The two main organizations working on open RAN specifications, Telecom Infra Project (TIP) and the O-RAN Alliance, have addressed a major perceived barrier to a common RAN platform by announcing a liaison agreement to ensure their efforts are aligned.
Although the two groups have very different starting points, and their work is largely complementary, there has been a widespread perception that they were in competition to provide specs for some key elements of an open network, such as a common fronthaul interface or a distributed cell site gateway (DCSG). The fact they each had different initiatives for such elements, and different operators appeared to be the main drivers (AT&T in O-RAN, for example, and Vodafone or Telefónica in TIP), fuelled the idea that they were in danger of splitting the nascent movement in two.
Now, the groups have announced a “new level of collaboration” – this stops well short of merger or full convergence, but should make it far clearer to the industry where each organization is focused, and how their efforts will align and, where necessary, work together. For instance, both O-RAN and TIP will test new 5G solutions in a Deutsche Telekom lab in Berlin this year. This will represent the first common location for an O-RAN Open Test and Integration Center (OTIC) and a TIP Community Lab and it will focus, according to TIP, on “interop validation of O-RAN compliant RU/DU solutions leading to an upcoming Open FrontHaul (RU/DU) TIP Plugfest, as well as supporting Open Optical Packet Transport (OOPT) technology trials”.
TIP’s executive director, Attilio Zani, said: “Our hope, longer term, is that this forms the ability to accelerate the solutions that are in the marketplace and drives greater adoption of open RAN technologies across the world.”
Alex Jinsung Choi, COO of the O-RAN Alliance and SVP of strategy and technology innovation at DT, said in a statement: “Alignment on O-RAN interoperability efforts will help the industry to speed up the delivery of commercial open RAN solutions. The establishment of the first joint O-RAN Open Test and Integration Center (OTIC) with the TIP Community Lab in Berlin is a concrete step to facilitate this multi-community approach.”
Under the liaison agreement, TIP and O-RAN can share information and specs, and conduct joint testing and integration. The TIP OpenRAN 5G NR project group will release its base station platform requirements document this year with normative references to the O-RAN specifications.
However, TIP does remain neutral in its specs and works with other open groups and even formal standards bodies. For instance, it has a close alliance with the Open Networking Foundation (ONF), which houses the CORD (central office re-architected as a datacentre) projects, among others.
“We’re agnostic when it comes to the technologies that we incorporate in our project groups so when it comes to looking for a specification to create a product in the OpenRAN space we’ll look around to see if there’s something pre-existing,” Zani said last year. “We are not at all defensive with anyone else. We’re not looking to own a space in any way so we’re open to working with 3GPP, ETSI, and other organizations to take a specification, work it through a set of requirements, and define a solution.”
However, such an agnostic approach can also appear to be confused. Back in 2018, Axel Clauberg, who was (until recently) chair of TIP and a senior executive in DT, called for greater collaboration between different initiatives, but also for greater clarity of purpose. He showed how OpenRAN and ORAN could complement one another, highlighting that Telefónica and Vodafone, as well as being leaders of the TIP OpenRAN project, also planned to base their work on the ORAN specs – this was subsequently clear in the requirements of the RFQ (request for quotes) which Vodafone issued for open RAN technology across its European site footprint.
Clauberg explained the difference between the groups, saying that TIP “has not done any specs from the ground up. They have not built architecture but are looking at how the architecture specified by the O-RAN Alliance could be built and deployed in a commercial way. In this area, TIP would do solutions integration and prove it is possible to build such an open RAN in real life.”
Last week, Dan Rabinovitsj, VP of Facebook Connectivity, enlarged on the complementary theme, saying that TIP is more focused on plugfests and system level issues than writing new specs. “We’re interested in how do you take disaggregated RAN transport and core elements and be able to swap between them and still come out with the same outcome for mobile operators?” he said in an interview. “We’re much more focused on how do we get the whole industry to collaborate on making stuff actually work in the real world when you have to plug it together.”
Now, operators which have been prominent in O-RAN development and trials, like Rakuten, are starting to join TIP too, though TIP’s new chairman comes from a bedrock supporter, Vodafone. Santiago Tenorio, Vodafone Group’s head of network strategy and architecture, will replace Clauberg, who stepped down when he left DT for Amazon Web Services at the start of this year.