Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 September 2007

Verizon challenges 700MHz open access rule in court

After the heated debate surrounding rules for the US 700MHz spectrum auction, scheduled for January, there was a surprising calm when the FCC actually announced the rules, including the key requirement that open access should be mandated in 22MHz, or one-third, of the band, a concession to the internet lobby whose battle against cellco walled gardens have been mainly vocalized by Google. Before the rules were published, AT&T and Verizon Wireless both backed away from outright hostility to the open access clause, presumably in order to discourage the FCC from giving in to even more of the Google demands. But it now seems that was just the lull before the storm, with Verizon Wireless taking the regulator to court last week to challenge the open access ruling, raising fears of a lengthy dispute that could delay the auction of the most desirable spectrum to become available in the US for years.

Verizon Wireless mounted its challenge in a federal appeals court, the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, claiming the FCC ruling ‘violates the US Constitution, violates the Administrative Procedures Act ‘ and is arbitrary, capricious, unsupported by the substantial evidence and otherwise contrary to law.’ The filing comes ahead of petitions for reconsideration of the 700MHz ruling, due later this month.

‘The nation’s spectrum airwaves are not the birthright of any one company. They are a unique and valuable public resource that belong to all Americans. The FCC’s auction rules are designed to allow US consumers’for the first time’to use their handsets with any network they desire, and download and use the lawful software applications of their choice,’ said Richard Whitt, Washington telecom and media counsel for Google.

Google had pledged to bid the reserve price of $4.6bn for the 22MHz if all its open network demands were met, but since the FCC only met it halfway, it is uncertain whether the search giant will bid for spectrum directly, in order to wholesale to innovative carriers. Other internet companies that are rumoured to be interested in making a bid include Microsoft, Intel and Apple.

Potentially complicating the 700MHz litigation is the unsettled state of a separate lawsuit seeking to overturn the results of last year’s AWS auction.