Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 October 2012

UK gets LTE in GSM band, other countries look further down the spectrum

UK regulator Ofcom has been holding peace talks this week and appears to have found a way to appease Vodafone and Telefonica O2, angry at recent 4G decisions, and to accelerate the pace of LTE roll-out.

The UK has lagged behind other major European countries in auctioning new LTE spectrum after a series of delays and legal challenges. It recently allowed the largest cellco, Everything Everywhere, to start deploying LTE in refarmed 1.8GHz GSM spectrum, giving it a headstart on Vodafone and O2, whose own 2G spectrum is in 900MHz (regarded as currently less viable for repurposing). The smallest player, 3UK, has also won 1.8GHz spectrum since EE had to transfer some of its own holdings as a condition of its merger (as a joint venture between T-Mobile UK and Orange UK).

The fury of Vodafone and O2 at the market advantage they said Ofcom had handed to EE threatened to derail the plan, which is important to the government’s aim of kickstarting mobile broadband expansion especially to support rural high speed access. Now Ofcom has informed culture secretary Maria Miller that it has ″found a way of speeding up the 4G auction process″, which would narrow the headstart of EE, allowing its rivals to launch in mid-2013 (assuming they acquire licences in the sale of 2.6GHz and 800MHz spectrum).

According to the BBC, this would appear to involve getting the 800MHz band ‘ the most desirable for first-wave roll-out because of its coverage capabilities ‘ cleared of current incumbents more rapidly. Operators had not expected it to be fully ready for use until late 2013.

There are also suggestions that the regulator may attempt to bring forward the auction itself by a few weeks. All of that would reduce EE’s period of 4G exclusivity from a possible 18 months to about six months, which is expected to be sufficient to head off legal action by Vodafone and O2. Those two carriers had agreed not to take such action for a month while talks were held with Ofcom, but that deadline expired this week.

The tactic seems to have worked, since a day after the news of the compromise deal filtered out, EE said it would go live with its first services on October 30. It will cover 16 cities by the end of this year and 98% of the population by 2014.

Analysts at CCS Insight said in a research note: ‘The freeing up of spectrum for 4G some five months earlier than previously planned is positive news for Vodafone, O2 and 3 as they will now be in a position to launch in spring 2013. This is great news for the UK, as consumers will sooner be able to benefit from a more competitive market for 4G services. However, the agreement slashes EE’s first mover advantage and means it will need to work much harder and be more aggressive in its roll-out and marketing if it’s going to capitalize on its period of exclusivity. Yesterday’s developments not only bring to an end years of wrangling and argument over the schedule to award 4G licences in the UK, but it also means any prospect of litigation or appeal to delay the process has been kept at bay.’

Beyond the UK, the most important aspect of the situation is that it highlights the increasing urgency with which operators and regulators are seeking to roll out LTE, in any spectrum they can get their hands on. With virgin 2.6GHz and attractive 800MHz not yet available in the UK, EE joined the rising tide of cellcos refarming 1.8GHz frequencies. And despite Vodafone’s arguments that its own GSM spectrum in the UK, at 900MHz, lacked the device ecosystem to be refarmed for mobile broadband at this point, it has gone ahead with an HSPA roll-out in the band at its Greek subsidiary.

Although fewer carriers are refarming 900MHz than 1.8GHz, there is rising interest, and some commercial initiatives in the Middle East focused on LTE. Although 900MHz was expected to be repurposed mainly to add to 3G coverage, that used to be the case for 1.8GHz too ‘ but in fact, many cellcos see the benefits of leaping straight to LTE, even in rural areas, for its greater spectral efficiency and lower overall costs.

All sub-1GHz spectrum is of interest for first wave 4G deployments because it supports broad coverage at affordable cost, and good indoor penetration ‘ capacity can then be added where required with smaller cells in higher frequencies, as well as indoor femtocells. The main drawback for 900MHz at the current time is a shortage of mainstream devices, but this will change as more carriers show interest, spurring handset makers to support the frequency.

Even lower down the spectrum is 450MHz, and even this is now being eyed for LTE. The CDMA Development Group has recently identified this band as one of the remaining growth areas for its technology, but CDMA450 will only be appealing to carriers outside of niche ultra-rural scenarios if there is an eventual migration path to LTE. The CDG is sure that this will materialize because of the race to secure more LTE spectrum, especially below 1GHz.

Some cellcos in northern and eastern Europe have deployed CDMA ‘ the only mainstream technology which has seriously targeted 450MHz ‘ once they turned off the old analog NMT services which used to occupy the frequency. The world’s last NMT network was switched off in June, in Poland, leaving its operator Orange with the country’s only 450MHz licence. It repurposed the spectrum for CDMA and, according to CDG, gained a twelvefold increase in 3G coverage compared to 1.8GHz or 2.1GHz, the usual 3G bands in Europe. This enabled it to expand coverage to 90% of the huge geography of Poland, where 40% live in rural areas.

Citing figures from Alcatel-Lucent, the CDG says that a CDMA450 network requires one-third the number of base stations to a similar deployment at 850MHz and African CDMA450 networks are profitable on ARPUs of less than $5.

Based on such experience, the CDG is now working on a specification for LTE450 using non-contiguous spectrum. It says there is strong interest from operators in Brazil, as well as Sky Link, the Russian CDMA450 player.

Joe Lawrence, VP of marketing for the CDG, said 2011 saw the launch of ‘over a dozen’ new CDMA networks, the majority of which are using 450MHz spectrum. New markets coming online in 2012 include eastern European countries such as Georgia and Serbia. ‘I think CDMA will always continue to be a very significant force in the industry. We have 331 networks, in 121 countries. That’s a sizeable business,’ he said.