Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2006

UK low power auction highlights race for enterprise indoor networks

The greatest weakness of GSM networks and their successors has been indoor penetration, and this has been a factor in the interest in dual-mode Wi-Fi/cellular solutions. Apart from the obvious benefit of lower, flat rate voice calls when in range of a signal, using unlicensed spectrum, there has also been the availability of cheap indoor access points. This has heightened the focus on systems for enterprises or commercial hotspots, that allow Wi-Fi voice to be used indoors, with the user falling back to the cellular network when out of range. A new option being opened up in the UK points to the way that all-GSM platforms could bite back against the encroachment of dual-mode, and give operators without a cellular license or partnership a route into the business sector.

UK regulator Ofcom is preparing to auction seven to 12 low power spectrum licenses that could support low cost GSM with improved indoor performance plus the superior cost efficiency of GSM voice compared to VoIP. It will open up spectrum in the the 1781.7-1785MHz and 1876.7-1880MHz bands (formerly reserved as a GSM/DECT guard band), with a low reserve price of £50,000 per license that would bring the licenses in reach of start-ups. However, some bigger names are interested in sidelining the likes of BT Fusion, the incumbent’s Wi-Fi/cellular converged service, using the new bands, including NTL.

Cable and content provider NTL has joined forces with vendor ip.access to use low power GSM for fixed-mobile convergence solutions. ip.access, a subsidiary of TTP, makes the smallest available GSM pico base station, the NanoNTS, and says this product’s output power matches the proposed EIRP (equivalent isotropically radiated power) limit of 23dBm per carrier in the UK license. The picocells can be backhauled by any IP network and connect to the corporate PBX exchange. The base station is built around handset technology and can use power over Ethernet instead of a separate power supply, making it highly cost effective even compared to Wi-Fi.

Although Ofcom says the licenses will be technology and application neutral, the most obvious uses will be to offer GSM services to make the mobile phone into an office extension when the employee enters the building, reducing the voice load on the Wi-Fi network. Similarly, such low cost voice hotspots could be implemented in public venues such as cafes or in homes.

The system will pose a challenge to Wi-Fi because GSM is already optimized for voice. The quality of calls will thus be better, and there will be no need to change to existing GSM phones. Far more important than the positioning of the various technologies, however, is the fact that are is an increasing range of options for using a small base station ‘ whether Wi-Fi, GSM, or even future WiMAX and W-CDMA picostations ‘ for improved indoor coverage and for linking the mobile phone to the wireline network.

While the various base station technologies may fight it out, the handset makers should be winners either way, whether enterprises focus on all-cellular systems or dual-mode. Nokia has been the most aggressive phonemaker in the quest to make the cellphone the only telephone in the enterprise, not only boosting sales but increasing its central role in corporate communications strategies.

‘Our target is to make the Nokia enterprise mobile device the de facto corporate telephone,’ said Jaakko Olkkonen, general manager for voice solutions, last year, recognizing that converging all voice calls in one cellular handset will be a major step forward in the Finnish giant’s overall strategy of establishing its mobile platforms as the key enterprise client environment of the future, indoors as well as on the road.

Both Nokia and Motorola ‘ with Alcatel, the key partner in BT Fusion ‘ know that such projects could raise the corporate profile and sales levels of their devices, as well as enabling them to open up a new range of channels and partners for their phones, from wireline operators to enterprise integrators, thus reducing their dependence on the cellcos.

Nokia has extended partnerships with Avaya and OnRelay, and is working with Cisco and IBM, to ‘marry the best of fixed and mobile telephony for service providers’. The Finnish giant has worked with Avaya on an enterprise handset that will work over WLans and, when out of range of an access point, over cellular connections. It is also licensing Cisco technology to integrate Series 60 handsets with Cisco CallManager for Wi-Fi and IBM, as systems integrator, will offer the combined Cisco/Nokia/OnRelay platform for companies looking to make the cellphone an integral part of the corporate PBX system.

Nokia could also look at producing, or partnering with a specialist in, picostations for an all-cellular alternative. One chip designer that has made significant progress recently in shrinking advanced wireless technologies down to the indoor level has been PicoChip, with its femtocell 3G/HSDPA base station reference design for use in home or small offices, which the company said could be an alternative to Wi-Fi and Unlicensed Mobile Access (UMA), with the benefit of using existing handsets.

‘Cellular operators realize they need to counter the threat of competition from those gearing up to offer UMA or voice over Wi-Fi,’ said Rupert Baines, vice president of marketing.

The interest in enterprise indoor systems should ensure that Ofcom gains far more than £50,000 per license for its new spectrum, though this may also serve to disadvantage start-ups. However, there could be up to 12 licenses, with no company allowed to bid for more than one, so some new competition is expected. An initial plan to offer only five licenses was angrily received, since it would probably lead to the new frequencies falling to the four mobile operators and BT, with no room for alternative operators, some of them with new applications and approaches.

As it is currently structured, each bidder has to say how much they would be prepared to pay, depending on how many licenses are made available (from 7 to 12). The amount bid by each candidate will fall the higher the number of licenses there are, of course. With only NTL showing its hand so far, not all the bidders may be focused mainly on corporates. There are also opportunities to add efficient, high quality voice services, using GSM, to Wi-Fi hotspots and metrozones, an option that could attract a large UK hotspot operator such as The Cloud. Such a system would reduce congestion on the Wi-Fi link by offloading voice and support additional revenue streams from users with GSM handsets rather than WLan laptops ‘ especially in areas such as shopping malls or large transport stations where cellular coverage is traditionally poor.

Indeed, ip.access could score here too, since it already has a deal with metrozone mesh vendor BelAir Networks to integrate their two technologies, backhauling the NanoBTS devices with BelAir mesh and offering a combination of Wi-Fi data and GSM voice services in one urban area.

BOX: Radioframe

One of the most innovative companies focused on indoor enterprise convergence is Radioframe Networks, which is backed by, among others, wireless super-entrepreneur Craig McCaw and whose major customer is Nextel. Radioframe recently introduced its S-Series of picocell and femtocell base stations for running GSM and GPRS over IP, providing indoor access and integration with Wi-Fi. This joins its existing MC-Series of microcells, which was initially conceived for the Nextel iDEN network but can also be adapted to most wireless platforms.

RadioFrame’s core base station is technology agnostic, and operators deploy different RadioBlades depending on they type of network they run or configuration they are trying to achieve. Nextel for instance, only used iDEN radio blades, but it could install Wi-Fi blades, GSM or CDMA blades alongside and in future WiMAX and others will be supported.

The MC-Series and S-Series have a software-controlled design based on a Layer 2, packet-based architecture with Ethernet control of low power radios. It provides an Ethernet-connected base chassis unit with interfaces to the Lan, internet, cellular network and so on. It places multiple, low powered radios at the network edge and manages them as a unified platform. The base chassis connects to a Network Chassis Unit, which supports integration with the PBX and wired data networks, and an Airlink Chassis Unit, which provides wireless processing for up to eight RadioFrame Units. These units contain up to seven RadioBlades or transceivers, each of which can support a different wireless standard. These convert all traffic into Ethernet packets and so apply Ethernet functions such as quality of service.