The major US CDMA carriers have led the world in embracing the VoIP support included in the latest iteration of the platform, EV-DO Rev A. This at first seemed puzzling, since delivering voice over IP is hugely less efficient than using the circuit switching of the cellular networks, and so the operators could be seen to be giving away their key advantage over their IP-based challengers. But the shift towards fixed/mobile convergence and complex alliances with wireline and emerging carriers makes sense of the strategy, which is accelerating the cellcos’ upgrades of their networks and enabling them, for the first time, to become one of the most advanced groups of mobile operators in the world.
Sprint highlights and leads the trend with its far-reaching venture with four of the major cablecos to provide a fixed/mobile triple play in 2008. Much of the attention has focused on which IP technology it will use for a brand new network in its national 2.5GHz spectrum, but it is also working hard to brush its existing cellular networks into shape for convergence. It said last week that it will offer commercial services on EV-DO Rev A from the first quarter of 2007, bringing the important addition of QoS for VoIP. There are two reasons why Sprint is so interested in this ‘ the immediate need to migrate users of the iDEN network it inherited with Nextel, and the need to offer integrated services with the cablecos even before the 2.5GHz network is widespread.
The telco has said it will not rush to phase out iDEN, but clearly the aim is to migrate users as quickly as possible to a new generation network based on CDMA and IP. This may not be a rapid shift ‘ Cingular only this month said it would turn off its original TDMA network at last ‘ but it will be helped by the tendency of iDEN users to be oriented around advanced services such as push to talk, and the network’s strong showing in enterprise markets. This base should be a natural one, Sprint argues, to move to the data-rich applications supported by the 3.1Mbps IP/EV-DO combination, and to help things along, it has commissioned a dual-mode iDEN/CDMA handset from the Nextel network’s creator, Motorola. Sprint aims to cover 190m people with Rev A by the end of this year, ready for commercial launch at the turn of the year, under its Power Vision brand. This figure will reach 220m in the third quarter of 2007.
Wireless VoIP will also aid integration with the cablecos, which have been focusing considerable efforts on combining their own technologies with IP services. Verizon has similar pressures around converging its DSL services with those of its cellular joint venture Verizon Wireless, which plans to roll out EV-DO Rev A in an even shorter timeframe than Sprint.
The attractions of Rev A are not just about VoIP but the broader issue of IP-oriented QoS, which is key to the network’s claim to be a true broadband wireless platform like WiMAX or Flarion, capable of delivering highly differentiated, multi-tier applications. The equivalent in the GSM world is TD-CDMA, backed by IPWireless, which also supports packet-based transmission and IP QoS over cellular frequencies. Both these technologies aim to appeal to cellular operators on the basis of offering a WiMAX-like performance without the need for an entirely different network, and both are being considered by Sprint for its 2.5GHz roll-out, as well as WiMAX, Wi-Bro and Flash-OFDM. IPWireless argues that its platform will offer 2.5GHz broadband IP performance immediately and then a seamless migration to the successor to current 3G, LTE (Long Term Evolution), which will be far more WiMAX-like anyway with its reliance on OFDM and smart antennas. Similarly ‘ and with far greater vendor backing, notably from Lucent and Nortel ‘ Rev A says it offers a software upgrade for existing CDMA operators that will provide a smooth route towards the all-IP networks of the future. That cellcos should take this claim seriously is critical to CDMA’s creator Qualcomm, which risks its major operator base moving away from CDMA as IP opens up their network choices.
Key to the case for Rev A is that operators will be able to prioritize different users and applications, enabling tiered services and multiple pricing options for more flexible models and to derive greater value from the network. Operators also can make additional security enhancements by using authentication mechanisms that can identify users and give specific access rights based on the user’s profile.
Meanwhile, Cingular is also stepping up its own 3G-plus efforts, solidifying its position as the world’s most advanced deployer of HSDPA. It launched commercial services, under the BroadbandConnect banner, in 16 cities in December, based on PC cards only (from Sierra and Novatel) and subsequently added two handsets, from Samsung and LG. It plans to cover the top 100 markets by the end of 2006.
As well as allowing Cingular to launch new services such as its video clips-on-demand offering, HSDPA gives it lower operating costs, with the carrier claiming a fully loaded HSDPA network delivers voice 40% more cheaply, in terms of cell sites and core network, than GSM. Capacity is a far bigger issue for US cellcos than their European counterparts, which are only just testing the commercial HSDPA waters. Cingular’s average customer uses 600-700 minutes a month, compared to 200 minutes, Europe’s average. This has driven Cingular ahead of Europe in the use of adaptive multirate (AMR) voice codec technology, a GSM standard which allows the vocoder speed to be changed on the network to keep up with capacity. It also plans to field test the next software update to the W-CDMA network, HSUPA, which addresses uplink speed, later this year.
With the big three forging ahead with advanced networks and services, where does this leave T-Mobile USA? The (distant) fourth ranked cellco has achieved high ratings recently for customer service and this has helped drive strong subscriber growth, but it has no 3G yet and so risks losing premium users to its rivals. Its main obstacle is lack of national spectrum, especially since the Cingular-AT&T Wireless merge cost it a sharing deal with the latter. It has recently signed extensive roaming agreements with regional carriers, which have greatly boosted its coverage, but it remains highly dependent on gaining significant 3G spectrum in the forthcoming FCC auctions for the 1710-1755MHz band, paired with 2110-2155MHz. This auction is expected to raise $10bn-$15bn and will take place this summer.
At the start of this year, T-Mobile extended the reach of its network by 56%, mainly through roaming deals in 850MHz that put the carrier on more competitive footing and marked a shift from its historic 1.9GHz-only platform. Most of the increase in footprint has been in the West, Midwest and rural Northeast through partnerships with carriers such as Alltel, Cingular, Centennial Communications, Dobson Communications, Edge Wireless and Rural Cellular. This has added more than 500,000 square miles of coverage.
The carrier has also turned on about 3,500 new towers of its own during the past year. Many analysts believe T-Mobile USA will go further and look to roll up a series of regional GSM carriers such as Dobson, Centennial, Suncom and Rural Cellular, which have significant 850MHz holdings.
But for a viable 3G-plus strategy, it will need to do well in the summer auction, and hope the prices are in a range acceptable to its parent Deutsche Telekom. If it gains sufficient spectrum, it is likely to turn its lateness into the 3G market to advantage by moving directly to HSDPA rather than implementing a two-stage roll-out. If it fails in the auction, the company says it will find ‘alternative strategies’ for delivering advanced services, which could include combining its Wi-Fi hotspot network with gaining spectrum or a network partner for WiMAX, and then seeking to buy the 700MHz spectrum to be auctioned in 2008 or 2009.
T-Mobile USA generates 40% of Deutsche Telekom’s global mobile revenue and has over 25% of its total subscriber base, with 22m US users. It added 1.4m subscribers in the fourth quarter, and 4.4m in the past year (half of T-Mobile’s total outside Germany) with monthly ARPU at $52. A national HSDPA roll-out, including spectrum costs, is likely to cost around $10bn.