Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2008

Two standards efforts aim to make wireless IP universal

Two significant wireless standards-to-be are making progress this month, pointing to new applications ‘ one, the IEEE’s Wi-Fi mesh platform, geared to stimulating universal access; the other, an Internet Engineering Taskforce (IETF) set of specifications for linking sensor nets to the main internet.

The proposed IEEE WLan mesh standard, 802.11s, is still over 18 months from finalization, but is being pushed further towards the goals of the open source, open access community, incorporating changes proposed by the One Laptop Per Child Foundation and a recently launched open source project, open80211s. These have worked on aspects of the platform that have now been fed back to the 802.11s taskgroup. This will make the eventual standard more geared to the vision, expounded over the years by Microsoft and others, of supporting ad hoc Wi-Fi mesh, allowing devices of all kinds to create instant networks and connections, reducing the cost and increasing the availability of access, even in poorer communities, and removing the dependence on Ethernet cable backhaul. 802.11s, therefore, will allow different wireless devices to find each other, interconnect securely, and forward traffic on behalf of other mesh nodes, forging new paths automatically if nodes move or wireless links fail.

The first vendor to promise a commercial implementation of the draft standard ‘ following the now common practise of bringing drafts to market long before they are ratified ‘ is mesh start-up PacketHop. Another key backer is Nortel, which has significant developments and IPR in wireless mesh. “If you think about this underlying technology to form opportunistic connections, it changes a lot of the assumptions of wireless Lans,” said Robert Withrow, adviser to the Office of the CTO at Nortel, in an interview. Nortel outlines the goals of open80211s as ‘creating sourcecode that implements the draft IEEE 802.11s WLan mesh standard; connect all the Linux devices in the world to One Big Mesh’.

The 802.11 standard does specify an ad hoc mode, but this requires every participating node to be connected directly to every other node, while an 802.11s mesh does not have this limitation. The OLPC began studying mesh benefits in 2006 to support communication without the need for access points or intermediate servers, as well as sharing of backhaul such as satellite links in remote communities. The 802.11s draft was a natural choice, as the mesh works at Layer 2, requiring no changes to the TCP/IP network stack or other higher layer apps. In late 2006, chipmaker Marvell hired Cozybit, an embedded wireless consultancy, to implement and tune an early version of the 802.11s mesh protocol for OLPC. The code was running on OLPC laptops in early 2007, according to Network World. Cozybit is developing a driver and firmware, due out in early June for beta testing, to let the OLPC laptop radio run the open source 802.11s code.

Meanwhile, the IETF is looking to define an IP specification this summer to link the increasingly popular wireless sensor networks to the internet, and help define the next wave of the embedded internet. The work is being done by the body’s Routing over Low Power and Lossy Networks (Roll) group. Cisco, whose ‘distinguished engineer’
Jean-Philippe Vasseur will chair the Roll effort, says there has been a proliferation of proprietary sensor network protocols that is threatening to fragment the market. “When each one aims to become an ad hoc standard, you wind up with a model of many translation gateways, leading to a complex and expensive architecture that doesn’t scale,’ said Vasseur.

Of course, Cisco support for any IP-based standards effort is important, and shows the giant’s perennial interest in driving and controlling the latest iterations of the internet models via standards bodies as well as its own platforms. Other companies represented on Roll include France Telecom, Intel, Sun and home automation specialist Zensys. Roll will look at home, urban and industrial environments and will base its work on existing developments by the IETF i6LoWPAN group, which focuses on low power short range networks for automation and industrial monitoring, in particular. This has specified use of IPv6 over low power wireless networks.

The ultimate aim will be to create the platform for the next generation of sensor networks to use IP from end to end, but in the mean time, Roll will enable the hundreds of thousands of non-IP sensor networks already in place to communicate with each other without proprietary translation gateways. The group could choose or extend an existing protocol before its deadline of June 2009, or if it finds nothing suitable, could be briefed to create a new protocol, which could take another 18 months.

Some of the potential candidates will be IP routing technologies for Zigbee and other low power networks, some from start-ups like Arch Rock (whose CTO David Culler is co-chair of Roll); others from majors like Sun, plus some universities and public bodies. Cisco has no product of its own to offer, but wants to ensure the sensor sector adopts the same IP standards as the enterprise networking market, to support cross-over applications. Most sensor standards work focuses on ZigBee, to some extent Bluetooth, and proprietary offerings like Zensys Z-Wave, though a few start-ups are also pursuing low power Wi-Fi.