken up to boost competition. The most likely candidates would be France Telecom and Deutsche Telekom, which Reding argues stifle competition by using their control over existing infrastructure to keep out new entrants. Other countries where she is said to consider broadband competition, in particular, too weak include Poland, Slovakia, Romania, Greece, Bulgaria and Ireland. The most likely route would be to split the telcos into two ‘ one to run and invest in national infrastructure and one to compete in offering services on that network.
Any changes that Reding will propose will need to be approved by the governments of the member nations, so national telecom operators are lobbying hard in Brussels and in their local capitals to try to limit her plans.
France Telecom said in a statement last month: “We think functional separation is a false good idea – it looks like a good idea, but it’s not necessarily’, arguing that break-up would degrade network quality as the company in charge of the infrastructure would have little incentive to adopt high standards. In a statement, Deutsche Telekom warned that a split of its operations could be so expensive that it would do more harm than good. “The costs [of a split] to the network providers could be higher than the benefits to the consumer or the market,” it said.
Reding’s model is clearly British Telecom, which split network access from consumer operations in 2005.