Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 December 2020

US MNO marketing strategies are shaped by spectrum patchwork

The USA is a useful microcosm for the world since between them the big three operators – T-Mobile, Verizon and AT&T – are covering most of the strategic bases shaped by their differing spectral profiles. Their marketing campaigns have been shoehorned accordingly, geared more to the exigencies of their offerings than balanced technical or even commercial assessments. At least though some of the mudslinging draws out some relevant aspects of 5G evolution and deployment.

T-Mobile, as we have discussed in recent works, has been particularly dismissive of Verizon’s emphasis on its Ultra-Wide Band (UWB) service based on mmWave spectrum. TMO has not denied UWB can reach colossal bit rates approaching 1Gbps if you are lucky, but takes pleasure in highlighting its lack of coverage, available to the average roaming consumer just 0.6% of the time, according to the web speed test service Ookla.

Verizon retorts such criticisms are irrelevant because its mmWave deployment is tackling areas of high density where capacity had come under strain. The operator has pointed out it can now accommodate up to onem connected devices per square kilometer (2.5m per square mile), about 10 times the number LTE reached. It predicts this number will go on rising towards 10m, or a 100-fold improvement, over the lifecycle of 5G. That has been cited as a target for 6G but that is likely to emerge from 5G more organically even than has happened with preceding generations.

Verizon also likes to claim that it is getting more out of mmWave than it had anticipated, by harnessing reflections and trajectories through urban canyons as constructively as possible. Without firm data this is rather speculative, but it is true that Verizon has demonstrated that Integrated Access Backhaul (IAB) over mmWave can work to accelerate deployment by avoiding need for fiber, without jeopardizing reliability, in a pilot with Ericsson.

This all seems to point towards a multilayered 5G strategy for Verizon, which is precisely what T-Mobile has been preaching, being after in line with how the technology has evolved in three distinct classes of spectrum. The difference lies in the balance and emphasis between the layers.

Verizon has been led by its shortage of midband spectrum into a two-layered approach, with those mmWave hotspots fleshed out largely by its 4G network, relying on DSS (dynamic spectrum sharing) to introduce 5G with flexible allocation between the two based on demand.

This is largely why T-Mobile has been dissing DSS lately after earlier advocating its use as a way of introducing 5G over a wide coverage area. T-Mobile’s President of Technology Neville Ray has been citing problems with overhead resulting from DSS reducing the total amount of capacity available, as well as impairing performance slightly, but this may not be as decisive as the operator makes out. It is more a stick with which to beat Verizon.

In any case Verizon has already acted to address its midband deficit, having in September 2020 spent $1.9bn for 5G spectrum in the 3.55-365 GHz band, about double that of Dish Network , which came in second in that FCC auction with $912m. That spectrum is not yet ready for deployment and we expect Verizon will change its tune as it starts rolling out its own third mid band 5G layer in 2021.

As for AT&T, it began advocating mmWave much like Verizon, but has downplayed that side lately while taking more of a middle line with its focus initially on national coverage using DSS, which attracted criticisms that this was not really 5G in the light of disappointing benchmarks. But like Verizon it had been outflanked by T-Mobile in the midband as a result of the latter’s acquisition of Sprint, and decided to adopt an approach rather like some sports teams by trying to influence the referee.

In this case, AT&T started piling pressure on the FCC in September 2020 by complaining that the combination of Sprint and T-Mobile has resulted in an “unprecedented concentration of spectrum in the hands of one carrier”. It went on to state that “the combined company exceeds the Commission’s spectrum screen, often by a wide margin, in Cellular Market Areas (CMAs) representing 82 %  of the US population, including all major markets. This level of concentration requires much more transparency into how the Commission evaluates transactions (and auction applications) involving spectrum aggregation in excess of the screen.”

That spectrum screen AT&T was referring to was cobbled up by the FCC some years ago as a marker for determining whether a single carrier’s spectrum holding was sufficient to damage competition. In the event of that level being exceeded, the carrier concerned can be forced to divest some of that spectrum.

That was never on the cards here, which is why the referee analogy comes into play. AT&T’s intention was to raise consciousness over the issue at the FCC ahead of the C band auction coming up this month, where 500 MHz of midband spectrum between 3.7-4.2 GHz is being auctioned. As we reported recently that auction has attracted a long list of potential buyers, and it will be interesting to see how the big three fare.