Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2013

Verizon could deploy first LTE-Broadcast system next year

There have been many attempts to come up with a commercially viable mobile TV system, but successive attempts such as DVB-H and Qualcomm’s MediaFLO have failed to gain ground, largely because they required their own spectrum, networks and handsets. The latest hope for providing TV services to mobile gadgets is centered on LTE-Broadcast, which Verizon CEO Lowell McAdam says it will deploy in time to ‘broadcast’ the Super Bowl in 2014.

Among the big name vendors, Ericsson has been the most active in this field, though Huawei recently announced the opening of an innovation center in Shenzhen, China, focused on LTE-Broadcast. This is based on the enhanced MBMS standard, included in 3GPP R9 and enhanced since, and uses existing network capacity, so that specially adapted devices are not required. Verizon demonstrated LTE Broadcast at CES in collaboration with Ericsson and Qualcomm,plus apps and content from MobiTV, Media Excel and Thompson Video Networks.

LTE-Broadcast supports multicasting of video, audio and even data to many users at once rather than using the on-demand unicast approach which underpins most mobile media. Therefore it makes more efficient use of spectrum capacity as well as being part of the main LTE standard, creating a readymade device ecosystem. MediaFLO, the US broadcast industry’s Dyle, and various DVB-H initiatives, were all squeezed into a niche, or failed altogether, because of shortage of mainstream devices. However, eMBMS will be supported in LTE device silicon and in the RANs as standard, only requiring adjustments to the core.

However, multicasting only comes into its own when many users are viewing the same content. This is why some carriers are considering using it only for certain mass events, such as Super Bowl, or for venues where a high%age of people are likely to stream the same items, as in airports or sports grounds. Mobile operators could even lease their capacity back to free-to-air broadcasters if they want to put their TV channels over the cellular signal, and leave it to those broadcasters to pay for it out of increased advertising potential. Subscriptions would go the same way for pay-TV operators, and that way the cellcos take no risks at all.

According to research by iGR, quoted in the GigaOM blog, cellcos are increasingly interestesd in an approach which will have its own guaranteed ecosystem, but no carrier actually admitted to firm roll-out plans. However, they are discussing ideas ‘ for instance, some carriers could offer services in which users subscribed to particular programs via apps like HBO Go. The LTE-Broadcast network would schedule the download of the shows at a set time to all the devices requesting them, with the gadgets caching them for future viewing. And LTE-Broadcast does not have to be confined to TV ‘ it could also be used for other multimedia content like magazines and radio, and also to schedule over-the-air services such as software updates or company file distribution.

The iGR white paper says video will account for 71% of mobile data traffic by 2016, but LTE-Broadcast could reduce the capacity strain on networks by 12.5% in a metro market, rising to 15% at peak times. The service could also offload 30% of the total mobile data network traffic attributed to audio and 45% during peak hours in 2016. Ultimately, it could offload up to 11.5% of the total daily demand per subscriber and 14.7% during the peak hours. “For the U.S. mobile operators, the amount of network capacity built in 2016 could be reduced by 9.8% if LTE Broadcast were deployed, equivalent to an overall potential saving of $4.21bn,” said iGR. That could mean savings of $60m to $100m per year from 2016, for the large US carriers.

However, it will remain only an adjunct to unicast, to support certain content, locations or times of day. More important will be ways to make unicast video more forgiving on the network, through a range of techniques such as caching, offloading and compression.

The difficulty has been designing a software layer for the base station that effectively grabs the same piece of spectrum for an event like a football match, in each of the neighboring cells, and coordinates its use. Effectively cellular operators want a system that scales from the very first person who tunes into a TV channel, which would be delivered as unicast stream. As more people request the same channel, initially this means more unicast streams are set running. But after about 10 such requests the base station decides to turn this into a single multicast system – it combines all the unicasts into one broadcast and tells the phones to shift to it. When neighboring cell sites experience the same demand they all coordinate and use the same spectrum, and then the cellular system behaves as a single frequency network where each base station boosts the robustness of an identical signal with the same timing.

There are those who think that full broadcast standards like DVB-NGH (Next Generation Handheld) can also be part of this, and that there can be broadcast TV across a country, multicast TV in one or a handful of base stations, and unicast to everyone else, with each TV channel finding its appropriate level. In fact there is one movement in France that says that the two protocols can be merged. In other words the modulation on the signals in eMBMS can be identical to those in the broadcast. While the two camps use different spectrum, you might look for a channel on the cellular offering of TV channels, and it may notice that this channel is also broadcasting on a nearby piece of UHF spectrum and it can offload the job to that, all done in software. This idea has been backed by Orange, Alcatel, CNES (the French space agency), DiBcom, Mitsubishi, Teamcast, INSA-IETR and Telecom Bretagne.