Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 July 2007

Verizon forces Amp’d to crisis point, but Virgin Mobile plans IPO

The immature state of the US MVNO market is indicated by the wildly different fortunes of the main players, which were thrown into stark relief last week as AMP’d Mobile applied to a bankruptcy judge to sell its assets, while Virgin Mobile updated its IPO plans with an estimated value of $506m.

Virgin Mobile USA – the most successful of the US-based mobile virtual network operators, using Sprint’s network to deliver media- and youth-oriented services ‘ said that
Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch and Bear, Stearns are underwriting its IPO, which follows the £2.2bn offering last summer from its UK counterpart (now part of the Virgin Media group. The US sister company is a joint venture between that group and Sprint Nextel).

The SEC filing reveals that Virgin Mobile USA had 4.57m customers at the end of last year, or about 15% of the prepaid market. This was up 19% over its base at the end of 2005, and as of March 31 2007 it had increased the figure to 4.88m. It accounts for almost one-third of Sprint’s wholesale customer base.

As for revenues, the MVNO totalled $339.3m at the end of March 2007 with operating income of $36.7m for the quarter, and ARPU of $22.54, fairly stable since 2004. Non-voice services make up about 17% of revenue. Total 2006 sales were $1.1bn but the company has never turned a profit, losing $103m in 2005 and $36m last year. It has $531.3m in debt, which it says will reduce, post-IPO, to around $341.3m.

The MVNO will need to increase its data services and counter the pressure on its prepaid base, in order to keep its market share and ARPU on track. This is likely to lead to an extension of its Sprint deal to include the future WiMAX and EV-DO Rev B networks ‘ indeed, since Sprint is a joint venture partner rather than purely a wholesaler in this case, Virgin may well be the first to gain access to premium facilities.

Meanwhile, Amp’d Mobile continues to pursue its transition from operator to mobile entertainment provider, from within the protection of Chapter 11 (see Wireless Watch June 11 2007). It has asked a bankruptcy court judge for permission to sell its assets at auction as soon as possible, a decision that should be made this week, and said it has received inquiries from possible buyers. The announcement follows the company’s failure to obtain debtor-in-possession financing, which could have carried it through bankruptcy. The assets in question include its inventory of handsets and accessories as well as studio equipment, office equipment and copyrighted content.

The crisis has been partly precipitated by the request by Verizon Wireless, whose network Amp’d used for its content-oriented offerings, to be allowed to shut off service to Amp’d customers. Verizon said in its claim to the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware that maintaining Amp’d service costs it $370,000 a day. By Monday, Amp’d said it expects to only have about $9,000 in cash.

Given Verizon Wireless’ request, Amp’d said its ‘ability to continue to operate was suddenly at risk’ and the company ‘determined that it was in the best interest of the estate and its creditors to sell all or substantially all of its assets in a court supervised auction process’.

The Amp’d issue also hit Verizon Wireless in its second quarter, with the decline in the wholesale base, largely Amp’d-related, offsetting strong growth in retail net additions. While gaining 1.6m net new retail subscribers, its total including wholesale was only 1.3m. Of the 300,000 customers Verizon Wireless lost from resellers during the second quarter, about 175,000 were due to the carrier writing off Amp’d’s customer base, according to a research note from Cowen. Other losses were down to churn at other MVNOs such as Tracfone Wireless. Verizon Wireless is far less exposed than Sprint, the pioneer of the MVNO model in the US, since only about 2.2m subscribers in a base of 62.1m are wholesale.

‘We view Verizon’s low exposure to wholesalers ‘ as a positive relative to its competitors, particularly since the demise of ESPN’s MVNO and the bankruptcy of Amp’d suggests the MVNO model is not viable,’ said the Cowen note. While the Virgin Mobile experience may suggest otherwise, the current developments will certainly make cellcos more risk-averse when selecting MVNO partners.