The big name wireless lawsuits are still rolling on, but this year, for the first time, patent trolls were behind more than half of IPR lawsuits filed in the US. Right on cue, well known ‘patent assertion’ firm, WiLan of Canada, has launched its latest attack, this time against RIM’s use of Bluetooth in BlackBerry.
Patent trolls, which own IPR purely to secure licensing fees rather than to develop products, were behind 62% of suits filed this year, up to December 1, according to a study by Collenn Chien, a law professor at University of California. Although these were across various industries, the report highlights the rising concern in the wireless sector about the patent arms races, often led by trolls, which threaten to add to product costs and involve vendors in costly legal battles. In 2011, 45% of patent lawsuits were filed by companies with no products, up from 29% in 2010, and this year, 61% of defendants had been sued by a licensing firm which had previously filed suit eight or more times.
All this reflects the growing aggression of some IPR holders as the value of patents, especially in wireless, rises. WiLan, which has a collection of 3,000 issued or pending patents often related to fundamental technologies such as Wi-Fi, has been engaged in lawsuits against some of the biggest names in the sector since it abandoned its original business as a broadband wireless equipment vendor in 2006 and decided to focus only on licensing.
Its latest target is RIM, which has been hit with a patent infringement suit in the Southern District of Florida. Products claimed to be in violation include the BlackBerry Bold and Torch, and the defunct PlayBook tablet. WiLan is citing Bluetooth assets which have been one of the weapons it has wielded most dramatically in recent years. In 2010, Bluetooth patents were cited in a huge suit against almost a score of the hi-tech sector’s big names, including Apple and Sony.
In other technology areas, last year WiLan launched various lawsuits connected to CDMA, HSPA, Wi-Fi or LTE, targeting Apple, HP, Dell and others. Last week, it added suits in Florida against Apple, HTC and Sierra Wireless USA, all focused on LTE patents; as well as two separate actions in Texas against Apple and Sierra, related to HSPA.
Such firms will never attract the attention of the prize fights between the big names when they reach patent court. Judge Lucy Koh, who is presiding over the Apple-Samsung patents fight in federal court in Silicon Valley, has once again urged the two giants to make peace.
After a hearing last Thursday, she seemed near the end of her patience, saying: “It’s time for global peace.’ She added: “Is there anything the court can do? I’m more than willing to issue orders. It would be good for consumers, good for the industry, good for the parties.” Apple and Samsung met ahead of the trial to discuss a settlement, in court-mandated talks that did not lead to a resolution.
Koh is echoing a line increasingly heard from her fellow judges in handset IPR cases round the world ‘ that the costly and distracting tit-for-tat cases and appeals are damaging for consumer choice and innovation. After Apple raised hopes of a broader truce by settling with HTC last month, Samsung took a stubborn line, with its mobile chief insisting it had no plans to negotiate with Apple. However, one of the Korean firm’s attorneys, Charles Verhoeven, was in more conciliatory mood in court, saying, as reported by CNet: ‘We are willing. The ball’s in their court.”
This was the San Jose court where Samsung suffered its biggest loss against Apple to date when a jury awarded over $!bn in damages against it for infringing Apple patents. The validity of some of those patents, however, has now been questioned by the US Patents and Trademarks Office and the judgement will go to appeal, though Samsung is requesting a retrial, citing jury misconduct. Both sides are also trying to broaden their respective claims to include newer device models and larger damages.
Samsung has been granted access to the terms of Apple’s licensing deal with HTC, on the grounds that it almost certainly contains some of the same patents as in the Korean firm’s case, and could weaken Apple’s decision to pursue product injunctions. Many elements of the deal, excluding actual royalties and other commercial items, must be made fully public, according to a judge.
Under the deal, HTC is forbidden from making and selling mobile devices that copy what is described as the ‘distinctive Apple user experience’, according to a redacted version of the document, filed in a California court. Examples of technologies which could be included in that ‘distinctive’ definition include the ‘slide to unlock’ feature at the bottom of the screen ‘ but another element at the heart of several trials, ‘pinch to zoom’ would not count.
This would be categorized as a ‘cloned feature’, and disputes over cloning are to be referred for arbitration, if the two firms fail to agree. If arbitration goes against HTC, it would have to remove a cloned element within 90 days. Only features designed directly by HTC ‘ not third party software such as Android ‘ are included in this process. Any arbitration requests are to be submitted to the International Centre for Dispute Resolution, and hearings will be held in Paris. The agreement does not give HTC rights to Apple’s design patents.
Apple is also on the same side as an Android player, for once, in its bid for patents being sold by Kodak. It has joined forces with Google to offer more than $500m for the fallen camera giant’s portfolio.
In the summer, the two mobile leaders were taking part in separate groups to bid for the 1,100-strong collection of imaging patents, which Kodak is selling from bankruptcy protection. According to Bloomberg sources, the two firms are now collaborating, perhaps to avoid the price war which developed when Nortel sold its patents, also in bankruptcy court. On that occasion, Apple teamed up with Microsoft, RIM, Ericsson and others to deprive Google of the 6,000-strong pile, but had to pay $4.5bn.
“Apple and Google learned a lesson from the Nortel’s auction,’ Richard Ehrlickman, former VP of intellectual property at IBM, told Bloomberg. ‘They have decided to come together in this process to reduce the cost of purchasing the Kodak patents, while meeting their business needs.’
At least such an approach could also reduce the possibility of one firm wielding the IPR over the other in future lawsuits, as signs grow that Apple is ready to settle many of its handset patent disputes, which are proving costly and distracting, and are not delivering the quick wins the firm had hoped for against its rivals. It has already come to a licensing agreement with HTC and hinted at arbitration with Google’s Motorola Mobility unit, though Samsung remains determined to fight on.
Initially there were two main groups in the running ‘ one led by Apple and including Microsoft and Intellectual Ventures Management, the other uniting Google with patent aggregator RPX and some Asian Android OEMs. The two groups had separately offered less than $500m for Kodak’s portfolio but are likely to increase that price now they have come together.
Kodak obtained commitments for $830m exit financing last month to get itself out of bankruptcy in a massively streamlined state, but this is contingent on its sale of the digital imaging patents for at least $500m. Kodak entered Chapter XI in January. In court documents, it said the patents migth be worth $2.21bn to $2.57bn, based on an estimate by patent advisory firm 284 Partners, but some believe that price was inflated because the value is squeezed by the fact Kodak has licensed its IPR so widely ‘ to firms including Samsung, LG, Motorola and Nokia.