Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 April 2013

The new-look RAN ushers in disruptive economics and vendor shake-up

The initial 3G experience seemed to have set the wireless RAN infrastructure market in stone, with a handful of virtually unassailable vendors controlling the whole supply chain and sharing the operators’ budgets. Consolidation was the name of the game, not new players or approaches, as firms acquired weaker rivals to gain scale and market influence. However, in the past couple of years, several factors have emerged which point to a shake-up in the old order.

Most importantly, they are:
‘ The shift of the small cell trend, started in the home, to public access, carrier networks. This has brought start-ups into the heart of the cellco’s network and most disruptively, enabled Cisco finally to seize a key role in the RAN.
‘ The evolution of the macrocell, deconstructing the traditional architecture to separate baseband processing from radios and antennas, then virtualize this in the cloud. That trend has generally been dominated by the large OEMs, but it is changing the balance of power. Samsung, for instance, is leveraging the new Cloud-RAN and small cell architectures to gain a presence in LTE which it did not achieve in 3G, while new technologies which are strategic to the new-look RAN ‘ such as active antennas ‘ are ushering new names into the supply chain.
‘ Cloud-RAN, smart small cells and the emergence of carrier SDN (software defined networking) highlight how the value in the RAN market has shifted from hardware to software, and over time, some vendors are likely to make their network intelligence products, which deliver their competitive edge and profit, independent of their base stations or routers.
‘ This fits in with another important trend, for operators to seek to grab back power from their large suppliers by supporting multivendor, software programmable networks based on standards, in which it is easier to mix and match kit and avoid vendor lock-in. The small cell wave, in particular, is encouraging interest in this potentially massive change in the operator/vendor balance of power.
These factors are identified and analyzed in a new report from Maravedis-Rethink, entitled ‘Forecasting The New RAN: How carriers will monetize the data deluge’.

While hardware commoditizes, operators will increase efficiency and value in their RANs by adopting software-defined technologies such as virtualization. For the first time in a decade, there is a real prospect of a shake-up in the RAN vendor landscape, and the winners will be those who innovate not just in network topology but in software.

Small cells and distributed RANs, the twin hallmarks of the new mobile broadband network, will squeeze revenues from traditional base stations, providing the opportunity for smaller vendors, with advanced technology in these areas, to move up the rankings or, in the case of start-ups, to seek well-priced acquisitions, as seen last week when Cisco snapped up small cell pioneer Ubiquisys. Macrocells will peak in numbers in 2016 and their slow decline will spark immense disruption while suppliers with a focus on C-RAN and/or metrocells will enhance their position (ZTE and NEC come to mind).

But Cisco stands to gain the most, as the mobile network becomes an IP one, built around routers and increasingly commoditized base stations. The networking giant is building its armory for its biggest ever assault on the carrier market, and the more that sector adopts the approaches of Cisco’s enterprise heartland ‘ SDN, standardized hardware, cloud platforms and so on ‘ the more dangerous the firm will be to Ericsson and the other giants. That is true even if it never really goes head-to-head with the big OEMs by launching a macrocell ‘ a very unlikely eventuality. Instead it will move into the cellco’s systems from the technologies that surround the traditional RAN ‘ small cells, private and public; routers; the packet core; the intelligence to make sense of all these new components.

Ubiquisys is just the latest in a string of purchases to build that carrier platform. The US giant will pay $310m for the UK start-ups, an early mover in femtocells – the tiny, low power base stations which started life as closed, residential coverage boosters and have evolved into public access metrocells for indoor and outdoor use. Cisco’s initial small cell partner was another UK innovator, ip.access, with which it provided AT&T with its femtocells. As the market’s attention shifts from private, indoor modules to public access cells and LTE, Cisco has said it will develop its own platform, and Ubiquisys brings it the technology and skills to do this.

The deal is expected to close in the fourth quarter of Cisco’s 2013 fiscal year and the Ubiquisys team will join the giant’s service provider mobility business, reporting to Partho Mishra. ‘Small cell technologies are one of the most cost effective ways to add data capacity and will grow in importance as service providers address the explosion of mobile network traffic.’ Wrote analyst Brian Marshall of ISI Group in a client note quoted by Bloomberg. ‘The acquisition adds to the mobility capabilities Cisco has been building up.’

Ubiquisys was co-founded in 2004 by three executives including current CTO Will Franks and has received funding from Accel Partners, Google, Advent Venture Partners and T-Mobile Venture Fund, among others. The firm initially created indoor ‘femtocells’ but in recent years has expanded its vision, producing a software platform that enables partners to develop small cells at low cost; moving towards public access and LTE cells; and working with Intel on the ‘smart cell’, a companion system to carry out processing tasks such as caching at the cell edge.

Ubiquisys has worked with assorted larger partners, including NEC of Japan. The purchase accelerates Cisco’s move into the heart of the cellco network via metrocells, and improves its competitive position against small cell enthusiasts such as Alcatel-Lucent, and more cautious movers like Ericsson.

After a period of austerity while it reorganized its business, Cisco is back in full serial acquirer mode. Several of its recent purchases epitomize the key issues in the new-look RAN, including deals for self-optimizing networking start-up Intucell for $475m, policy vendor BroadHop, and enterprise cloud specialist Meraki for $1.2bn. These three belong to the category of technologies which will shift attention from hardware to software, bringing flexibility and intelligence to the RAN, while squeezing capex on traditional base stations as these commoditize. It is notable that Cisco is also selling some units, significantly Linksys, part of that commoditized hardware landscape from which value is rapidly draining.

Some vendors, however, will benefit from that trend by innovating in ways to support standardized, low cost network hardware. Movements in this direction kicked off with the creation of standard interfaces between base station elements, notably the OBSAI and CPRI definitions. The ability to link different remote radio heads to basebands was followed by similar standards for antennas, which will allow operators to mix and match their equipment, reducing cost and seeking best of breed solutions.

CommScope has been a prime mover in many of these developments, and its latest contribution to affordable, off-the-shelf RAN comes with the announcement of the world’s first factory assembled tower tops for base station remote radios. It is deploying this kit initially with Middle Eastern operator Ooredoo (formerly Qtel), aiming to reduce deployment time and improve installation quality.

The two companies have developed remote radios which are pre-assembled according to a single global design standard, leading to a radio vendor-agnostic system that does not require significant on-site remote radio modifications for future upgrades. In the past, CommScope said, the lack of a single tower-top design standard has made each upgrade a complex process. The tower-top solution will become Ooredoo’s standard cell site design across its markets in the Middle East, North Africa and Asia, and support a network modernization strategy of upgrading or replacing 15,000 macro base stations over the coming years.The tower tops are vendor agnostic and support virtually all current frequency bands and technologies, said the carrier.

Ooredoo’s CTO Paul Salmon said: “Ooredoo is embarking on a radical plan to upgrade network sites as part of our mission to stimulate human growth. Working with CommScope to develop a new tower top solution that is assembled in a factory will enable us to deliver a distinctly different approach to building and operating a wireless network.’

This is just one approach, but it epitomizes the approach of the new RAN, and the way that traditional economics will be thrown upside-down ‘ potentially with those vendors which fail to adapt sufficiently quickly. Standard designs and interfaces, enabling multivendor, multi-technology networks – with differentiation taking place in software and network planning ‘ will be the order of the future, leading to a model that will be closer to that of the enterprise.

“Forecasting The New RAN: How carriers will monetize the data deluge” is published next week by Maravedis-Rethink and also forms part of the full RAN subscription research service. For more details and an executive summary, please contact [email protected].