Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 February 2013

The old Wintel partners forge new mobile alliances for emerging markets

The challenges of the Wintel partnership in penetrating the mobile world are well documented, and they are largely meeting them separately these days as Microsoft gets closer to Qualcomm/ARM and Intel to Android. This month’s launch of tablets and notebooks running the x86 version of Windows 8 does, of course, represent the latest push by the old alliance into the ‘post-PC’ future. How far W8 Pro devices can marginalize ARM-based Windows RT and colonize new form factors, rather than just allowing the PC to evolve by a step or two, will be important in shaping the device landscape at the high end ‘ and deciding how much weight Microsoft gives RT in future.

But to create impact on virgin user bases, and wrongfoot more powerful mobile players in the process, both Microsoft and Intel are focusing (separately) on emerging economy bases where PCs have scarcely shown their faces.

Intel has seen its belated breakthroughs in smartphone chips coming from partners in emerging markets ‘ counter-intuitively, given that its strengths lie in high performance processing rather than low cost and power. And Microsoft has brought its activities in Africa far closer to its commercial heart. Whereas the firm has always sought to spread its platforms to users without the resources for PCs, via initiatives like One Laptop Per Child, it is now addressing these untapped segments with an eye on immediate commercial returns, partnering with Huawei in its new 4Afrika program.

The initial device in this initiative is a co-branded, $150 Windows Phone handset made by Huawei, though the effort will extend through the year to other partners and devices. It shows Microsoft’s increasing desire to control the devices which run its platforms, not just by imposing strict rules on partners, but by branding the products itself. At the high end, as seen in the Surface RT, this causes more headaches than gains, alienating OEMs and confusing consumers, many of whom rate the hardware brands more highly than Microsoft’s own.

In emerging markets, the strategy makes more sense however. Hardware brands like Huawei are less recognized because handsets have usually been white-labelled by a carrier or other service provider ‘ whereas Microsoft has significant recognition even where PC usage is low. A fully integrated hardware/software platform can reduce cost and complexity for carriers addressing low-ARPU user bases.

And vendors concerned by that low spending power will welcome Microsoft’s apparent willingness to subsidize its products in order to encourage uptake, in markets where the cellcos rarely perform that function. So the 4Afrika device is a fully fledged Windows Phone 8 product ‘ not an entry level smartphone running the WP7 Tango release, as often pushed by Nokia at emerging economies. It is actually a variant of the midrange Ascend W1, which is targeted at Europe and costs $300 there. It has a dual-core, 1.2GHz Snapdragon processor, 480×800 pixel screen, two cameras and 4Gbytes of storage, though for neighbourhoods where power is unreliable, the key feature may be standby time, rated at 420 hours.

Huawei, of course, brings cost efficiencies of its own, but it was still a surprise choice to spearhead the new initiative, given Microsoft’s close alliance with Nokia, which has hefty featurephone presence and strong carrier relationships in many parts of Africa and also sells some entry level Lumias there. The Finnish company has reportedly been the main force pushing Microsoft to adapt Windows Phone for entry level hardware specs, though the success of its Asha ‘smart featurephone’ may have reduced the urgency with which Nokia is moving towards really entry level Lumia models ‘ and possibly created conflicts with Microsoft. It looks more likely than it did a year ago that Nokia could retain a multi-OS strategy, evolving the Asha Series 40 platform towards a Linux-based OS (its own or Android) while keeping Windows Phone for the high end (see inset). Huawei, of course, already has a multiplatform approach to support its aggressive 2013 targets for handset growth. Android has been its focus, but it now appears that Microsoft has wooed it into giving Windows Phone a far more strategic role.

Whatever the tensions between Microsoft and its major ally, highlighted by the deals this week with Huawei and Dell, the Windows giant has certainly woken up to a message Nokia has often preached ‘ the need to steal an early march for Windows Phone in markets where Apple and even Android do not yet have a tight hold, leveraging local content and partners.

Microsoft says in a blog post that the handset also comes preloaded with certain applications, reflecting common policy among operators and vendors in emerging markets, to bundle devices with web services or localized apps. Microsoft says 4Afrika comes with ‘custom apps created by African developers for African consumers’ and there will also be a subset of the Windows Phone store dedicated to relevant local items. Local content, often ignored by Apple and others, has long been recognized by Nokia, in particular, as an important differentiator, and a key factor in its past glories in India.

This attempt to sneak in ahead of Android and Apple was reflected in comments by Ali Faramaway, Microsoft’s VP for the Middle East and Africa, in a company blog post, where he wrote: ‘When we look at the world, many see China or the BRIC countries as the next big opportunity for growth. At Microsoft, we view the African continent as a gamechanger in the global economy. We believe deeply in the potential of technology to change Africa, and we equally believe in the potential of Africa to change technology for the world.’

The handset will be available in blue, red, black and white when it launches later this month in Angola, Egypt, Ivory Coast, Kenya, Morocco, Nigeria and South Africa.

The strategy sees Microsoft positioning itself rather as Apple is likely to do, if and when it debuts an iPhone for mass emerging market bases ‘ not trying to take on the thankless sub-$75 smartphone segment, but hovering in a slightly higher, but still affordable price range, and justifying that with a better quality and consistency of experience. Microsoft’s tight reference platform for WP8 should ensure that the 4Afrika will deliver a far better experience than cheap Android handsets based on less powerful components and of variable quality.

Microsoft will ensure that 4Afrika and future devices are part of a broader wireless and web platform for new user groups. This week it said it was working with authorities and ISPs in Kenya to deliver low cost broadband accessing using the experimental white spaces spectrum and devices, and solar-powered base stations. And it will launch an online hub in April for small businesses in parts of Africa, giving them free services and domain registration.

We can expect to see Microsoft working on new device types and with a widening range of applications, content and chip partners. It has been active for several years in platforms to enable ultra-low cost handsets and other web-enabled form factors, which often involve integrating web services directly onto the chip. This was seen in the alliance it formed with MediaTek in early 2010, focusing on low cost reference designs for emerging economies, and in its OneApp and Fone+ initiatives. Both these were created at the end of the last decade by the software giant’s ‘Unlimited Potential Group’ and have seen their ideas moving towards the mainstream at Microsoft and elsewhere. Fone+ was a midrange concept phone that would also serve as a PC, connecting to a TV to provide a large screen, while OneApp was a software platform for featurephones.

MediaTek itself is a master at integrating software straight onto its chipsets, and has done this with Facebook, Baidu search and most recently, Opera Software’s TV Store, an HTML5 app store for smart TVs and media players. By implementing it on-chip, cost and time to market are greatly reduced.

This pre-integrated, reference design approach was once alien to Intel, but it has had to borrow many of the tactics of MediaTek to push Atom chipsets into smartphones for emerging markets. Like Microsoft, it may be trying to work around the most entrenched bases for Qualcomm and other established smartphone players, building beach-heads in emerging markets and tier two vendors in order to prove Atom’s capabilities and notch up some comparatively easy market share. “We’ve made a conscious effort to go after these fast growing markets as our first foray into the business,” Mike Bell, head of Intel’s mobile division, told Reuters.

So, while the firm has signed OEMs like Motorola Mobility (with Droid RAZRi) and Lenovo, many of its commercial launches so far have been for Asia and African markets ‘ the Xolo from Indian vendor Lava International, followed by the new Yolo, which will be launched by Safaricom in Kenya. The Yolo comes bundled with 500Mbytes of free data and runs Android, plus the new low power Atom chipset, Z2420 or Lexington. It sports a 3.5-inch touchscreen display, FM radio, 5-megapixel back camera, expandable memory slot, HSPA+ and Intel’s McAfee mobile security software. The Z240 was unveiled at the Consumer Electronics Show earlier this month, and is targeted at the ‘value smartphone’ market.

Meanwhile, Intel was also making waves in south east Asia with the launch of Acer’s Liquid C1 model ‘ also using Lexington – initially in Thailand but then due to roll out around the region, though at the relatively high cost of $330. Like Microsoft, Intel is not going after the ultra-low cost space where MediaTek and Chinese rivals would be hard to catch. Instead, it is targeting the $200-$500 range where there is still significant growth potential in emerging economies. The C1 is the ninth Atom device to launch since April 2012 and ‘Intel Inside’ handsets have appeared in Europe, Africa, Latin America, Russia, India and China, some branded by operators like Orange in the UK or now Safaricom in Africa.

After repeated failures, Intel has invested heavily not just in the chips, but the relationships and surrounding expertise that will turn into mobile influence. It acquired Infineon Wireless for modem technology and is tapping into its longstanding relationships with PC makers like Acer, Lenovo and Asustek, which have the same urgent need to cross the PC/mobile divide. Industry sources in Taiwan have often said that Intel had offered major incentives to OEMs and ODMs to try its mobile chips and Intel executives acknowledged in the Reuters report that they had shouldered some costs, though said that had not gone as far as buying a production line.

However, such a tactic might not be entirely out of the question. Just as Microsoft and Google are spending their cash on hardware partners, device subsidies and inhouse gadgets, so Intel could invest its resources in buying its own friends.